Disappointing runner bean production

10 years ago

I tried some white-flowered runner beans this year, and found most of the flowers did not set beans. I grew Insuk's Wang Kong before and had a high degree of beans set on. I don't know if pollinators don't like white flowers or what is going on. I did see a hummingbird visiting the white flowers, I was afraid they would not. As the season goes on there have been more beans setting on, but not comparable to IWK, which was pretty much my highest yielding pole bean last year. I've realized I am not much for shelly beans anyway, since I like the food value of the pods, and eat even runner beans with pods since I don't mind chewing up the pod and spitting out the fiber. So I don't think I will try white-seeded runner beans again. Otherwise I have been having a very good bean year, except that one trellis set-up has a very large vole population and they have been nipping off all the bean stalks down the row, even after my usual deterrent of wrapping the stems with aluminum foil.:-(

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

drloyd
10 years ago
Hi Nancy,

The hummers do seem to like white runner bean blossoms.

This has been the warmest summer that I can remember and your area is 5-10 degrees F warmer than here. Bond's Orcas Lima barely set pods in the 80 F plus weather here. I have heard that 85 F is about the limit for most runner beans. Insuk's is more suited to hot weather. - Dick
zeedman Zone 5 Wisconsin
10 years ago
My runner beans have been disappointing this year as well. I am growing "Tarahumara Tekomari", which has red or white flowers, and gray seeds. They bloomed early, but would not set pods until we had a brief cool spell. Setting a lot of pods now, though... it helps that the bumblebees are out in force.

Speaking of heat tolerance... it seemed to me that the white-flowered / white-seeded "Gigandes" set a fair amount of pods last year during the warmth of mid-summer. It was a tough year for them, between heat & hail; I am looking forward to growing them again under better conditions.
Related Discussions
Scarlet Runner Beans, opinions needed
Q
Comments (7)
Well, I can't speak for Texas conditions, but they are great plants here in Michigan. It's pretty normal for them not to set a lot, or even hardly any, at first, then they get going later in the season and are productive. Overall yields are lower than P. vulgaris beans, but the flavor is great and I feel it's worth it. Unless you've planted them really thick, you could probably just plant some regular pole beans right in with them and just let them slug it out -- you would most likely end up with some of both kinds yielding in the end.
...See More
Anyone Else disappointed with Lima Production?
Q
Comments (4)
Maria i had very good luck with Dixie Speckled Butter Pea limas this year. Only a four foot row but i have been able to pick a meal every few weeks and they have good flavor. My goal is to have perennial, low maintenance vegetables that produce a continous small harvest and these little beans are perfect for that. The only drawback is that picking from the bush form can be a little tedious, especially if you have a 100' row to pick! i will be slowly experimenting with some pole varieties in the future. There is a lima bean thread on the bean forum with a picture of some Hopi Limas that are absolutely eye-popping, just smothered in fat little pods. You might want to pop over and check it out. Seems like a lot of folks had unusually cold, wet summer weather this year and i think Limas like it warm so yes, hope the sun is stronger next year for you ; ) MN gardener-how different our experiences are! Long beans and cowpeas absolutely decimated by powdery mildew this year in my garden, green beans almost as bad. The limas? Untouched. One of the few pest and disease free crops for me this year.
...See More
Runner beans for hotter climates?
Q
Comments (4)
I feel a little embarrassed! I have just spent the last few HOURS in this forum, and found lots of answers to my questions. Sorry for taking people's time! And what a wonderful forum. Still,if anyone has a brilliant idea for hot weather runners, please let me know. I found a new variety on Thompson and Morgan called Firestorm, which says it is good in hot weather (although what goes by the name of hot weather in Britain is perhaps not that hot!). There was another variety called Aintree which is apparently OK in the heat. I will try them next year. As well as my Hestia bush beans (which I have learned from this forum can probably be cut back and will sprout again), I am also growing the variety I mentioned, called Morocco in Japan. It has white flowers and has set quite a few pods already Ã£ÂÂI have searched for its Latin name but at the moment have drawn a blank. The picture is of the seed packet. When visiting Hokkaido, the northern island, I saw in the market some massive beans that looked just like giant runner bean seeds. I wonder if these are similar to the Wang Kong beans I have just been reading about! I will have to look for them! Ashita
...See More
'Peanut' is a pole bean (NOT a bush or half-runner)
Q
Comments (7)
I grew Red Peanut, here in OK, two seasons ago. It made a compact bush with twining, 3' runners. Upon seeing how they twined I gave them some support, but they did not climb. Perhaps they would have if provided support earlier. I once received seed of a family heirloom bean, from the very family who had raised it for about 40 years. They always grew it as a half runner. But when I gave it support it easily reached 10-12 feet. I greatly prefer to grow it as a pole bean, myself. Penny Rile cowpea is noted for being of less vigorous, vining growth than many other varieties. When I give it support it tops 10'. I grow it both ways. George Tahlequah, OK
...See More
florauk
10 years ago
" .....and eat even runner beans with pods since I don't mind chewing up the pod and spitting out the fiber...."

There really shouldn't be any fibre in a runner bean eaten as a green bean. Either you are leaving them too long before eating or you have a poor cultivar. The beans inside the pods should be barely discernible if you pick them for green beans. At the very most you may need to string them, but the pod itself should not have any tough fibre.
hemnancy
Original Author
10 years ago
That's just it, I like the beans to develop before I pick them, so I do pick them later, and then some are fibrous, but not all. The ones I grew this year tended to be very short, so not very substantial to pick without the seeds developing at all.
seysonn
10 years ago
I don't know if pollinators don't like white flowers or what is going on.
*************************************************************************
peas and beans are self pollinating and do not need insects or anything else. I have heard that some varieties get pollinated before fully opening. although, it is possible that insects may cross pollinate them, but otherwise they do not need insects' help.

I am also in PNW and have planted several Scarlet Runners. Early on they had very few pods but lately they are growing more.

I like their pods at every stage;; as young green and slightly matured shellies. With Shellies you get more bang for the buck. Matured pods are quite long (8" ?) and large and have many large beans.
drloyd
10 years ago
The two issues seem to be temperature and pollination. Too hot, no beans.

Some have bagged blossom clusters to prevent cross pollination. The result was that "some varieties produce some beans" but I do not know if good production of any runner is possible without pollinators.

Here is a link that might be useful: Runner bean pollination

This post was edited by drloyd on Sun, Sep 1, 13 at 11:38
florauk
10 years ago
I guess I'm just not on your wavelength, hemnancy ;-) To me that's like growing apples so you can eat the stalks, pips and cores! Oh, well, they're your beans.

Mine were a disaster this year. They were fine when I went on holiday but when I got back there had been no rain at all and they were just about finished before they started. Worst year ever for runners for me.

Disappointing runner bean production

Comments (7)

drloyd

zeedman Zone 5 Wisconsin

Related Discussions

florauk

hemnancy
Original Author

seysonn

drloyd

florauk

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Disappointing runner bean production

Comments (7)

drloyd

zeedman Zone 5 Wisconsin

Related Discussions

florauk

hemnancyOriginal Author

seysonn

drloyd

florauk

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

hemnancy
Original Author