skip to main content

Plastic vs. Paper bags

13 years ago

I recently attended a conference discussing various aspects of the sustainability. One topic discussed was plastic vs. paper bags. People frequently say paper bags are much more environmentally friendly than plastic bags. Take a look at the process required to produce both plastic bags and paper bags. Both have several advantages and disadvantages. The answer to the debate seems to simply be a matter of opinion. It is interesting to me how people make decisions based on what they have heard rather than what they have learned.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

civilengr3
13 years ago
so what are you saying? They're the same?
prairiemoon2 z6b MA
13 years ago
Maybe neither is better. Both are bad for the environment. What about fabric bags, like canvas? Wouldn't those be sustainable?
Related Discussions
Germinating Seeds inside in Plastic Bag
Q
Comments (1)
Cool. But I'm just kind of wondering where you find rabbits who are timid enough to be scared away by a 6-8-inch seedling.
...See More
Plastic bag or paper bag for seed storage
Q
Comments (25)
The folded paper design I posted earlier, I use only for temporary storage or for mailing seeds. If you are having trouble folding it, it is usually because you do not turn it over as directed in picture #3. For long time storage I use the plastic air tight containers used for diabetic test strip storage. They are a little smaller than the old 35MM film shipping cases. Dr. Norman Deno in his many years of seed experimenting found very little difference in life expectancy between seed at a constant room temperature and that at refrigerator temperature for most seed. Al
...See More
Plastic, paper in bagged mulch -- problem?
Q
Comments (12)
There is a fast growing industry in collecting and composting organic waste, especially food scrap. So bagged compost is not just going to be manure anymore, it's yard trimmings, tree limbs and food scrap. Some contamination is inevitable. Lots of the food scrap haulers use compostable can liners, but not all, so you may find bits of plastic now and then. Plastic itself is merely a nuisance in the garden, not a toxic problem. If you're concerned about what else goes in, keep bugging the producer and ask them what their inputs are.
...See More
Ripen a mango in paper or plastic bag? Other fruits?
Q
Comments (5)
bsbullie Yeah one of my own mangoes. It needs a few day's more. I was about to put it in a paper bag when I started to think, why not just use a common plastic supermarket bag? That's where it is right now. But maybe no bag is needed. Mangoes don't put out ethylene gas the way bananas do. So you do put bananas in a bag to help them ripen I've had mangoes that fell off prematurely. I exposed them to the sun and made some of it sweet and edible. Salvaging something at least
...See More
Demeter
13 years ago
IMO, paper is more sustainable than plastic. Trees regrow; oil doesn't. And paper recycles or composts - most people don't bother to recycle plastic bags, and every one of them that was ever made still exists somewhere.
Maxie007
13 years ago
Yup I agree with demeter. Paper is recyclable and may even come from reforested woods. This means that whenever a tree is cut, another one is planted to replace it.

Here is a link that might be useful: Learn more on reforestation
Tiffany, purpleinopp Z8b Opp, AL
13 years ago
Well you've got to put your trash in something to get it into the garbage can. Sorry, but I like getting "free trash bags" with my purchases. Once in a while I ask for a few paper bags just because they're handy to have around.

Ana - they've been recycling plastic for at least 20 years now, where have you been?
joanie_pomseed
12 years ago
purpleinopp says:
Well you've got to put your trash in something to get it into the garbage can.

http://www.biobagusa.com
http://www.indaco.ca/cgi-bin/commerce.cgi?display=home
http://www.ecosafezerowaste.com

No place I've shopped uses paper bags anymore, but I'd recommend them because if one gets soiled with something unsafe to touch, you can throw it away without it being an ecohazard.

On the other hand, even if the spot is just something harmless like spilled juice, you can't wash paper for recyling...
gunnersm8
12 years ago
brown paper bags are composed of post consumer content. not sure of the percentage.

also, a brown paper bag will decompose in a few years making something better. cant say that about plastic bags.

as far as recycling plastic, yes theyre recycling plastic. however alot of places its difficult to find someone to recycle plastic bags. here in virginia i have to go to a business that takes plastic bags(target is the only one i can think of now). the city wont recycle them. the city wont recycle anything that isnt a plastic bottle. they recently starting allowing the caps. some places are years behind the curve. i had to throw a patio chair in the trash even after arguing with the waste management folks that HDPE is HDPE regardless of what shape it comes in...

silly. and i just realized this thread is a year old. sorry

Related Stories

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING Choosing a Deck: Plastic or Wood?

By Vanessa Brunner

Get the pros and cons of wood, plastic, composite and more decking materials, plus a basic price comparison

MATERIALS A Hard Look at Recycled Plastic for the Home

By Julia Pockett

It's durable and versatile, but processing takes a lot of energy. We sort through the facts on recycled plastic so you can choose wisely

KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS Kitchen Counters: Plastic Laminate Offers Options Aplenty

By Ivon Street Studio

Whatever color or pattern your heart desires, this popular countertop material probably comes in it

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Details: Out-of-Sight Paper Towel Holder

By Mary Jo Bowling

See how some homeowners are clearing the counter of clutter while keeping this necessity close at hand

DECORATING GUIDES Handmade Home: The Paper Pompom

Put your own spin on these fluffy, pretty paper poufs for parties, dinners or year-round décor

ORGANIZING Avoid the Great Paper Pileup

By Bneato Professional Organizing

Don't let unavoidable scraps cause a jam in your paperless system. These easy tips will keep your home office lanes clear

LIFE The Absolute Right Way to Hang Toilet Paper. Maybe

By Mitchell Parker

Find out whether over or under is ahead in our poll and see some unusual roll hangers, shelves and nooks

DECORATING GUIDES DIY: Fluffy White Paper Lantern

By Vanessa Brunner

Recreate this cloud-like light fixture using a surprising secret ingredient

Bean Bags: A Surprising Answer for Chic Comfort

By Shawn Gauthier

Sink into a new generation of squishy, go-anywhere seating

PRODUCT PICKS Guest Picks: Earth-Friendlier Finds for the Home

By handsoccupied

Reduce paper and plastic use the simple, stylish way with ecoconscious kitchen, laundry and bathroom items

Sponsored

MCR ROMERO WORK LLC

Innovative & Creative General Contractors Servicing Franklin County

More Discussions

Help with an Air fryer

0