Confusion about violas being perennials or annuals??

gardenfanatic2003

20 years ago

I got some violas in the "Annual" section of the garden center. The tag just said "viola mix" so I have no idea which kind they are. They have small dark purple flowers with a little yellow dot in the center and are about 8 inches tall. I'm a little confused about whether or not violas are perennial. I've read they are perennial, they are annual, they are self-seeding. If they are self-seeding annuals, I would assume mulching around them would prevent them from self seeding?

Does scent or lack of, indicate which type they are?

I've grown some Penny Lane Mix violas from seed this spring. They were in the perennial section of the seed catalog, but all the stores seem to have violas in the annual section. Does anyone know if Penny Lane violas are annual or perennial? Thanks,

Deanna

Featured Answer

membertom

20 years ago

Deanna,
I think of the violas (the pansy-like ones -- not the species violets) as winter annuals. I plant them in the fall and expect them not to survive the summer heat. In this group, I would include the 'Penny Lane' and 'Sorbet' violas. I know that sometimes they are regarded as perennials. For me, however, they have always been very short-lived perennials -- usually not making it past one year, and never past two. From what I've read, the (pansy type) species -- Viola cornuta, was used with pansies to produce the violas. Viola cornuta is supposed to be perennial. Sadly, for me it hasn't been so, either. Maybe in the proper climate, Viola cornuta and the violas descended from it, are good perennials. But not for me, in Maryland.
Now as far as self-seeding goes, I've had a lot of that from pansies and violas. As the seed capsule opens and dries, each of its three boat-like pieces pinches down on the seeds, shooting them off in all directions. It's really neat to see or hear. I save seeds by putting capsules in plastic drinking cups with a tissue rubber banded over the top. As they dry, I'll get to hear the occassional "pings" of the seeds being ejected. Makes me think of bullets flying in an old western movie ;o)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

Claire_from_Michigan
19 years ago
I purchased a Viola cornuta "Rebecca" today and the label on it said it is a "perennial" but when I did some reading on it on the web, one site called it an annual, another a perennial... so I'm with you and confused too. It seems to me it depends on what zone you are in. From what I have read, they do not like the heat. So if you are in a warm climate, they probably don't make it through the summer. I'm just concerned that they won't make it through our winters, wondering if I should "cover" them or something??

Here's another site that is informative: http://www.americanvioletsociety.org/Species_N_Cultivars/Viola.htm

Here is a link that might be useful: Northwest Horticulure
Related Discussions
Is Silene Armeria (sweet william catchfly) annual or perennial?
Q
Comments (3)
I love silene. It's a self-seeding annual in zone 5. If you leave them to seed, you will have babies all over the place next year. They will sprout in early spring, sometimes in autumn to winter over. They're easy to weed out where you don't want them, but I let them pop up between plants. I also save some seed each summer just in case they don't return. But they always have. The color is gorgeous.
...See More
what percent of 'annuals' are actually 'perennials'
Q
Comments (18)
Based on what I've seen in the industry since I first got involved in it, the percentage of perennials grown as annuals for the home gardening market grows every year against seed-grown true annuals. Marketing has resulted in a more sophisticated audience and the search went into fast forward for more fodder to throw the hungry masses. A good deal of the new introductions are from 'head-hunters' who are testing the feasibility of using native species from other countries. About a decade ago, we had a lot of introductions of Australian plant material. They may have been tweeked by the breeders, but remained fairly true when introduced to their original state. Many of them were perennial there but not in temperate zones here. Of course a lot of the old standards like were always around and generally were thought of as annuals when they aren't. I have always thought that a disservice was done when seed sources and catalogues for retail sales bent the definitions of annual and perennial to mean 'hardy'. Most of the commercial catalogues will state if stock are tender perennials or hardy/half hardy annuals. That really helps to adjust people's expectations. This is also a bone of contention in box store plant lots where stock is correctly labeled perennial, but sold in areas where it's not hardy. Since they distribute over the whole nation and everything is labeled the same. I'd like to see a 'truth in advertising' label on all seeds and plants. If it's a perennial.......call it that and give the zones where it is. If it's an annual describe if it's half hardy. If it's something else go there too. LOL. As it is, most gardeners end up learning by trial and error and have to look up each plant they may want to consider for bringing inside, to see if it's gonna bloom and die or might survive a winter with protection. The whole shebang is a matter of popular use and it's not going to go away easily. I have no idea of the percentage of 'annuals' who are really perennial in today's market, but I'll take a guess at around thirty percent or better.
...See More
annuals or perennials?
Q
Comments (8)
Of course the plants are either annual or perennial (or biennial!) regardless of where they are grown but everyone has assumed that you mean 'Which ones will come up every year in my garden?'. That probably IS what you mean and I can't answer the question since I live a long way away and have a very different clmate. However, some of the true annuals do work quite well in various climates, adapting their growing and flowering times to local conditions. If your summers are very hot, you would probably need to sow autumn or winter and let them do their thing in spring. They would probably self-sow (reseed?) freely and give you a nice display each year without much input on your part. I particlarly like S algeriensis (syn. maroccana), pretty smoky blue-mauve colours, and S roborowskii, primrose yellow. S viridis (syn S horminum) is grown less for its flowers than the striking coloured bracts at the top of the stems - pink, purple, white. I would avoid S tiliifolia, which has a certain charm despite its tiny flowers, but produces seed by the ton and really is a weed!
...See More
Perennial gardeners what are your favourite ANNUALS in 2020?
Q
Comments (33)
Any annuals I plant in my beds must be colorful, self-sufficient and flower all season. No deadheading, no supplemental watering, no flopping and must be deer/rabbit resistant. That really narrows down my selection. I've found these four fit the requirements and use then liberally: angelonia, melampodium, spreading vinca, lantana, They're all annual in my zone 6. I use plenty of other annuals in pots on my deck where I can give them a little more care and attention (and keep the critters away).
...See More
kymmieann
19 years ago
I bought a few different violas this year Rebecca, Better Days and Etain they are suppose to be perennials. I also have Freckles which is a perennial it came back this year and it also reseeded. Im hoping these varieities above also are perennials.
Heres hoping
~Kymmie
drthor
15 years ago
I have seeded Violas last year. They came up an bloomed very nice. This year, by the end of January, a millions of little Violas are starting to pop up where I seeded them last year and in more areas , even in the expansion joints of my driveway. Definetly a Perennial by seed here in Dallas, TX zone 8.
buyorsell888
15 years ago
I have Viola 'Etain' here that I expected to be annual but was tagged perennial and they are going on their third year. Some are blooming now.
coolplantsguy
15 years ago
This should help a little. Graham Rice from the RHS (I know that's the UK, but it should still apply), in his new book classifies them into the following three groups (note: all are from the genus Viola, despite one of the groups below also being called Viola).

Violet - includes Sweet Violets (V. odorata and its hybrids) which are usually hardy perennials, and the Parma Violets (which are less hardy).

Pansy - includes all forms of V. x wittrockaiana (hybrids of V. altaica, V. lutea, V. tricolor, and other speices). These are mostly annuals and biennials, and grown from seed.

Viola - includes all forms of V. x williamsii (hybrids of V. cornuta with cultivated Pansies) and other plants derived from V. cornuta. These are all mostly perennials, and usually propagated by cuttings. Good examples are the popular 'Etain', 'Rebecca' and the black-flowered 'Molly Sanderson', etc.

Each of these three groups is further divided into sub-groups based on flower form, etc.

Of course, species like V. labradorica, V. cucullata, V. pedata, and V. sororia stand on their own and are perennials.

Good luck.
extragalactic
15 years ago
@ coolplantsguy: Those three main categories are very interesting, since I've always been confused about the similarities/differences among violets/pansies/viola.

More specifically, I'm currently growing indoors from seed "Viola Princess Mix" (from Burpee seed), but I have no idea what species these seeds correspond to. DavesGarden, for example, only gives the genus (Viola) but no species, as does Burpee.

I suspected V. cornuta, but some cultivars look significantly different in images from the Burpee stock pictures -- and many are only hardy to zones 7+, rather than 4-8 quoted for the Burpee seed.

Does anyone know the correct genus+species for Viola 'Princess'?

Here is a link that might be useful: Burpee seed page for Viola Princess Mix (with image)
Henry Z6(OH Zone 6b)
4 months ago
Depends, if you live somewhere where it’s too hot, annual, I’m in zone 6 in NE Ohio in a shaded area, I expect them to survive summer from the shade they get and since our summer temperatures only sometimes exceed 85 degrees

Confusion about violas being perennials or annuals??

membertom

Comments (8)

Claire_from_Michigan

Related Discussions

kymmieann

drthor

buyorsell888

coolplantsguy

extragalactic

Henry Z6(OH Zone 6b)

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US