Eastern White Pine Replacment

10 years ago

With these last two storms this week, I'm seriously questioning our young white pine's future in our yard. There has been a lot of damage to mature ones in our area this week. I was thinking of digging it out and replacing it with something a little more tough. Here are my criteria:

Evergreen
30-60'
moderate - fast growing
NO Leylands or Arbs

The area gets plenty of sun after late morning and I'm in zone 6b. We have clay type soil with shale rocks and get about 42" of rain a year average.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

edlincoln
10 years ago
Eastern Red Cedar is really tough, but looks like arbor vitae.

Pitch pine is supposed to be tough, but prefers clay.
edlincoln
10 years ago
Eastern Red Cedar is really tough, but looks like arbor vitae.

Pitch pine is supposed to be tough, but prefers clay.
Related Discussions
Eastern White Pine
Q
Comments (2)
Just want to be clear - are you looking for someone (preferably knowledgable!) to bonsai your tree? If so it's a great idea... but this is not necessarily the place to spread the word (kinda slow moving these days), and you might also want to post on ibonsaiclub.forumotion.com (and don't forget the 'i' at the beginning.
...See More
How much growth in an Eastern White Pine?
Q
Comments (9)
first off.. ken does turn off the computer once in a while ... lol second.. i already addressed the issue of growing much of anything under mature pines ... it will be near impossible... due to water competition .. third.. a 40 foot tree.. DOES NOT NEED FERT.. EVER ... some say that a tree is twice as big below ground as above... though in a different shape/form ... if that is true ... the feeder roots are probably.. half way down the block.. to the seven eleven ... to feed themselves... otherwise... any fert put on the lawn ... within about 50 feet of the tree.. the tree will take what it needs ... check out the link ... nothing growing under them ... forest of white pine of course.. you dont have to take my word for it.. give it a go ... maybe you can do better than i did ... plant small... bare root.. plant in native soil.. never fert [to discourage the monster from invading the planting hole ... and try to water enough to get the babe established ... ken
...See More
Wide plank eastern white pine flooring: grade question
Q
Comments (3)
I did get an sample for the "original" (carlisle) and it wasn't too bad. The other vendor would be a custom order, so no sample). I'm ok with knots and character, but I dont want the boards to be loaded with them. Here's a picture of what I like. Would #3 fall into this category? Or would I be looking at way more knots?
...See More
Eastern White Pine (Pinus Strobus)
Q
Comments (4)
There is a difference between where a plant grows in the wild, where it has to outcompete other plants, and where a plant can grow when established by humans. White pines have absolutely no problems growing around me, where the natural soil pH is about 7.2. However, in abandoned farmland, there are very few white pines, but a lot of red cedar.
...See More
baxswoh
10 years ago
A pine to thwart the snow & ice damage would be a reflexa. Vanderwolf, Extra Blue or Joe Burke. Those three have incurred no damage this winter here. We have had more ice this year than any prior year that I can remember so it has been a valid test for the Limber pines.
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
10 years ago
with that big green lawn.. one might think you might look for something other than green ... i am going to slaughter the spelling.. but what about a Picea mariana 'Aurea Variegata'????

remind us where you are ... a little more specifically ...

with a name such as yours.. one would presume you are not using the word pine.. generically .... but i have to ask ...

any reason picea abies or p. glauca might not work .... or even an abies?? .. perhaps a location issue????

ken

Here is a link that might be useful: link
Sequoiadendron4
Original Author
10 years ago
I'm in south central PA. I like the picea abies but they seem to get raggety when they get older and sometimes I see them and the base is really wide. I know I could limb it up though. I thought, and perhaps incorrectly, that the p. glauca would be too slow growing. That p. mariana is nice but it says that it grows 10' in 15 years and that is quite slow for my tastes.
mikebotann
10 years ago
I have a few questions for you.
What's the problem with a wide base in your situation?
Why is a 'raggaty' silhouette not wanted?
What do you want the tree to do?
Is privacy from your neighbors a concern?
Are you going to plant other trees around it and make a planted composition, or have it as a lone specimen?
Mike
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
10 years ago
probably going to slaughter the name ... but how about :

Picea abies 'Virgata' ... leader growth is easily 2 to 3 feet ...

but i dont know if its zone appropriate for you ...

but if you insist on a pine.. how about a winter yellow .. like Louie ... again.. if it will work in your area ....

or if you want to stick with green... at least a sublime pine.. like ... carp.. i just blanked.. lol.... Pinus koraiensis ... or even wallichiana in your zone ....

or: Picea omorika 'Pendula' -- Weeping Serbian Spruce ... with its white undersides.. and slightly blue tinge ....

or one of the spring yellow blush pungens .... like early gold or colonial gold ... mine went from one foot to about 15 in 10 years ...

and just to set you straight.. just about anything FAST GROWING .... is weak wooded ... and subject to the same storm and ice damage you have already noted ..... i would not look for pines.. like strobus.. that do 3 to 5 feet per year.. find something in the 1.5 to 3 foot growth range .. MAX!!!!!

you asked for ideas.. and it is for you or others to determine if my ideas would work in your area ....

ken

ps: joy says it should be Picea abies 'Cranstonii' ... rather than virigata ... lets see if he did a reply.. before he got to my ps... lol ...

Here is a link that might be useful: link
baxswoh
10 years ago
I second Ken's recommendation of Pinus koraiensis. The trees grown from seed are often just as nice as the grafted cultivars. This tree is vastly underutilized.

Picea orientalis will solve the problem you have with Picea abies as it ages. Orientalis will stay full to the ground and not develop the sparse lower branching that you see in older Picea abies. The trade off is the growth rate is much slower.
bengz6westmd
10 years ago
I'll agree w/baxz5oh -- P flexilis (and P reflexa) have very flexible branches & resist breakage better than E white pine.