Jades: The Joy of Whacking

9 years ago

I'm the person who annoyingly posted 6 separate photos of my sick jade plants recently. Thanks, Josh and Gill, for your responses. I've gone and read quite a few posts on jade-whacking that were quite inspiring, and I'm now champing at the bit to get started. So far I've just removed the sick leaves and done a little mild whacking on the one pictured here. I'm uncertain what to do next. Since it has no central trunk, is it even worth fooling with? I'm holding off on repotting it with fresh soil until it's clear that I can make it into something that looks at least decent. All suggestions and opinions welcomed!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

Phodge
Original Author
9 years ago
Here's a side view of the same plant.
greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
9 years ago
Ah, the joy of whacking....
Your pot has several cuttings, so when you re-pot, you could remove one of those and pot it by itself to get that single-trunk look. I, personally, wouldn't hesitate to chop even harder. Wherever you prune, you will likely get branching, and those leaves will be heavier at the end of these trunks, which will cause those thin trunks to bend. And then you just end up cutting away all that growth in order to work the foliage down lower for a sturdier canopy.

Josh
Related Discussions
Whacked my Jade
Q
Comments (32)
1 yr after the wacking. i can report that she is very happy and healthy again! recap: my jade was severely infected with scale insects on the leaves and root mealies on the roots. after losing the battle i decided to cut off all the foliage and complete replace the soil. so i wacked it back, took it out of the pot and removed all the old infected soil. re-planted it and then waited until it started sprouting some new leaves. once new growth appeared, i watered with a very diluted systemic that had the active ingredient imidacloprid. i used bayer advanced tree and shrub insect control. for the first few months i used the systemic every watering. now i just use it once every 2-3 months just to be sure those little bastards don't return!
...See More
Lucky Whack (not a Jade trim story)
Q
Comments (9)
That's a very Zen hammer hit if I ever did see one, Mara. And a handsome boy in the first pic, too. I was advising kaktusChristopher against a recurved position just the other day, so your posting is most timely. I can't tell you the number of times I've moved plants, but it's been a few - garden planning isn't my forte, but I do well with lines of lilacs on the hill. This post was edited by cactusmcharris on Sun, May 25, 14 at 16:59
...See More
whacked jade guidance
Q
Comments (2)
Nice collection! The big leaves usually grow in response to lower light and/or high fertilizer levels. The new leaves that grow in will be smaller, I imagine. If the plants have roots, wait about a week to give them some water. That should be enough time for any root-damage to have callused. Josh
...See More
Need some jade pruning/whacking tips
Q
Comments (1)
Just do a search here for 'Jade whack'. You'll be titillated for hours.
...See More
Phodge
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks, Josh. I don't actually insist on having that single-trunk look and am no longer averse to merciless whacking -- I'm just unsure how to prune these many trunks so that the result will be something that looks full and pretty. Or at least interesting.
greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
9 years ago
When I'm home again, I'll make some suggestions on your pic.

Josh
Phodge
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks, Josh! I appreciate your help.
greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
9 years ago
These are just suggestions, based on a small pic where I can't actually see all the branches or their directions. But I wouldn't hesitate to bring the branches in this far if the plants were my own.

Josh

Edit: forgot the pic!

This post was edited by greenman28 on Tue, Jul 8, 14 at 13:56
Phodge
Original Author
9 years ago
This is so helpful, Josh! I'm prepared to be ruthless, and I will follow your suggestions. I bought some cactus/succulent mix today and some perlite as well. Only question remaining is about the new pot. I'm expecting to find that the plant is way root bound and that I'll need a larger pot. Since jades like to be somewhat root bound, how do I ensure its happiness in an initially roomier container?
greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
9 years ago
Well, I wouldn't recommend a hard-pruning *and* a re-potting at the same time. Jades are tough, yes, but that will increase the stress. Tough call. If it were mine, I'd probably do the pruning now, and then re-pot in a month or so....or whenever new growth begins to sprout.

As for the container size....I think the container size that the Jades are currently in will be fine. I suppose the pot could be full of roots; or you might find fewer roots than expected. Either way, I would just rinse off the old mix and put the Jades back into the same pot (or the same sized pot) with fresh mix. Add lots of Perlite to the mix.

Josh
Phodge
Original Author
9 years ago
Oh, OK -- I hadn't picked up that it wasn't a good idea to whack and repot simultaneously. I was thinking repotting might be needed promptly because of the weird diseased appearance of some of the leaves. Maybe I should repot now and whack laterÃ¢ÂÂ¦?
greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
9 years ago
You could re-pot now....I was just thinking that those long ungainly branches will be floppy and more difficult to support / handle when re-potting, but if you prop the trunks up with some stones, et cetera, it should be fine. It's totally up to you :-)

Josh
Phodge
Original Author
9 years ago
Yeah, that's why originally I was thinking of whacking before I repotted, but then I was assuming I could repot right away. I guess I'll go ahead and cut first and hope the soil it's in isn't too meager for it. Thanks again, Josh!
whip1 Zone 5 NE Ohio
9 years ago
Jades are pretty tough.A few years ago, these "sticks" were sent to me from California. I put them in a gritty mix, and put them outside.
{{gwi:94249}}
This is what they looked like a few months later.
{{gwi:3220}}
I think this pic is from last fall.
{{gwi:597620}}
Seriously, Jades have a very strong will to live.

Rob