Houzz Logo Print
fredsbog

Threatened and endangered species Recovery Act

21 years ago

Our local radio station has been advertising that there is a bill to HELP threatened and endangered species recover. It's called the Threatened and Endangered species Recovery Act - TESRA - Here's a link to the web site that has been advertised on the radio here.

http://www.saveourspeciesalliance.org/

I thought since only one local station is advertising I'd spread the word across gardenweb to rally support!

Comments (26)

  • 21 years ago

    hmmmm...interesting to say the least. Looking at the list of supporters raises a big red flag. Many are those who have historically claimed to be "burdened" by the ESA....forestry, agriculture, petroleum, mining, water districts, realtors, homebuilders, off road businesses and utilitiy interests, to name a few.
    While I agree that the ESA has some flaws and has at times been used to list species inappropriately, not sure that this is for the best either.

  • 21 years ago

    By "recovery" they mean "ending all that annoying restriction for industry". It's just more of this double-speak that the administration always uses--when they want to allow more logging in forests, they call it the "Healthy Forests Initiative", when they want to let factories pollute more they call it the "Clear Skies" bill, etc. With the Bush administration, always assume that they mean the opposite of what they say.

    In this case, it's quite simple--they start from a fact, that the ESA isn't accomplishing its goals as well as it should, and then propose to "solve" this problem by gutting the ESA and making sure it never has a chance to accomplish its goals.

    Patrick Alexander

  • Related Discussions

    Canary Island Date Palms ravaged by non-native beetle

    Q

    Comments (1)
    oops, wrong forum, meant for palms forum
    ...See More

    Wild Endangered Plants

    Q

    Comments (19)
    Hey KWOODS As per any country (this one included) alot of good and bad happend and happens. That is past now and hopefully the country will start progressing forward and not sink. I personally agree 100% with the decision to put such a fence up, reason being that it pretty much cured the issue of fence jumping. Nowdays when its "more humane" and give a little shock people literally steal the fencing and walk on through. As bad as some things were, many people in other countries infact dont know the history of what actually happend and only rely on CNN which is a dangerous thing. As I said to start with, the US has an horrific history, as does Spain and many other countries, with the bad though there is always things and decisions that that were actually a pretty good idea for the saftey of the country and its people. Thata all Im going to say on that one. Cheers Sheldon
    ...See More

    Canary Island Date Palms ravaged by non-native beetle

    Q

    Comments (1)
    bummer.
    ...See More

    I'm a Seed Snatcher 2

    Q

    Comments (150)
    OMG! I never thought there were so many of us out there! I thought I was alone with this bug. It started two years ago on a trip to Florida. I picked up seeds off a small palm at a factory outlet. Came home to my zone 5a and germinated the seeds. They all germinated and I became the father of 30 beautiful Washingtonia Filifera. I guess I must have caught the disease when I picked up the seeds. Well ever since then, It's been all downhill for me. Needless to say that this year's trip to Universal and Disney was nothing short of a carnage. I came home with 4 ziplock sandwich bags full of seeds. If your looking for a cure, don't go there, I tried to look away, to walk past the seed pods dangling in my face. They were all over; up down, right ,left. Dodging one seed made me trip on two. I was outnumbered. I so understand you, my fellow seed snatchers, when you talk about the looks, the stares, the comments and wise remarks we occasionally get. Well to all these people passing comments and judgment I say: Oh for God's sake. Get a life! It used to bother me but now I've accepted myself. I am SeedLova and I'm a seed snatcher please accept me in spite of what I am. If I never find a cure, then the world will only be a greener place. To all you fellow seed snatchers, I now officially join your ranks. PS. No joke, Univeral and Disney is like a candy store for a seen snatcher!
    ...See More
  • 21 years ago

    Well said, Patrick.
    Most military installations will be applauding this as well-the DoD has the most T&E species in their care on land in "Public Trust". Or should I say, had?

  • 21 years ago

    This group seems to be about commercial interests and profits. When they say "save our species" I think they are referring to a particular species of environmental rapists.

    Gutting the ESA will do little to save threatened or endangered species.

  • 21 years ago

    A nice quote on this from Brock Evans:

    "Q: I saw a press release recently from a group called Save Our Species Alliance. The group claims that the ivory-billed woodpecker recovered all on its own with "no federal assistance of any kind." According to the group, this proves that the Endangered Species Act is ineffective and needs to be "modernized." What is your reaction to this statement and what do you know about this group?

    A: This is such an ill-informed, may I say bogus, claim that it almost defies belief. As pointed out above, the ivory-billed woodpecker was found in its small bit of remaining habitat - the swamp forests of the Cache Refuge. It wasn't found and couldn't ever be found in the flat soybean fields which USED to be their forest habitat too.

    Ivory-bills need special places - "habitats" - to find food, reproduce, and have shelter, just like humans and just like every other species of plant or animal on this planet. River bottom swamp forests are their required habitat, not concrete or soybean fields. If creating the federal Refuge 30+ years ago, and then protecting its habitat, isn't "government assistance" without which the woodpecker couldn't be saved, well I don't know what is!

    I have never heard of the "Save Our Species Alliance" before now. It sounds like just another of the developer- or industry-funded front groups out there whose real purpose is to gut or totally repeal the Endangered Species Act. Such ersatz groups always pick a nice-sounding title, and carefully use words like "modernize," etc. But when you see their real agenda, it is not to "modernize" the ESA, but to render it ineffective and impotent so that it will not protect any more species or their habitats. Once the ESA is thus weakened, the developers who fund these groups can proceed with all kinds of habitat-destroying activities, even if the wildlife will be thus exterminated.

    These groups are very careful to use environmental-sounding names and slogans because they know that the American people support better, not weaker, protections for endangered species. The Endangered Species Act is a great, very effective, and noble law as it now stands. If anything, it should be strengthened, not weakened as these front groups desire."

    Here is a link that might be useful: the whole article

  • 21 years ago

    Apologies all! I should have known. After reading back over the site I decided to attempt to read the actual legislation. Looks like we may as well scrap the Endangered Species Act if this passes.

    It is all VERY misleading, and I fell for it without doing my homework!

    I was duped, sorry! I posted this message last night, it must have got lost in cyberspace.

    Here's a link to the actual legislation:

    Here is a link that might be useful: TESRA legislation

  • 21 years ago

    No need to apologize. It is hard to know when an organization actually exists, has goals in keeping with the stated purposes and doesn't exist simply for self-serving reasons.

    We saw this in the 2000 elections when John McCain's primary bid was torpedoed by misleading, negative ads filled with half-truths run by a group supposedly called "Republicans for Clean Air." This "environmental group" proved to be fictitious, consisting of Sam Wyly and his brother, billionaires from Texas, heavy political contributors to McCain's rival.

    This "group," The Save Our Species Alliance, for all I can learn from the website, may be one person. The director, the only individual whose name I could see, was a PR man for Georgia Pacific, is an executive for a lobbying firm and has worked to promote Bush's so-called "Healthy Forests Initiative."

    So don't feel bad. It's easy to be scammed by people with the money to set up front organizations, purchase broadcast time and promote a hidden agenda under the guise of a noble cause.

  • 21 years ago

    The bill has passed in Congress and will now go to the Senate.It is designed to replace the Endangered Species act from 1973.Which was Passed almost unanimously in both houses. Apparently public sentiment is more appathetic towards the environmental issues now than we were thirty years ago.
    I hope that all of us who care will make an effort to
    keep this bill from becoming law.
    The present administration has shown itself to be willing to sacrifice the future to promote its interests.

  • 21 years ago

    If you feel strongly about this you can always send your senator an email or letter and let them know you are concerned. The bill in the house was sponsored by Richard Pombo who is a California congressman, rancher and developer. It had the full backing of the bush administration.

  • 21 years ago

    When does this come up for vote? I couldn't figure that out.

  • 21 years ago

    It's currently in committee (Enviornment and Public Works) in the senate.
    HR3824

  • 21 years ago

    Pombo is also attempting to gut our national park system - NPCA just sent out an action alert.

  • 21 years ago

    Since I am barely computer literate I am not the one to do this, but isnt there a simple way to inform all users of all the Garden Web Forums and other web based forums of this travesty.
    I feel that enough people do care and would rally if they were aware of what is going on, and how to make their voice heard.
    It seems that the majority of media is controlled by the powers that promote legislation such as this and so will not attempt to inform us of what is really going down.

  • 21 years ago

    Rudy,

    There are sites out there that send email alerts about issues like this to people who have signed up for them.

    Here's one, and I've put another on the link field:

    http://www.nwf.org, National Wildlife Federation

    When I see something like this in the newspaper or from an email alert, and I want to see if it's been posted, I think I'm most likely to see it on the Bird Watching Forum. For this particular issue, I saw a posting on the Wildlife Gardening Forum and didn't check for it on the Bird Watching Forum. Since that's where Elly hangs out the most, I'm sure it's there. In the past I'd be most likely to post something like this on the Wildlife Gardening Forum. I'll try to remember to post or at least link to another post here also.

    I had thought I had received no email alert on this issue, but looking back at my inbox, it looks like the National Wildlife Federation did send me one.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Union of Concerned Scientists

  • 21 years ago

    To get a better understanding of the double talk, check out:

    www.luntzspeak.com

  • 21 years ago

    I received an alert from Audubon.org on this. They're requesting people reach legislators and the taskforce with comments by November 23rd.

    BTW, my intentions to post about this type of thing were good, but I must admit, that when I've gotten too busy I'm just not doing it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: National Environmental Policy Act. Comments needed by 11/23

  • 21 years ago

    If people really cared about the environment we would not have Bush in the white house or a majority of republicans in both houses of conress.

    I think of this thread as similar to the ANWAR thread. The time to vote for the environment is when YOU go to the poles. ANWAR and ESA were decided in the last few elections by the american people.

    And is sad.

  • 21 years ago

    I understand that the election results were disappointing, but I don't think that people should give up on trying to do anything until we have people elected that see the environment as a priority. If there's a reasonable chance that making the effort does help, I'm hoping people will do it. These alerts IÂve signed up for make doing something relatively painless.

    IÂve read that the administration is losing a large part of its support, and this aided in getting some legislators to vote against the party in terms of the Artic Refuge drilling. I've also read that there are segments of the politically conservative that care about the environment, and are making this a priority. IÂm of the opinion that if we wait to prevent global until thereÂs a new administration to slow global warming, weÂre definitely waited too long (if we havenÂt already). Some people say thereÂs not enough proof that people are responsible for global warmingÂmy take on this is to compare the consequences of not acting if we are responsible versus the consequences of acting if we are.

  • 21 years ago

    "If people really cared about the environment we would not have Bush..."

    That attitude - the tying of environmental issues to a particular party or political viewpoint - is really the problem, and part of what helps to marginalize them. The left takes environmental support for granted, the right, no matter how the individual candidates feel themselves, have nothing to gain by supporting issues that're labeled "left side only".

    So what are us poor voters to do? I'd like to support candidates that're concerned about environmental issues, but because of that tie-in to the left, the ones who do are mostly those whose other positions are even more detestable than those of the Bush crowd. So I'm stuck weighing the environment against too damned many other things.

  • 21 years ago

    You have twisted my comments. I agree it doesnt matter what party a politician is from as an indicator of how they are going to vote on environmental protections.

    However, the current administration prooved their environmental record in the first term, yet was re-elected. Which tells me that most americans don't consider the environment a priority.

  • 21 years ago

    I think there are many people out there who tend towards the right wing, AND care about the environment.

    What IÂd love to see happen is concern about the environment and wildlife become an issue that would differentiate the conservative politicians from each other. Maybe if people make enough noise about this, the politicians will realize itÂll give them an edge. I think it may even be happening a bit already.

  • 21 years ago

    "Which tells me that most americans don't consider the environment a priority."

    Not necessarily. What it proves is that most people either aren't one-issue voters, or if they are, their issue isn't the environment. Would you vote for a candidate with a strong environmental record, if his/her positions on just about every other issue were completely at odds with yours?

  • 20 years ago

    Do you think the current administrations attitude towards environmental issues sort of represents their attitude toward other issues?
    It seems that some of the decisions they make and the positions they take tend to be short sighted.
    They are willing to sacrifice clean air and water in order to support the interests/profits of corporate polluters like mining,logging, and manufacturing companies.
    They are willing to disrupt a sensitive environment in the arctic to squeeze out a little more of our precious oil/gas
    to keep the machine humming a few more years.
    They are willing to gamble that the issues of global warming and ozone depletion are caused by something cyclical or something other than our/their actions and will go away by themselves.
    That civil and human rights are less important than their agenda that they tell us is needed to fight the "war on terrorism."
    It seems strange to me that executives of oil companies would have input into making decisionson our nations energy
    policies.
    It feels wrong that Haliburton is making billions of dollars in the Mid East.
    It seems strange that the reasons we were given for invading Iraq turn out to be not true.
    That Colin Powell would bail on this administration after they made him get up at the U.N. and say things that he knew were not facts.
    It feels wrong that the trade balance and deficit are snowballing.
    In short the situation we have now is not sustainable Can not continue indefinately. There will be consequences in the long run.
    The administration is in denial. They spin the truth, they try to scare us into thinking that the boogeyman is waiting around the corner.
    I dont consider myself a Democrat or a Republican. I am an American. Maybe a little more LIBERAL than some.
    I vote for the person with whom I agree the most, or disagree the least...

  • 20 years ago

    Rudy, You hit it right on the head! I agree with what you just posted 100%. I'm not even going to post what I'm thinking about the government as it is right now because I don't want to offend anyone (or get flamed)!

    I did see a wonderful "environmental" bumper sticker the other day:

    SAVE THE PLANET, MORE TREES, LESS BUSH!

  • 20 years ago

    Ditto what Rudy and Fred said.
    Martha

  • 20 years ago

    "Clear Skies" allows more pollution. "Save Our Forests" meant for clear cutting. Lots of people getting fooled here, fred. Don't feel bad, at least you figured it out.

    It is people who who want to bury their heads in the sand that are the problem, not folks who want to discuss issues. Any dissent will be met with denounciation. Remember what Dubya said when he was asked if he ever got used to protesters, "After a while you learn to ignore them".

    Indeed...

    Lets send the industrialists a message they can't ignore in 2008...

Sponsored