Dwarf Japanese Maple Damage from snow

9 years ago

We just had a severe snow event last week (5 1/2 ft) now that we have some snow melting our Dwarf Japanese Maple Tree has some severe damage with quite a few major branches snapped off due to the snow which it had not lost it's leaves yet. It is about 17 years old (previous owner planted it) and it survived damage from a major snow fall back in 2001 (5 ft of snow but had no leaves it at the time) which it did bounce back, but this time has occurred much more damage. Is there a way to keep this (meaning how do I trim it for the snapped branches) or is it a lost cause and dig it up and start with a new sapling next spring? I love this tree and would rather save it rather than start with a new tree. Any suggestions?

Featured Answer

mikebotann

9 years ago

I would dig it up and move it. The maple is way too close to the wall. Plant it someplace in the backyard where you can experiment on it with regards to pruning. Give it more room this time. They can easily get 10 feet wide. Prune it as if it had a snow load on it. Start at the bottom and work up and out so you have a thin canopy like a shredded umbrella that won't hold very much snow or ice. Show the trunk, but don't let the trunk get too much sun from the south or it will sunburn.
If you also replace it, do you have enough room in front for it? Can you make room?
They're very nice plants if pruned correctly.
Here's one of mine.
{{gwi:324534}}

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

ally77dano20
Original Author
9 years ago
second picture
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
9 years ago
Impossible to see how much damage occurred with the snowpile still blocking the tree and the leaves still in place. As carefully as you can, remove the snow and gently comb out the remaining leaves. Then, cleanly cut back any torn limbs/stubs to the next growth point. You can then report back with clearer photos or make your own decision as to save or replace. If the tree is very misshapen or the damage severe, you might want to consider replacing. The tree will fill out some but probably not to the same attractiveness or fullness it had before the damage.

Weeping laceleaf maples like yours are frequently prone to snow damage, leaves still in place or not. The dense, layered branching habits of these little trees is just very accommodating to accumulating pies of snow. In areas with heavy snowfalls, you will either need to prune to thin out the canopy or diligently remove the snow as it begins to accumulate to avoid the weight causing damage.
Related Discussions
Damaged Japanese Holly from Fallen Snow
Q
Comments (1)
If the branches are broken you should remove them. If not it is up to you. They may recover somewhat. The plant will recover nicely from even very heavy pruning.
...See More
Dwarf Japanese maple off spring still dwarf?
Q
Comments (1)
Maybe yes, maybe no :-)) Seedling Japanese maples can often show a great deal of variability from the parent tree in terms of habit, leaf color and leaf size. That's why you cannot get named forms (cultivars) from seed. However, a good many times seedlings will resemble the parent tree quite closely. All you can do is wait and see. FWIW, virtually all commercially grown JM's are grafted and the location of the graft (combined with typical habit) is what determines ultimate height. If yours is a weeping form, chances are it will stay relatively short.
...See More
sick dwarf japanese maple?
Q
Comments (1)
Don't worry, it's fine. Alot of different laceleaf cultivars vary in color from spring to summer to fall. Sunlight also plays a big role in how much color change you'll see during the seasons. Sounds like your tree is doing fine, especially since it's putting out its summer flush of growth.
...See More
Japanese Maple winter damage branches - tricks to minimize?
Q
Comments (8)
A certain amount of dieback is to be expected. But this is typically just the odd branch end or smaller twigs here and there. If there is a significant amount of dieback, then it may be the problem is not related to normal growth patterns or weather/cold damage but to some other cultural condition or disease pathogen. Without seeing exactly what kind of damage we are talking about, we are just speculating on a) it is normal or b) the symptom of something more pernicious.
...See More
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
9 years ago
wait until spring ... unless you can get it completely snow free to see what you are doing

cut out all damaged parts ...

post us a pic ... and we can THEN ... tell you how to prune it back into some nice form ...

pruning NEVER killed anything... nature done or man made ...

one thing for sure.. it wont look like it did before... so what ...

there is NEVER a hurry.. with trees ...

if there are parts.. completely broken off.. and you can get them out of there ... w/o doing more damage.. do so ...

ken
ally77dano20
Original Author
9 years ago
Thank you for the replies and advice. My husband was able to clean it up with the advice given and thankfully we had some warm weather to assist. So now it can be seen the real damage but I think it may be saveable? I am worried of insects or infectious diseases getting to it now that it has many open areas on its branches from snapping off from the weight of the snow but I think that will be in the spring time to worry. I have some more pictures to follow this post from different angles. so the question now is: Can it be saved? If so should I prune now or wait till springtime to fix some of the damaged areas so not to have any further issues. Again thank you for your advice Ken and Gardengal48 :)
ally77dano20
Original Author
9 years ago
second picture after clean up
ally77dano20
Original Author
9 years ago
third picture after clean up
ally77dano20
Original Author
9 years ago
fourth picture after clean up
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
9 years ago
Personally, I would replace it. The damage is extensive and the tree will never regain a good form. Unless the tree has a significant attachment for you, I think you would be much happier replacing with a new, well-formed, undamaged choice, Especially if the tree is in a very conspicuous location, like by your entry.

If you do decide to keep this unfortunate little tree, make sure there are clean, almost surgical cuts, reducing the damaged portions to just outside the nearest growth point. The tree is well able to scar over or seal these wounds if properly tidied up to prevent disease or insect infiltration.

But I really don't think it is worth your effort :-(