Urgent! Is this canning method a major botulism risk?

12 years ago

I have a friend who is canning hot peppers and giving them away as gifts, but I'm not sure they are safe to eat.

He slices the fresh peppers (jalapenos) and packs them into jars with some chopped onion and some dried oregano.

He then heats (but not to boiling) a solution of cider vinegar, sugar and salt, and pours that into the jars of peppers. The reason given for not boiling is to avoid burning the sugar in the mixture.

He boils the lids, then puts them on. That's it.

Is this safe?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

esox07 (4b) Wisconsin
12 years ago
It is probably as safe as opening a jar of peppers that were canned correctly and leaving it in the fridge. If he is not refrigerating them, then I would say he is asking for trouble.
Bruce
2ajsmama
12 years ago
The vinegar should be boiling - it won't burn the sugar. If he's getting it close to boiling (not just warm) it may be OK but jars should be processed in boiling water.

*IF* he's using straight vinegar, then they're probably OK to open and stick in the fridge even a couple of days after they were made. Even if they never sealed (better that way - botulism needs low-oxygen environment). I don't know if I'd keep them on the shelf - certainly not long-tern.

If he's mixing vinegar and water without following an approved recipe (at least half vinegar, depending on how tightly the slices are packed and how much onion - which is very watery), warming it just enough to dissolve the sugar, and not processing the jars (but they seal b/c it's hot enough to do that - called "open kettle" method), then I wouldn't touch them, not even to put in the fridge, since botulism can grow to toxic levels within 48 hours.

If they never seal, then botulism shouldn't grow, but other yucky things can if not enough vinegar and/or not heat processed.

Really, if he wants to keep making these, he should use approved recipes including processing times. Here is a very useful site

Here is a link that might be useful: NCHFP
Related Discussions
Using a pH meter and lowest pH to kill botulism
Q
Comments (65)
Should have posted this sooner but here is a reply I got back from an inquiry - Thank you for your interest in the National Center for Home Food Preservation. Regarding your question: (My sent message) Background, I am a home food preservationist with an extensive history of home sausage making (both with hot ((refrigeration required)) and some cold smoking ((humidity and temperature controlled to produce country cured sausage, no refrigeration required)), home canning (pressure canning only, I do not trust water bath under any circumstances) and extensive dehydrating experience. I have done a little pickling under the recommendations that the USDA has out in regards to fish and hardboiled eggs (including the need for refrigeration). However in my research into historic preservation techniques I have found references to pickling (especially) fish preserved at room temperature. The references also stated that the vinegar solution used at the time was homemade and was of strength higher then the present 5% available for modern commercial sales. Given that botulism spores growth is inhibited at a PH of 4.6 and they can not therefore produce the toxins, the fact that! a 10% or 15% acetic acid can be readily produced using food safe glacial acetic acid (99.85% available commercially mixed in proper ratio with water (yes, acid to water, I remember basic chemistry) and the PH of the 10% solution is approximately 2.4 and given that 1.5â x 1.5â x 0.75â pieces of fish would readily equalize PH is this theoretically a safe preservation method. Please do not give me the standard rely of not recommended or approved due to lack of experimental data etc. brush off, I am just looking for a theoretical answer. (The reply) This is Elizabeth Andress, Director of the National Center. I personally apologize for not getting back to you sooner, but we have been trying to keep up with people needing help with more standardized recommendations and methods of preserving. I can tell you that under the circumstances you describe with the low pH environments, that theoretically botulism spore germination and toxin production does not seem likely. But that is indeed as much as I can say. You would want to make sure the fish pieces get below pH 4.6 throughout fairly quickly to keep it longer at room temperature (probably at least within 24 hours). It is not a brushoff but a fact that no one here has any practical experience with pickling fish at room temperature (or for that matter, at any temperature). We do not have USDA pickling or smoking for fish on our website or in the USDA canning guide, but there is information from Oregon State University we have shared on smoking fish. I have pretty much relied on contacts in Alaska, or formerly in Oregon, for issues related to smoking and pickling of fish. You also might find an actual food microbiologist actively researching with bacteria at Univ. of Wisconsin who knows more in detail of C. bot. patterns. Thank you, Elizabeth Andress
...See More
Botulism in flavoured oils, honey and vinegars?
Q
Comments (11)
1) Different sources can't always be expected to agree. :) 2) This is, as mentioned at the beginning of the discussion, a controversial topic since it is only borderline safe at best. So disagreement is to be expected. 3) My interpretation of the Oregon document (linked below) is that they actually do agree for the most part. As an extension I would expect them to use the NCHFP guidelines. The issues are just stated differently and so cannot be taken out of context. There are exceptions and limitations included throughout the document. 4) The primary issue is fresh vs. dried foods being added. Using dried herbs and spices - no problem IF one can be assured of it being fully dried. Human error is invited - How would you know? How would you test moisture content? What is fully dried garlic to one is still 10-15% moisture content to another. Thus risk survives. 5) Using fresh ingredients and IF fresh foods are used ALL of it MUST be filtered out. Filtering ALL of it out invites human error once again. How does one know ALL has been removed, that none remains? Microscopic examination? So, given the potentially lethal level of risk and to eliminate the role of human error as much as possible, freezing or limited 3 week refrigeration is the guideline. No shelf storage. And IMO, certainly no gift giving of flavored oils. You have no control over how long they would keep it or store/use it. Accept the risk for yourself if flavored oil is so important to you. Do NOT pass that risk on to others. Hope this helps but the bottom line with flavored oils is it is risky, not worth the risk to most, and not recommended. Dave Here is a link that might be useful: Oregon Ext. on Flavored Oils
...See More
Is water bath method or pressure can necessary for tomatoes?
Q
Comments (6)
For home use and canning, USDA rules is not enforced. If you mean there are no canning police who will come and arrest you then yes, they are not enforced. However liability, not to mention responsibility, does attach to any home canned foods that are shared with others. fill the jar, tighten the lid, then place them upside down, ...how the heck bacteria is going to get into it ? It doesn't have to "get in". It is already in there. So is the air still trapped in the jar that allows the bacteria in the jar to continue to grow, reproduce, and produce toxins. The only foods where inversion sealing is still commonly practiced anywhere is with highly acidic foods - fruit jams and jellies, canned fruits, and brined pickles. Tomatoes do not quality as highly acidic foods since they are borderline pH at 4.5-4.8. If you cannot kill a bacterium by boiling, forget about canning and eating tomato sauce. There are many bacteria, including c.botulinum, that cannot be killed by boiling but that doesn't mean the food cannot be canned. Those bacteria are killed only by irradiation (which isn't possible at home) or by high pressure temps in excess of 240 degrees for a period of time determined by the density of the food in question. Alternatively they are packed in an highly acidic medium which prevents the bacteria from reproducing in the jar. Thus the requirement to add additional acid to tomatoes when canning them. None of this is new info. It dates from research begun back in the 1950's. And it is all discussed in great detail on the Harvest forum for those interested. But I would suggest some research into all the science behind the canning guidelines before sharing such mis-leading information with others. It does them a dis-service otherwise. Dave
...See More
Used canning jars and botulism
Q
Comments (14)
I'm a "bad Master Food Preserver" and Master Food Volunteer. I was taught in both courses the need to boil low-acid foods is still a precautionary measure suggested for "foods not canned according to the recommendations in this publication [Complete Guide to Home Canning] or not canned according to other USDA-endorsed recommendations". Even though the Ball Blue Book follows the USDA standards for their recipes, they don't cover the safety of foods that are NOT canned in Ball/Kerr jars - as it states the the Ball Blue Book (which few people doing home canning read, or realize there is the disclaimer). I still suggest it for all new home canners and older home canners as well; because they all tend to "go-off-the-reservation" when it comes to using tested recipes. If you get in the habit of boiling low-acid food, you won't have to remember was this Aunt LulaBelle's untested recipe, or was this a USDA tested recipe? Was it in a Kerr/Ball jar or a recycled mayo jar? Or as a cover-your-backside because your pressure canner isn't working properly. Home canned foods don't get better with age like wine and cheese. Between harvesting and canning the foods begin losing their vitamins. As much as half of them if it isn't properly stored in a refrigerator before canning. The heating process destroys from 1/3 to 1/2 of vitamins A and C, thiamin, and riboflavin. Once in storage (depending on the temperature of storage) additional losses of those sensitive vitamins are from 5-20% PER YEAR. Old canned goods are more often than not perfectly safe to consume. Although the jar being seal proves nothing other than the jar is sealed, not that there isn't any botulism toxin- another mistake people make. And as already pointed out the color, texture and flavor alter over time - more so on some foods than others. But maybe it's only me - the health nut talking - why would anyone want to consume "dead" food with so little nutrition in it. It's a waste of energy to boil it for 10 minutes - where it loses even more nutrition. But then, I'm a thinker, not a risk taker. I'm inclined to be over cautious when I teach classes - dot all the i's and cross all the t's kinda gal. I want canning mistakes to fall squarely on the home canner, not me as an instructor because I left out the part about boiling low-acid foods. -Grainlady
...See More
User
12 years ago
botulism risk, who knows.

Based on your description, your friend is using an untested recipe and not even meeting an "old method" standard for canning, open kettle method where jars were filled with boiling liquid and capped to seal without processing in a BWB (boiling water bath).

At the very least, your friend risks making people sick from any number of pathogens that may thrive in a shelf stored jar. They should give them away ASAP after topping and instruct people to refrigerate and consume within a week.

Bill
Tunneler
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks, all.

He is not telling people to refrigerate. He seems to think this is an acceptable method for canning, then storing long-term on pantry shelves.

He probably does clean the jars beforehand, but not sure if he boils them.

I am really worried but he is the kind of person who "knows it all" and won't listen.
User
12 years ago
Tunneler,

Don't make yourself crazy, some people will not listen to reason or admit they didn't know. The best you can do is point your friend to the link ajsmama provided and warning anyone you know who received the jars about the risk.

Bill

ps. I've admired your green island home from across the channel for years while vacationing on SMX. Next trip I'm definitely heading over!
rockguy
12 years ago
You could warn him that his house, car etc are at risk here if he makes someone sick and they sue....
PrestonFarmer
12 years ago
Is your friend named Dr Kavorkian? I wouldn't eat that if it were more than a week old. I'm actually pretty brave, doing my own fermentation and all, but that sounds pretty dangerous to me unless he's packing them to the top to eliminate the air and allowing them to ferment. Doesn't sound like it though.

Urgent! Is this canning method a major botulism risk?

Comments (7)

esox07 (4b) Wisconsin

2ajsmama

Related Discussions

User

Tunneler
Original Author

User

rockguy

PrestonFarmer

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Urgent! Is this canning method a major botulism risk?

Comments (7)

esox07 (4b) Wisconsin

2ajsmama

Related Discussions

User

TunnelerOriginal Author

User

rockguy

PrestonFarmer

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Tunneler
Original Author