Follow Up Info On Camellia Dieback Problem And Replant Issues

15 years ago

Luis, you are a gem for trying to help me. I spoke with Jerry Conrad at Erinon Camellias, and he said that some varieties are suseptable to dieback disease here in Florida. He will only grow and sell those that have high resistance, and I have to say , every camellia I have gotten from him is aboslutely excellent. He has the finest nursery I have ever seen. He didn't know much about Rutledge Minnix down here, but I haven't ever seen one growing in anyone else's garden. That probably says it all. The Rutledge Minnix was not purchased from him.

I didn't take a plant sample to Erinon Camellia nursery, (I didn't want to risk contaminating anyone else's stock), but I did thoroughly explain the situation to Jerry. He said it sounded exactly like dieback disease, since my roots are not spongy and mushy. I have well drained soil, so I was fairly sure I didn't have root rot, and further examination of the roots seem to rule it out. His recommendation was to remove the bush. Since I don't have evidence of root rot, he felt I can safely plant another camellia there. However, I am going to remove some of the soil and replace it with some from a "fresh" area.

Possibly, my slight pruning allowed the disease to enter this bush. It is the only bush that had a problem with it though, with the exception that it spread to the 2 next door neighbor camellias to this one. The camellias farther down the foundation planting are still clean and healthy.

I feel this camellia was coming down with the condition prior to pruning, as it had become infested with tea scale, something that I never have issue with in my yard. It was the only bush to get any. My opinion on all this is that the plant was ill, had not shown symptoms yet, but the insects knew of a weak speciman. Jerry concurred with that. Jerry Conrad has been growing camellias for years, teaches classes, and is highly respected in the camellia world. I trust what he has to say. Needless to say, I came home yesterday with 4 more beautiful camellias, and I just might have to go back for a couple more.

Sandy

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

luis_pr
15 years ago
Oh my goodness. You were definitely trying to help the economy this weekend! Hee hee hee!

I tried too. I went to a nursery that was closing a store nearby, hoping to check their Monrovia camellias and hydrangeas but struck out, i.e., they were out already.

Hope you have better luck with these new shrubs!
sandy808
Original Author
15 years ago
Thanks Luis. The new camellias I got are absolutely gorgeous specimans. Actually, all of the camellias that Jerry Conrad has at his nursery are really, really nice, and every one that I have ever bought there takes off like gangbusters. He propogates them himseolf, and uses organic gardening methods. If I could have gotten a couple more in my car that day, I would have come home with them. I'll need to go back for them. You would be amazed how we got 4 ten gallon camellias in the back of a Grand Am as it is! I keep telling my husband we need to get a large van, but he's not keen on spending money on one now. We like not having a car payment. So, I guess I'll make due with the little car. It's my little workhorse.

I like to give my business to private nurseries and businesses. I rarely shop at the big chain stores anymore. Yes, I have a bad addiction to plants and all things gardening, but at least it's a healthy one, and hopefully it will help keep some of the special businesses going:) I sure have discovered some of the most wonderful private nurseries in the past couple of years.

Sandy
Related Discussions
Camellia Dying?
Q
Comments (18)
Re-reading your initial post, I see that the camellia is probably 30-40 years old, and you've had it for 20 years since you bought the house. But it sounds like you've only been covering it for two years? Or did you use a different sort of cover prior to that? I wouldn't worry about the camellia's ability to recover from a cold winter- it's old enough that I think it's survived worse, though it may not always bounce back quickly. I do wonder if keeping the cover on for several months at a time is necessary/useful/counter-productive, but I have no experience of growing camellias in a cold climate, and can only advise you to be observant about how different conditions affect your plant's health, and her ability to bloom well. And ditto to what Luis said above... Virginia
...See More
Gardenias and Camellias in Central Texas
Q
Comments (37)
Well, I am sad to say my gardenia AND two camellias are likely done for. The odds were stacked against me-- a) I planted too late b) DFW heat is murdering them c) as a beginner gardener, I'm just not skilled enough yet to handle high maintenance plants. Especially since they're new plantings and d) trying to establish those types of shrubs in this heat was unwise. They did fine at first. I used good soil, the right fertilizer and food, appropriate watering, checked for pests/disease everyday. What finally sealed their doom was my dear lovely husband doing his part by manning the irrigation system. He input the start time for every single zone (8 in total) instead of just one start time for the first zone and the system tried to go through the irrigation cycle 8 times! I caught it when I got up in the morning and realized the sprinklers were STILL going (had them set to start at 5am). The overwatering murdered the gardenia and camellias. Gardenia is turning yellow again and losing leaves. Camellia developed leaf gall, root rot or both plus sun scald from getting a bit too much western sun. I'm not happy about losing these beautiful shrubs but I knew I was taking a risk with them, especially as a beginner. But it was a good test. I have a small variety of plants that range from super-low maintenance to very high. It was a good learning experience but I know that for now, I don't think I want to mess with those kinds of plants. Creating and maintaining the delicate balance of elements these shrubs need is just not something I think I want to mess with yet. Meanwhile, I'm having better success with my Texas sages, abelia, crossvine, star jasmine, angelonia, creeping rosemary and kalanchoe. So I'm out of the gardenia and camellia game (for now). But after some time and learning, I'm sure I'll revisit them again. I am determined to have at least one shrub that produces gorgeous, elegant, velvety white blooms.
...See More
Damping Off Issues
Q
Comments (10)
I think you maybe reading too much into the linked article. They are offering you general guidelines, not any absolutes. So just to be clear I am not saying it isn't in soil, it is. It is all soil. I am saying that it isn't ONLY in the soil. It is also in the air and on surfaces all around you. Soil-less potting mix starts out at the factory as sterile. (Bales of peat do not.) During transport, storage, and once you open the bag it is no longer sterile. The extension offices are quite right in saying start out with a sterile soil-less mix. That improves your odds. But they are not saying that you still can't get damp-off even when you do. That is an important distinction. What I am trying to tell you is the fungus spores, just like all other fungus is in the air all around us. The only way you could prevent the fungus from coming in contact with your plants is by doing the whole process in a vacuum. You can't so there is no need to dump out mixes because the new you get will quickly also be contaminated. But it isn't the inactive floating-around fungus spores in the soil or in the air or on the container that do the damage. They just lie there, dormant, unless they are given the conditions they need to go active, to grow and replicate and produce the toxins that do the damage. Deny any fungus spore acidic pH, humidity, excess moisture, and expose it to good air circulation and it remains dormant and eventually dies. <Knowing that my plants are going to start off under the lights, would you recommend switching back to my smaller 72-count cells, or should my 50-counts work equally well as long as I go more by the weight and not soil appearance to judge dryness?> I don't think it makes any difference. We start all our plants in the greenhouses in bulk flats and then transplant to 6 packs or other larger containers depending on planned sale form. Many times I have started 20-30 tomato seeds in each cell of a 4 pack when I'm only germinating a small number of the variety. That way I can get 100-200 plants going in a small space. But as long as I use a soil-less potting mix that is pH balanced, keep good air circulation going, and limit the water there are no problems. Dave
...See More
Potted Lime Tree Sudden Dieback Need Opinion
Q
Comments (15)
If the one side is in fact dead then, yes you will want to remove it as it will invite all kinds of infections/diseases. I would start cutting it down from the outer limbs and slowly cut small sections off and check after each cut if there is green inside. Stop cutting if you see green. Even if the other side is alive and it is found to be a separate tree and not just a separate trunk from the same roots, It will need to be removed when you are able to see the roots. Growing one citrus tree in a pot is hard enough, never mind growing two. Citrus trees are not house plants and require lots of sunlight. unless you get all day sunlight from a south facing window it will not be enough. You will need to supply extra light and one CFL, unless you can focus all of its light like steve, will not be enough. Some people also try placing there trees in a cool garage will low light to try and put the tree in a some what dormant state but this is tricky. I would try and hold off on switching out the soil until your tree is outside but if you have the room and can get the materials for either the "gritty mix" or "5-1-1" put together then go for it. These mixes take some time to get use to and will dry out very quickly and may need to be watered multiple times in a week and possibly everyday outside in the hot sun. When you have your tree bare rooted( all old soil removed) make sure to keep it wet and check for dark brown/black rotted roots that need pruning. As for the fertilizer, I don't know much about Miricle grow fertilizers but I would recommend "Dyna-Gro Foliage Pro 9-3-6" which has all the micro's that a potted citrus tree needs and seems to be recommend by all the experts here. Keeping your pot elevated off the cold floor with a stool or something will also help warm the roots.
...See More
tqsgardens
15 years ago
hi, I have only been doing camellias for a few yrs, buying my first 7 from Jerry Conrad, (they are doing great and and the others from other growers , and i have now lost most (but not his) from dieback and root rot. Is there a fungicide available to gardeners locally that will work? they all have been planted the same , but this has been very discouraging. they all looked great for a yr or 2 then I fertilized as told and bang! almost all were dead or half edad, still if someone can tell me of a fungicide I can use for my healthy ones and the ones I took the infected leaves off of. thanks
luis_pr
15 years ago
Hello, tqsgardens. One of the causes of root rot and dieback is watering too much. Another is cuts that allow the fungus to enter the plant. C. sasanqua are more susceptible to this disease too so keep all these things in mind if you live in places where this is a problem (FL for example). The following fungicides can be used: Cleary's 3336 50W and Heritage 50W.

To make sure that you do not end with resistant fungi, it is a good idea to use two fungicides whose active ingredients are different (like 3336 and Heritage's). Apply one of the two fungicides twice per label directions and then apply the other one twice; then repeat the cycle. Observe that application intervals for these two products are different. The spray interval in the label for 3336 is 1-2 weeks and Heriate is 1-4 weeks. Always read the labels, apply on zero wind days and wear protective gear.

Luis
sandy808
Original Author
15 years ago
I haven't been on the forum for awhile and just noticed the problem you are having with dieback and root rot. Jerry Conrad has indicated to me that many varieties of camellias are prone to dieback and/or don't do well in Florida. The varieties he sells are a result of his extensive research as well as his personal experience with what does well here.

It is correct that improper watering is one cause of dieback issues. However, the flip side is that some camellia varieties don't adapt well to our soil and climate conditions. I have purchased camellias from other growers who did not care for their camellias the way they should have been. Most have not done well over the long term. I now only purchase them from Jerry (all have done excellent) or from our local cammellia society raffles (that are propagated from local collections). Megily Farms in the Gainesville area also has nice camellias, but I still feel Jerry Conrad has the best.

Sandy

Follow Up Info On Camellia Dieback Problem And Replant Issues

Comments (5)

luis_pr

sandy808
Original Author

Related Discussions

tqsgardens

luis_pr

sandy808
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Follow Up Info On Camellia Dieback Problem And Replant Issues

Comments (5)

luis_pr

sandy808Original Author

Related Discussions

tqsgardens

luis_pr

sandy808Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

sandy808
Original Author

sandy808
Original Author