Purchasing Online versus Local Plants

16 years ago

Hi Everyone,

I am researching the above topic and I was wondering if anyone in the forum would mind giving me their input by answering the following 8 general questions.

1. Do you believe you get the same quality of plants online as you do locally?

2. Where do you get a better selection Â and why?

3. Have you ever purchased from one of the following:

Gurneys, Nature Hills, Spring Hill Nursery, Park Seed, Flower World USA, Molbaks, or Home Depot?

4. If so what was your experience?

5. Would you purchase from them again?

6. Overall, do you have a preference between online or local for purchasing your plants; and if so, why?

7. Do you go to one place for all your plants, or do you go to different places depending on what you are looking for?

8. Do you have a favorite online source, if so what is it Â and what makes it stand out so that it has become your favorite?

Thank you for the time youÂve taken to help me with this project for my English class.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

marlingardener
16 years ago
Glad to be of help. Good luck with your project.
1.Generally, the plants we buy locally are bigger and more adapted to our climate--a big consideration in Texas.
2.Of course there is a better selection on-line. No nursery can carry the hundreds of plants available on-line, nor should they.
3. I have bought from Gurney's, Spring Hill, and Home Depot.
4.I was dissatisfied with Gurney's--plants arrived in poor condition and some didn't survive. I haven't ordered plants from them for several years. Spring Hill was all right--haven't ordered recently because I have found better alternatives. Home Depot I only buy plants that I know. Customers pick up a tag, read it and stick it in the wrong container, and the staff is not knowledgeable about plants.
5. From Home Depot, yes. Not from Guerney's nor Spring Hill.
6. I prefer local. The money stays in the community, the plants are adapted to the Texas climate, the nursery staff are usually knowledgeable about the plants they sell, and if I have a question later, I know who to call.
7. If a place has a plant, I'll stop and probably buy it! I shop all over three counties and have a favorite rose nursery and a favorite tree supplier.
8.No favorite for plants, although I love PineTree Seeds because they offer a great variety of seeds in amounts handy for the home gardener, and also have a very informative web site.
mekales
16 years ago
I've replied to several of this same question... I think in general we are SO wow'd by the pretty pictures in on-line and paper catalogs, that we become over enthusiastic about buying "sight unseen".
1. I've rarely received plants via the mailbox that compare with those offered by local growers!
2. The selection offered in the local greenhouses are the plants that they know grow well in your local climate. The cataloga are vague and general when giving hardiness and growth conditions. They don't care that the plant USUALLY dies in zone 5 - and there is no official control of these hardiness numbers. Micro-climate also dictates the actual hardiness as well.
3. See above - and if you buy NEW deliveries at the Big-Box stores, you may be in good shape. The problem lies in that they don't "care" about the plants they sell... JUST SELL AS MANY AS YOU CAN! (I worked for a big-box) - the point is that they dont' care about fugus-fly or white fly infestations and if the plants are in their yard for more than a day or two, they are stressed and usually mass soaked or not watered at all. When they look bad, they just dispose of them!
4. Yes, miserable poor little stressed out plants! Again, a great point for a locally owned businesses. They take pride in what they are selling being tagged correctly and that the plants are properly tended daily!
5. Never wasting money on mailbox orders again!
6. 1-5 abaove!!!
7. Once I had built a relationship with my local greenhouse, I was able to learn their ordering process. I tell them what I'm looking for, they watch their availability lists and can usually find what I am looking for. Sometimes it may take a couple of weeks because their growers are not offering something specific, but I've been able to find 99% through them. Agian, they know I'm a good customer and that I LOVE my plants!
8. I've come to use on-line as only a resource. If I find something I WANT (never NEED any of it!) I talk to Brenda or Jim at the local greenhouse and they can tell me the pros and cons to the plant - and ususally find it if I can't live without it! They LOVE the plants they sell - they LOVE that I LOVE the plants they sell! It's not just another flat or another pot of merchanidse to them like it is at Big-Box or mailbox businesses.
I hope everyone can find a local independent greenhouse like we have here in Bedford, MI We are lucky! I guess not everyone has this kind of business in there area! Go find one! It's worth it!
Happy Gardening!
Related Discussions
Buying plants thru online suppliers vs. big box or local stands
Q
Comments (16)
Hi, I started buying my stuff online because I worried about the diseases and "pests" I would end up with when buying Big Box Store plants. They may be high quality to start with, but then they are transported and come into contact with any number of other plants and produce, which can cause cross contamination. I always ended up with those little nasty gnat things in my houseplants and then had to buy stuff to get rid of them. The other aspect is that most of these big box stores will not have any kind of guarantee on the plants. You can take them home, plant them and have them die overnight and you will not be reimbursed for them. That being said, I also had my share of disappointments online (I NEVER had good luck with catalogs at all). But...I've found a good place, with decent prices, a satisfaction guarantee and the best customer service anywhere. They even have a Master Gardener on staff to ask questions of and an extensive blog section (Latest News) with all kinds of pertinent information dating clear back to 2008 (I think!). I won't buy anywhere else now...unless I get too late a start and just want to plop something in the ground and hope for the best :) Hope this helps! Here is a link that might be useful: THE Best Garden Supply Ever!
...See More
Buying locally vs online
Q
Comments (11)
I guess it depends on what you want. If you don't really care...for instance, just want 'yellow' daffodils, then buying locally is probably fine. Most local sources from big box stores to local nurseries (around here) sell mixes...which is what you get, anyway. Very seldom do you get a correct named variety. I collect daffodils, so it matters to me. After years of buying, I am very picky. I joined a local daffodil society and am making my third order with them. Very pleased... they procure bulbs from specialty growers around the world. Btw, now is a great time to be thinking of what you might want to plant (in the fall). I always order now...and then the bulbs arrive at the right time in fall. Remember for the little bulbs, like crocus, glory of the snow and scilla that you'll need a bunch to make a show. You'll be so glad (next spring) that you spent a bit time (and $$) thinking about this now. I love spring! Have a look, if you want, at some of my daffodils now blooming at the link below...the mids are blooming now with still the lates to come. I am always looking to add more lates because I want to the show to go on and on... Take care now....Happy Spring! Here is a link that might be useful: Scroll down to see some daffodils now in bloom...
...See More
Do you buy locally or mostly online?
Q
Comments (28)
I buy mostly online. The local nurseries carry only the usual, well-known, or whatever J&P and Weeks carries. I'd like to support the local nurseries, but their prices have gone up so much, that it's actually often cheaper to buy online even with shipping charges. And buying their potted roses, you get the fertilizers that they use to promote the growth and blooms. The most popular nursery here feeds their roses with sulfate of ammonia, and the roses are big and beautiful, but they almost always die once I get them repotted or planted in the ground. And the other local nursery doesn't take very good care of the roses, and pots them up in those 2gal peat pots, and they end up looking like crap by mid-season and full of disease. Ordering roses online you get better selection, and can often find the unusual and hard-to-get varieties that local nurseries just can't get. I order from many sources. Heirloom, Hortico, Regans, Edmunds, Rosemania, Roses Unlimited, Vintage Gardens, Sequoia Nursery, Rogue Valley Roses, Pickering, Wisconsin Roses, Almost Heaven Roses, Ashdown, Chamblees, Palatine, Jackson & Perkins, Northland Rosarium, Nor'East, Bridges, Moore's Roses.... I also do buy from the local "big box" stores when they get the packaged bareroots in winter and the potted roses in spring. They often have some interesting roses. And I find it sort of fun even with the cheapie bareroots that sometimes are mismarked. But, I am getting to where this may be the last big hoorah for ordering or buying roses for me. I am definitely out of room!!!
...See More
2016 Seeds & Plants on Sale, Locally? Online Catalog Sales?
Q
Comments (42)
I'm interpreting this line of email to mean the scratch and dent sale starts on Monday "Super Bargains For those of you who wait for our "scratch and dent" specials, the super bargain sale starts on Monday, September 5th. Here is a list of the specials and their prices. " The 30% off sale "continues" and the email dated Friday says specials "this week" which I assume meant starting Friday. They were set up at the house where she was English and he was from New England. The garden was a series of rooms. The sale plants were in the front yard. The garden descriptions for August are gone off the Open Days website. I think it might have been the one in VT. I think I meant to visit Rocky Dale when we also visited the nursery in northern VT that was semi-retiring. We did an overnight plus some other things and never got to Rocky Dale. Last year we were quite close when we went on the barn tour that included Warren.
...See More
hairmetal4ever
15 years ago
Most local nurseries are touch and go - you can have excellent quality stock or very poor or anywhere in between, and this is whether you're talking a mom and pop or a Home Depot.

The biggest negative to buying locally is you almost always have trouble finding a tree that's not a Callery Pear, Japanese Maple, or Red Delicious apple - in other words, selection.

That's where I venture online.

Purchasing Online versus Local Plants

Comments (3)

marlingardener

mekales

Related Discussions

hairmetal4ever

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US