What do we do with our old rose catalogs?

12 years ago

Easy answer: don't throw them away.

Harder answer: Store them somewhere so that maybe, in the future, they'll be scanned and shared.

Reasoning: I went to the National Agriculture Library in Beltsville, MD, last fall to search their rose (and other) catalogs in special collections. They had a lot fewer than I expected them to. It was a "white cotton gloves", no flashs on my camera, pencils only experience. But when I saw how little had survived the 1800s I could appreciate their cautious approach. Maybe a percent of all the catalogs that were published in 1900 still exist there. So often there was a mention of other sellers in one catalog, but that seller had vanished. (Example: the Alabama Rose Company)

I am going to box my catalogs up.

I wouldn't give them to a library just now. I'm not sure if some libraries are going to continue to exist... I see more and more scientific periodicals pre-internet being placed in storage (including the ones that are not on line). Storage is relatively cheap. Every university library storage I've visited (three so far), Larry and I have been the only folks there using their musty olde books.

Ideas? anyone?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

strawchicago z5
12 years ago
When I decorated my 5-years old's room, she wanted to cut flower pictures from the catalog and glue them on the $10 "Peel-and-stick" princess border.

That was 3 years ago, the border still looks good and makes her bedroom into a flower garden. What's nice is that you can peel the border off, without any damage to the wall.
pfzimmerman
12 years ago
I've saved all mine and will continue to do so.
Related Discussions
why do we like what we like...and will we always?
Q
Comments (13)
Hi Elmire, I've thought about this some too, and as I've looked through various pictures I've tried to define what I do and don't like. I tend to like flowers, period. What I like best probably depends on the distance I'm looking at the plant from. Up close, a frilly picotee edge is the greatest thing... but from a distance, a simple single flower probably has the greatest impact. I like big yellow centers and no visible centers, both. I like both singles and doubles, but overall I'd rather have more semi-doubles than anything else, and I like them even better if their petals have some waviness to them. A rose with a subtle color blend to a darker or lighter color on the edge appeals to me hugely... though if the entire yard were composed of those kinds of flowers, there would be too much competition between them. So just a few Mrs. Dudley Cross roses (or roses of those types), sitting perhaps right next to Duchesse De Brabant to help point out the sublime in Mrs. Dudley Cross. I have always liked roses, but less so the hybrid tea forms than their smell. The brief amount of time I had Belinda's Dream with the same form, though, I liked it plenty. It looks especially nice with roses of other forms in a vase. I liked the effects of the tiny Rose Rosette to add variety to a vase of flowers, too. Overall, if I had to name just one favorite flower form, I'd probably go with a rhododendron, especially those with a bit of a frilly and/or picotee edging to the individual flowers within the truss. I love rhododendrons, huge trusses and small ones both. Rhododendrons don't withstand drought well, however, so I wouldn't suggest getting started with them if you can't give them plenty of water during a drought. Oh, no, maybe I should have said the one favorite was a camellia, all kinds of camellias... And daffodils! The Ice Follies variety is pretty much a perfect flower. But peonies (of all kinds) can't be bested by any other flower! Oh, I forgot to say how wonderful the tiny-leaved karume azaleas look when they are covered in a blanket of tiny flowers. They make for spectacular arrangements in a vase too. I like flowers, period. In a mood to really look and appreciate, I can get excited with just a single bloom from a native woods violet. And at that moment, it seems that nothing could best the simple woods violet. I guess the real luxury is in having a good variety of flowering forms, and especially in having them at various times of the year, which roses and camellias are both good at. Though I do have one rhododendron that blooms a bit every fall. I can't think of any flowers I actually don't like, though irises are probably fairly low on the list. I have stronger opinions on garden design than on the flowers themselves. (I'm not into geometrical/formal gardens so much as very informal ones.) Mary
...See More
What do we want the old house forum to be?
Q
Comments (32)
I don't consider anything after 1940'ish to qualify as an old house. And a house built after 1940 is 75 years old and a house built in 1965 is 50 years old. Not considering something of this age worth discussing, or thinking that something 50-75 years old is open game for gut renovation every time because it's not old is exactly the mentality that ruined so many Victorian and Edwardian houses in the 1950s. I don't believe every house has to be maintained as a time capsule. I dont believe any house really is ever a complete time capsule unless it's a museum. But there has to be a point when one asks oneself why XYZ is not worth saving and needs to be replaced with whatever is current no matter how bad it looks in the house. (And people don't think it's bad until later and its not the latest thing any more). There are enough options out there that a new kitchen or bath could look completely compatible with almost any age of house, without necessarily trying to be a period recreation, and without breaking the bank. Daltile ceramic or porcelain tiles in basic sizes cover the bases for practically any period of bathroom from after about 1920 and if you are okay with non rectified subway, you can do a compatible bath from before 1920. The Old House forum should at the very least support those who want to restore and renovate compatibly with their older houses instead of leaving them to the vagaries of fashion in the general Kitchen and Bath forums. I don't think this necessarily has to be a forum for complete purists--I don't think it is now, but apparently some people do (?). Many people may beg to differ but I don't think there is anything wrong with trying to maintain or recreate something from as recently as the 1980s. There is really nothing "wrong" with some of it, Late- and Post-Modernism can be kind of interesting. It's just that most people hate with with the same knee jerk reaction that they hate anything that they think is too old Not to hate and too new to not look back on as just another period in design history.
...See More
What should we do with our porch? We have wrought iron floral columns.
Q
Comments (4)
You will need to plan to water frequently. Generally where are you located such as nearest large city and state or country? What is happy as a potted plant in NH might not be the same as TX. What is the light level like over the course of the day? It looks quite shaded from this photo. Have you considered pots with vines such as clematis or mandevilla vine growing up the wrought iron columns, or are you firm on wanting hanging plants?
...See More
What Color Do We Use To Match Our Brick?
Q
Comments (0)
We are renovating our 1988 home and adding a small study to the back. The brick is painted brick from Mexico that was popular at the time. The colors are variations of gray, slight tan/yellow in some spots and a slate blue color. The addition is in HardiBoard as we would never be able to match that old brick. What specific color/brand paint should we use to compliment the brick?
...See More
roseseek
12 years ago
The last time I had a large amount of them was when Barney Gardner gave me decades of old catalogs. I passed those on to Bob Edberg of Limberlost Rose Books. You've probably seen them, Paul. I have several Arena, Sequoia, Vintage, Ashdown and others which I use for reference. Kim
windeaux
12 years ago
I've saved catalogs for quite a few years and find that I do refer to some of them from time to time. The importance of old catalogs was made abundantly clear to me as I read the recent Australian book on Tea Roses. Throughout that impressive book, as the authors repeatedly make references to early catalogs and sales lists, one realizes how very vital those sources were to their research and to the unraveling of much confusion.

Some of the older U.S. catalogs -- the early Edmunds' catalogs, for instance -- make for very interesting reading, and often contain helpful (& sometimes humorous) personal observations/opinions.

It would be wonderful if, at a minimum, there could be an online repository of a listing of rose varieties that were available thru the years from the various suppliers. Scanning the catalogs would, of course, be the ideal approach.
roseseek
12 years ago
Oh, yes! Wini Edmunds HATED mauve roses! I mean, she HATED, really HATED, mauve roses! "The Nile isn't blue and neither is this rose!" Her descriptions were chock full of those types of personal tidbits. I couldn't wait to read the thing cover to cover just to laugh hysterically at what she'd write about the roses. A Hybrid Tea was named for her, Wini, she wrote, "Fred will only let me have one of these in the garden, I guess he figures one in the garden and one in the house are enough!". About one, I'm not sure which it was, "I guess I should revise what I said about this rose. After last year's description, several people called to cancel their orders!" She repeated what a columnist wrote about Garden Party, calling it "Garden Pity". I seriously wondered if anything that crossed her mind didn't come out of her mouth. She was an absolute hoot! Kim
jerijen
12 years ago
I value the brief available access to the catalogs from Theodosia Burr Shepherds "Shepherds Gardens" Catalogs from "Ventura By The Sea" of the late 19th Century. I wish there were more of such "ephemera."

Libraries are a treacherous resource, because as times get tight, they "de-accession" what they feel they can't afford to keep.

Jeri
melissa_thefarm
12 years ago
I recently became aware of the existence of the Gutenberg Project, which converts books in the public domain into e-book format and makes them available free to whoever wishes to download them. Part of the raison d'etre of the project is to preserve rare books and make them widely available. Anyway, Project Gutenberg deals primarily or entirely with book-length works, or so I understand, but there might be other entities out there that would be interested in preserving these catalogs in electronic format. Who does research on roses? or rose history? and has a(n electronic) library? Those would be the folks to ask.
If preservation isn't the primary issue, there are ways to keep nice--tempting, beautiful--rose catalogs in circulation. I used to take all my nifty old magazines that I thought were way too good to throw away and haul them on down to the local coffee shop, which was always glad to have fresh reading matter for its customers. Or one could donate them to the local library book sale.
Melissa
organic_tosca
12 years ago
I will never, never give up my Vintage Gardens catalog.

Laura
roseseek
12 years ago
Your local VA and nursing homes are very good outlets to share your magazines with, too. Some doctors offices appreciate the reading material, too. Remove your mailing address labels from them before letting them go. You don't want nut cases showing up at your front door as if the magazine was an invitation! It has happened! Kim
seil zone 6b MI
12 years ago
I have all my Austin catalogs just because the pictures are so darn pretty! And I have a lot of Nor'East's too. Don't know how they got kept, maybe because they're so small, but I'm glad I have them now. They're good for referencing. J&P used to send me a new catalog about every other week so a lot of those got tossed. I usually keep garden catalogs 2 years and then when the 3rd year comes I toss the oldest one out. Otherwise I'd be hip deep in them!

What do we do with our old rose catalogs?

Comments (10)

strawchicago z5

pfzimmerman

Related Discussions

roseseek

windeaux

roseseek

jerijen

melissa_thefarm

organic_tosca

roseseek

seil zone 6b MI

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US