Concerns with Aaron's Farm Nursery

10 years ago

Just as an FYI to anyone who might use Aaron’s Farm Nursery for their trees, I wanted to warn you about their customer service and return policy.

I primarily garden with conifers. But I also enjoy having companion plants intermixed with them. I recently wanted to add a Sourwood tree (Oxydendrum arboreum). No-one locally carried the tree so I found a supplier online named Aaron’s Farm. They weren’t one of the big nursery suppliers as was evidenced by their inventory list but their pricing looked really good. So I ordered a 6-7’ tree from them for spring delivery. Nice price…only $80 dollars shipped.

I read their replacement warranty and was concerned from the beginning. But in my experience I lose very few traditional trees. So I ordered it anyway. They include in their warranty that if you do not let them prune the tree by 30% prior to shipping they will not guarantee the tree.

Well again, I lose very few regular trees and I didn’t want my 7’ tree cut down to a 5’ tree so I requested they not prune it. I received the tree on time but saw immediately the box was small. When I opened it I found a 52” stick, 4-5” of which was a small branch Y at the top. I looked at the packing slip and my request to NOT prune the tree was right on the slip and had even been highlighted with a marker by someone. But they did it anyway. I emailed them immediately and expressed my frustration but at the same time acknowledged that at least now it would be guaranteed. I received no reply.

When I got ready to plant the tree I unwrapped the large paper wad at the base and was surprised there were no fibrous roots at all, only a couple of major anchor roots. I planted it to the original crown, mulched the base to 1-2” away from the trunk, watered it in and then wrote a second email again expressing concern there were no fibrous water roots on the tree. And now I have a real concern because our hot summer temps are not that far away. Again I received no reply.

So now I’m just kind of ticked off but thought if the tree buds out then I won’t have to worry about it and I’ll just move on. Well time has marched on and it is a dead stick. So I went back to review the details again of their return policy and it is as follows:

1) First you have to fill out a return authorization request for the tree. It can only be sent in after the growing season. Then if approved you can return it

2) If approved they want the tree packed in the original box with a copy of the original order and packing slip. That means you have to keep any box of something you order from them in anticipation of returning it. Freight to return the dead stick in that large a box will cost me as an individual probably $15 or so dollars.

3) And finally they want you to enclose a check for a minimum of either $20 or 20% of the purchase price, whichever is largest to cover shipping on the replacement tree. So now I have $35 more dollars invested in getting my dead tree replaced.

So they want me to pay half the original purchase price to get something replaced they shipped incorrectly to begin with, and they shipped dead. I don’t think so. So if you’re thinking of using Aaron’s for your next tree or shrub order, keep these facts in mind.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

j0nd03
10 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Your #1 problem (as far as tree survival is concerned) was ordering such a large sourwood! These babies need root pruning pots and need to be transplanted even smaller than yours in our climate if not from seed in their permanent location. I have killed... oh let's see... 4 so far. The two that I have had success with were purchased as dormant 3' bare roots which I immediately root pruned and potted in a rootmaker pot for 1 growing season. Planted them out the following fall of 2012. They are alive and doing ok so far this year.

Basically, your complaints about their root system is just a typical feature of sourwoods. They have large singular roots with comparatively few feeder roots that branch out from the root collar randomly. If there was a root system opposite to maple roots, it would be the sourwood root system. In other words, it is hard to place the blame solely on your source for the tree dying because the things are just so damn finicky!

As for the company you dealt with on this order, they sound about as shady as a closet in a black hole. They obviously don't read their own notes and do not want to discuss complaints/questions from their customers. Try soonerplantfarms for an in state source that uses root pruning techniques on all of their stock now. They also, sometimes, carry sourwood.

Sorry for your loss. I would eat the $80 and not screw around with any "replacements" they offered. Doesn't sound like you are going to get a response anyways. Maybe contact the BBB? And do visit GardenWatchDog and leave a lovely review of your experience. This will reach more people than this topic alone =)

John

Edit: Whoops! Is Aaron's Farm Nursery another front for TyTy?

Can't include a link because it belong's to "that other site". Regardless, you are far from the only one to have problems with them... After discovering they are TyTy, your #1 problem was probably them to begin with. I rescind my opening comment.

This post was edited by j0nd03 on Wed, Jun 26, 13 at 13:40
lucky_p
10 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Uh-huh. One of TyTy's alternate monikers.
Cut your losses and chalk it up to experience. You're not the first person to pay 'stupid tax' ordering from the folks at TyTy - been there, done that, had the dead sticks to prove it.
That's been their 'return policy' for more than 20 years - kind of cumbersome and off-putting, isn't it?

If you want some commiseration, just do a search of this site for TyTy - you'll find lengthy threads from folks who've dealt with them - some with posts from folks from the nursery itself, who logged on to post incredible glowing reports, 180 degrees from the experiences of the majority.

Here is a link that might be useful: forum search

This post was edited by lucky_p on Wed, Jun 26, 13 at 15:37
Related Discussions
Online nursery review guide w/ photos (finishing up)
Q
Comments (16)
Will- The reviews are great. I really appreciate them. Are you familiar with Evergreen Nursery? I have placed several orders from them in the last year and have been wonderfully pleased. They don't have the largest selection, but they do have some uncommon species, and what they offer is top notch size, quality, and price. They have terrific service as well. Darren does all that he can to help, and does it in a very timely manner. You might want to check them out. Eliot P.S. I have no interest in Evergreen Nursery, I'm just one very satisfied customer. Same goes for Girard Nursery. I only live a couple of hours from them and hope to make it up to visit this year. I started buying from them about the same time as Evergreen. Can't wait to see your review for Girard's as well. Here is a link that might be useful: Evergreen Nursery
...See More
Concerns with Aaron's Farm to share
Q
Comments (12)
texjagman, if you really want this tree, do not get a bnb! This should be container grown (in a rootmaker pot preferably!). You might even start a few from seed and go the old fashioned way if you get really desperate. John Edit: This coming from someone who successfully transplanted a 20' bnb shagbark hickory! Sourwood is not meant for bnb treatment for us. In its native range, they might have some success this way but not here. Have I stressed my opinion enough? Good luck to you which ever way you decide to proceed =) This post was edited by j0nd03 on Fri, Jun 28, 13 at 11:20
...See More
Should I be concerned about this trunk structure?
Q
Comments (11)
FOUND IT... lol... listen.. you got some nice stock.... quit worrying .. they either live or they die.. my inventory is at around 600... my DEAD list at 150 ... i learned to do my best .. including selecting.. planting.. etc.. and let it ride.. long ago ... but for PROPER WATERING ..... read that link i gave you on planting IN CLAY ... you do NOT plant IN the clay... half in.. half out ... i dont understand your grinding story.. but i dont know if i would plant there... rooting wood is near impossible to maintain moisture in .... ken ps: if you really want to cut your anxiety level.. quit fooling around locally.. AND MAIL ORDER YOUNGER PLANTS .... not only are they easier to plant .... including root pruning.. etc... but they get established faster.. and get going faster ... and the big upside is.. if they die.. you lose $25 to 40 dollars.. instead of a couple hundred.. eh??? .. refer to conifer kingdom... girards nursery... etc ... buy small and buy more.. for the same investment.. delivered right to your door .... pps: i knew i wasnt going crazy... yet.. lol..
...See More
Aarons Bulb Farm
Q
Comments (2)
Ty-Ty is the WORST place ever. I had the misfortune to order from them 2 years ago. They sent me a growing and all greened up plant bare root. Obviously yanked out of the ground and soil washed off. Plus they shipped it post office on a Thursday so that it would not arrive until the following week, DOA of course. Thanks for letting me know this is all the same place.
...See More
Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis
10 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
That is getting to be a pretty penny though! The box stipulation is pretty ridiculous I agree. I have a locally bought sourwood just hanging on by a thread so maybe they are difficult transplants.

Take this from a guy who still emails a certain auto repair chain a decade after they tried to stick it to me, sometime it is just better to walk away. Well, after leaving a negative bbb review :). There is soo much time involved in our hobby waiting for things to ship or leaf you are better off finding a better source.
hairmetal4ever
10 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
How is that nursery (TyTy) still in business?

Concerns with Aaron's Farm Nursery

Comments (4)

j0nd03

lucky_p

Related Discussions

Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis

hairmetal4ever

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US