Are these native perennials going to be invasive at all?
20 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (12)
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
Related Discussions
Looking for Somewhat Invasive Perennials
Comments (40)Kurchian.... I cringe when I read of someone's desire to replace weeds and grass with invasive plants. I understand the desire to have something grow without care and provide color and interest, but I haven't heard of anyone who has managed to do that yet. :-) Since I have had more than one battle with unwanted invasives over the years and have read many posts on the forums describing other people's exhausting battles with these type of plants, I can hardly think of a situation in which a property would be 'improved' by adding some of these plants. Once you have them on your property, it seems they rarely actually become an asset but instead, they find a way to become a liability not only to you, but sometimes to your neighbors as well. Then when you try to get rid of them...look out. If you have a 'contained' area, like between a street, a driveway and a concrete walkway and a building. That is to say something immovable on every side...this could be considered an area that might be safe to plant some invasives to battle it out and hopefully create an area that might take care of itself. But even then, you still have to be careful what you plant because birds and wind can take the seeds into areas off your property. Mint and Lily of the Valley are two plants I have heard have been known to travel under concrete walkways and show up in the grass on the other side. I had a landscape architect here giving advice once and when I expressed a desire to grow blackberries, he laughed. Since I have a small 1/4 acre property, he suggested that I would need concrete barriers that went down three feet into the ground all around where I was going to plant it, or it would take over our property and be a huge problem to get rid of. Mowing grass and weeds once a week, is a piece of cake compared to battling some of these invasive plants once you have them and they start traveling where you don't want them, or they don't perform the way you want them to and you want to remove them. So...what can you do with this area that you describe as 150 ft from your house, that is about 100ft x 200ft and gets sun until 2pm? Well, it sounds like a great adventure to create something there, but important to know ahead of time what you are getting into. Not quite sure if you are trying to end up with a garden that you would actually care for, or something like a meadow effect? I would start small and try some ideas and see how they do and then duplicate what works out best in other areas. Or start with a complete plan for the whole area, but break it down into smaller parts and go slowly until you get an idea how things are working out. Trees and shrubs are a great idea for a larger area. If you spend some time investigating, you could come up with a list of them that would give you all season color and interest. You might consider trying a small area for a butterfly garden. Many of those plants will colonize in a respectable manner and are native plants that spread and fill in fairly quickly. Joe Pye Weed, Asclepias, Butterfly Bush to name a few. Coneflowers and Rudbeckia with Monarda, Grasses and Sedums can take care of themselves pretty well. The Asclepias will reseed, the Monarda will spread more than any others. If you are careful to add clumping grasses, rather than runners, you can choose anything that appeals to you and add some perennials and instant easy care garden. Cosmos is an annual that in my Massachusetts garden, comes back on it's own every year and is a welcome addition to my sunny garden beds. I don't know if you have ever visited Garden in the Woods, in Framingham, but I highly recommend it. They are always trying to establish plantings that take care of themselves in many different conditions. Not only would you be able to see for yourself what they have been able to achieve, but they sell plants and can give you lots of advice too. Below is a link to one of the threads on this subject that has already been referred to. I see there is also a Part 2 as well, with another 128 posts. [g] Good luck! :-) pm2 Here is a link that might be useful: What do you Wish you never planted?...See MoreWS's what has been your most invasive perennial??
Comments (55)Have had mint, monarda, obedient plant with little to no problems. Campanula punctata reseeds but cute so I remove most of it in spring and leave few clumps. Macleya cordata reseeds, easy to pull. Bishop weed was planted because of my own stupidity- still trying to get rid of it but the bed full of bulbs and perennials so it is pretty hard to remove it completely. Chameleon plant died on me- I wanted it to grow. Petasites japonicus was speading last year with alarming speed- well, got killed this year during recent cold snap- barely found couple survivors and potted them up. Got some running bamboo last year- it is marginally hardy for me......See Moremy treasured natives invasive?
Comments (7)"Invasive" means a plant that's introduced and crowds out natives. So a native, by definition, can't be invasive. That being said, some natives do grow more enthusiastically than others, and in particular circumstances certain plants will crowd out others. Plants are always in competition with each other for light, space, nutrients, water. There's a lot going on that you can't see. Your site may be better adapted to the Solomon's seal than to the jacks because of something in the soil. And vines, in particular, are always prolific because they can't fruit until they get full sun. Sometimes it helps to try to see it from the plant's point of view! There's nothing wrong with moving things around--maybe you need to divide the Solomon's seal (next spring), or maybe you need to try the trilliums in different spots. And I too grow Virginia creeper and need to cut it back throughout the growing season or it would overpower some of my perennials....See MoreNative plants, invasive roots and water pipes
Comments (2)There is a book called 'Grow What Where' which could give you a good idea. I used to have it and lost it with my sister's house fire. I am about to buy it again. It is just lists of Aussie natives that are good for or bad for particular things, like pipes. Book review here: http://farrer.riv.csu.edu.au/ASGAP/APOL2006/oct06-r1.html Cheers Judy...See More- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
- 20 years ago
Related Stories

TREESNative Plant Alternatives to Invasive Common Buckthorn
Learn how to identify and control this aggressive plant, and what to grow in its place
Full Story
GARDENING GUIDESDo You Have This Invasive Plant in Your Yard?
Garlic mustard is spreading across the U.S. Here’s how to spot it and what to do
Full Story
NATIVE PLANTS10 Essential Native Perennials for the Great Lakes and Upper Midwest
These adaptable native plants thrive in a variety of conditions and will provide flowers throughout the season
Full Story
FLOWERSRudbeckia Mania: Go Beyond Black-Eyed Susan in the Garden
Branch out from typical nursery fare, with lesser-known Rudbeckia species that have delightfully unexpected features
Full Story
GARDENING GUIDES15 Native Flowers That Feed Native Bees
These perennials offer superfood to hundreds of bees and are gorgeous in their own right
Full Story
NATIVE PLANTS5 Ways to Keep Your Native Plant Garden Looking Good All Year
It’s all about planning ahead, using sustainable practices and accepting plants as living organisms
Full Story
GARDENING GUIDESGreat Native Plant: Baptisia
Bring beneficial bee pollinators with this drought-tolerant perennial that looks like a shrub and acts like a flower
Full Story
GARDENING FOR BUTTERFLIES3 Ways Native Plants Make Gardening So Much Better
You probably know about the lower maintenance. But native plants' other benefits go far beyond a little less watering and weeding
Full Story
GARDENING GUIDESHow to Find the Right Native Plants for Your Yard
Find plant maps, sale sites and guides that make going native in the garden easier than ever
Full Story
GARDENING GUIDES6 Native Goldenrods Worth a Second Look
Goldenrod gets a bad rap as being aggressive, but these more mannerly choices offer a bunch of benefits
Full Story
joepyeweed