Plowing when wet - how compacted and how to fix?

10 years ago

Maybe I shouldn't post until I go out tomorrow and assess the damage, but we have 1.34" of rain on Tuesday, sleet and snow that night, took a while to melt (at least in shady spots) yesterday, today DH took the tractor out and plowed the back field!

I didn't know that he was going to do it, didn't find out until he came in at about 6:30 as I was leaving to take DD to Easter egg hunt - all he told me when he called at 5:30 was that he was out back - I assumed tearing apart the beaver dam yet again.

So how bad do you think this is, I know wagon trails across the West still show signs of soil compaction 150 years later.

He doesn't even know what he wants to plant there, I'm looking for a place to plant potatoes, was going to try the old hay field since the hay's no good but I know parts of that are too wet.

We haven't had anything planted out there, he'd mow it with the riding lawnmower occasionally, it's near the old orchard. Last fall he had my dad go in with the excavator and pull out all the wild roses (and black raspberries). There used to be wild strawberries in that field/clearing but I haven't seen any the past 2 years.

I can't seem to impress upon DH and Dad that running heavy equipment over the fields and/or working the soil when it's wet results in soil compaction. Just looking to salvage the area now - DH said maybe plant peas to get N up (but we haven't had it tested so I don't know how bad it was, grass looked pretty good to me last summer), I said peas need support, and potatoes don't need much N, he said he could take 2-bottom plow out if I pick up the stones. Maybe we should just sow clover?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

Rio_Grande
10 years ago
As far as the compaction, a good plowing will take care of most issues. Has a lot to do with your soil. A soil test is best but this stuff ain't rocket science. Crops were grown fo a long time before we gained all the knowledge we have today.

We grow in clay loam. Not the best soil.. Compaction is always an issue for us. We run a ripper in the fields at about a 2 inch depth every spring and fall. It helps drain. Remember you really only grow in the top foot ish of soil. A good size plow will turn close to that.

Good luck, relax, have some fun.
2ajsmama
Original Author
10 years ago
He disked it. I didn't think we had more than 1 plow, but he had said he plowed it and not with the 2-bottom.

He swears it wasn't wet but I haven't gotten out there (running to riding lessons and looking for 1801s today). I give up. None of the men in this family discuss anything with me before they do anything on the farm.

DH didn't even tell me he was taking Thurs and Fri off this week - I woke him up yesterday AM and asked if he was going to work. And he didn't tell me when he did a phone interview for a job in TX last year - just announced he had an offer 10 days before school started. DS told him he wanted to finish high school here and that was the end of it (for another couple of years at least).
Related Discussions
Cultivators, Breast Plows, Hand Tillers, Man Pulled Plows
Q
Comments (8)
Those stories are so sweet! I have a tall hill, and I don't think I can get a 200 pound tiller up there. I have a digging fork, shovel, even a 2 and 1/2 pound pick mattock. The soil is soft mostly because I pile leaves on it at the end of the year, if wet, it is soft enough probably for the cultivator, but because it's mostly hardpan, if dry, it's solid. I was just thinking what the best option would be, I see I may be doing it already. I even did the double dig method on one of the 10x10 areas, it grew the worst. I didn't even get a beet out of it, so I guess I'll just do as normal, turning it with a digging fork. Thanks for the advice. I dreamed of the 8 horsepower rear tine for forward and back, it will even cut through tree root, but really it won't make it up the hill. If I can't get 20 gallons of water up there on a wheelbarrow, a tiller won't make it up there. I got the most of 15 gallons, weighing 8 pounds per gallon, 120 pounds, it was a killer, I won't try a plow. I think I'm moving anyways, but wanted to check the options out.
...See More
How do I know if fill is compacted enough?
Q
Comments (8)
I filled in my inground pool in 2006. It had concrete block walls, vermiculite floor and vinyl liner. My friend has a mini excavator and demolished the hole thing and dug up the floor for drainage. We put the walls, perimeter concrete decking, pool pump and filter, some fencing, etc into the hole. We then had 2 huge dumps of unscreened soil brought in then a big dump of screened soil in whing my buddy tilled and leveled along with some lime and milorganite. That was September 2006. I seeded the same day and had lush grass by October. Its now 2010 and I have had zero settling.
...See More
How to fix low starting moisture problem
Q
Comments (9)
I used to wonder why people were pre-wetting their mix before filling the containers. Last year I found out why after I got some potting mix that was bone dry. In previous years the mix I got had the perfect moisture content to use straight out of the bag to fill my containers. It had just enough moisture to allow it soak up the water from top or bottom after I filled and tamped it down in the containers. When peat is too dry and light in color it is very hard to wet it and water runs right off the surface. With mix that is too dry right out of the bag I put it in a large storage tube, spray it with the sink sprayer, then mix it in with a garden cultivator. It is amazing how much water it takes just to get the mix to that darker and slightly damp but still fluffy state that is perfect for filling the containers. I concur that bottom watering is the best way to get them damp now although it will probably take a long time. You can tell by the color change of the mix through the side of the jug when it is wet enough. Also they should feel quite heavy for their size. Top watering is likely to just displace the seeds and then run down the sides again.
...See More
Basement - How to Finish when cinderblock gets wet
Q
Comments (2)
It does depend on how much water is coming through. I'd try to find out why the walls are damp. There are several reasons why water seeps through a basement wall and 90% of the time it's a simple fix where a professional waterproofer is not needed. This is a true statistic...90% of the time, wet basement walls can be corrected by either proper grading around the house or, proper drainage of downspouts (or both!!!). If you have the red gooey when wet clay soil, then some other work may be needed. If you are at a lower end of a hill, you may be susceptable to spring heads which can be easily circumvented. In addition to grading and downspout correction, I would suggest using Drylock from top to bottom. You could then cover the wall with construction plastic and then install the metal studs.
...See More
Rio_Grande
10 years ago
That should of been 2 feet not 2 inches,
myfamilysfarm
10 years ago
My dad used to use a subsoiler every so often to help keep the compaction down. this year unless he disc it several times, it will have 'cloditism, what I my dad called it when he accidently plowed or disc when it was too wet. It may take years to work those clods back out of the fields.

Good luck. Peas really don't need support, just easier to pick if they are. I usually plant 2-3 rows close together and they help to hold each other up, plus more peas per foot.
2ajsmama
Original Author
10 years ago
Yeah, I looked at my seed packets (only 3) and have bush type snow/snap peas. Problem is the deer - and I'm not going to fence that area off this year. So I'm thinking potatoes? Hope the deer won't eat those down to the ground like they would peas or beans.

He didn't disk the whole area - just a strip (10 ft wide? by maybe 100ft long) where they had pulled out the brambles and roses. Thing is, I don't know how much sun it gets b/c of overgrown orchard to the south, woods to the west (very close). Gets some morning/noon sun. I should have taken a shovel (or a piece of rebar if I could find 1) out to test for compaction but it doesn't look like he disked very deeply - though with the excavator running over it last fall it could have been compacted already.

My uncle came out when I was out there, said no to DH's sunflower idea (if there's even enough sun for that), said the bears would be all over them. I didn't think we'd get any sunflower seeds anyway with the birds and squirrels, didn't know bears liked them though.

I thought maybe pumpkins would be fun, we haven't had space to put them before, but need to get soil tested and I'm worried about hauling water back there (it's a pain to haul water to the tomatoes, and these are twice as far and less accessible). I guess if they dry up and die no big deal - DD would be thrilled to get just 1. But will deer ravage those? I know people usually grow them (and corn, etc.) in unfenced fields but usually plant so many they can deal with some losses.

DH likes turnips - what about turnips? Again, don't those need a lot of water so they don't get woody and bitter? Any ideas? The pH is probably about 5, and I don't know how much OM is in the soil since it was all chewed up and turned over (though not too deeply) by the excavator and disk harrow, our soil is sandy and may be compacted, lots of rocks, not sure how deep it is (though I think the big vein of granite is to the south), and no irrigation, morning/early afternoon sun only. Perfect, right ;-)?

Plowing when wet - how compacted and how to fix?

Comments (5)

Rio_Grande

2ajsmama
Original Author

Related Discussions

Rio_Grande

myfamilysfarm

2ajsmama
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Plowing when wet - how compacted and how to fix?

Comments (5)

Rio_Grande

2ajsmamaOriginal Author

Related Discussions

Rio_Grande

myfamilysfarm

2ajsmamaOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

2ajsmama
Original Author

2ajsmama
Original Author