Neighbor asked how I felt about cutting down my oak!
cdooer
11 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (30)
j0nd03
11 years agohydrangeasnohio
11 years agoRelated Discussions
How much would it cost to have this water oak tree cut down?
Comments (5)Ken is right. The cost of having a tree removed is all over the place, and depends a great deal on where you live, how close to the house (or neighbors) the tree is, ease of removal, etc. We had some local yahoos remove some trees in the back for a very good price. They left a total mess of the backyard...ruts, dead grass, small limbs stuck in dirt, etc. We bit the bullet to pay more for a better company when we need trees removed from the front yard removal --- and they did a great job! They kept the grass nice - no tire tracks, divots, damage to the house, etc. They laid down plywood on the grass on which they drove their bobcat to remove the wood. I guess it all depends on the type of service that you want/need. Also, get an estimate for removal of the stump at the same time. You'll pay more for removal of the tree wood, and stump chips. If you want to save the tree wood for your fireplace, then let them know. (Sorry, tried to edit this but Garden Web insists on adding all this advertising code that makes it impossible to edit. ) This post was edited by dave_in_nova on Wed, Oct 1, 14 at 11:22...See MoreMy neighbor cut my pea plants off the fence!! Will they live?
Comments (13)Obviously, I'm a very novice gardener, but I read that you could get a second crop in this area and we had a really cool July (low 70's) so we gave it a try. We had so much trouble this year with our garden. We got squash borers and they seemed to take out our zucchini plants over night. That was really sad, because they were really huge and healthy and started dying just when it was time to harvest. We only got 2 zucchini out of 3 plants. I had never heard of squash borers before and I read they rarely attack cucumbers...I guess we're special because they got all of those and our cantaloupe too! I don't know if we're going to have a garden again next year. All that work starting them indoors, transplanting, caring for them for months just to lose them...it's been very frustrating! My neighbor was just the icing on the cake, ya know?...See MoreNeighbor cut tree down-now what?
Comments (6)its wasnt your tree... so there is nothing to be sad about ... most things that are shade TOLERANT ... do just fine in sun ... there arent many things that REQUIRE shade ... that said.. if too much sun.. they tend to get ugly in the summer.. with leaf scorch or some such ... but they rarely die from such ... and a lot of things actually have more vigor in sun .... and of course.. how far south you are.. makes a big difference as ot the intensity of the sun .... frankly.. you observe it for this year... and then decide if it should be moved.. in the next proper dormancy period ... whenever that may be.. for your area ... ken...See MoreShould I cut down this oak tree?
Comments (25)"No were did I say that the branch changes position of attachment on the trunk. Limbs just don't reposition themselves on trees. I said the trunk lengthens." "Let just agree to disagree." We're disagreeing because you're wrong about your main thesis. When I said, "...change position of attachment ..." I'm making the point that branches do not move up FOR ANY REASON, be it the trunk lengthening or the branch taking a walk. I'm covering ALL the bases, in case you decide to land there next. "Yes, sometimes branch do need to be removed to benefit the tree, but not for vanity purposes." Let's make our disagreement here, clear, too. Appearance IS a major reason one removes lower tree limbs. The trees are working for the house. Their job is to shelter, frame and show it off as much as possible ... not screen off its most important features. And trees are working for people. They should be trying to stay out of their way as much as possible. "... cutting branches of very much size at all produces lingering wounds ..." This is explicitly another reason that the task of removing lower limbs on a timely basis, when their cross-section diameter is the smallest, is the best policy. Not only does it prevent low limbs from transitioning into awkward trunks, As soon it is recognized that the limb will not fit the final tree from, but is otherwise in the way of ground activity, and it's job is taken over by other limbs, it should go. Which would be true -- As a general rule, homeowners, A) keep up with tree maintenance on a timely basis, or B) They don't. ...? It's clearly the latter and by a wide margin. A hundred trees experiencing some level of neglect can be found for every one that is maintained on time. There's not much point in encouraging people to delay maintenance. They overwhelmingly already default to that position. I have to disagree that the birch problem is because it is missing limbs from its interior. Even if it had those, its form would still be defined by the existing limbs. It's ugly on account of being a single trunk tree starting its wide spreading canopy structure at 4' off of the ground ... centered in front of a sizable house. If compared in a line-up with other possible tree forms, its attractiveness level would rate at the bottom....See MoreToronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis
11 years agoHuggorm
11 years agoken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
11 years agocdooer
11 years agoj0nd03
11 years agowhaas_5a
11 years agoalexander3_gw
11 years agotreeguy123
11 years agowhaas_5a
11 years agotsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱
11 years agocalliope
11 years agofamartin
11 years agoEmbothrium
11 years agoorso
11 years agoilovemytrees
11 years agocyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
11 years agoSmivies (Ontario - 5b)
11 years agofamartin
11 years agoEmbothrium
11 years agojqpublic
11 years agofamartin
11 years agobengz6westmd
11 years agoDzitmoidonc
11 years agoEmbothrium
11 years agowisconsitom
11 years agofamartin
11 years agofamartin
11 years ago
Related Stories
LIFEHow to Get Along With the Neighbors — and Live Happier at Home
Everyone wins when neighbors treat one another with kindness, consideration and respect
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: A Modern Home Meets Its Neighbors Halfway
Its exterior proportions fit the next-door Victorians, but this Salt Lake City home has its own distinctly modern personality
Full StoryCURB APPEAL7 Ways to Create a Neighborly Front Yard
Foster community spirit by setting up your front porch, paths and yard for social interaction
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESA Mom, a Garden and a Gift for the Neighbors
Gardening can be therapeutic in unexpected ways. See how one gardener found peace and purpose in a patch of Florida soil
Full StorySIMPLE PLEASURESThe Art of Being Neighborly
Learn the heartfelt gestures that go a long way toward creating a welcoming community
Full StoryLIFE6 Tips for Teaching Your Kids to Be Good Neighbors
Everyone wins when your children learn to respect boundaries, get help when they need it and show others they care
Full StoryLIFEThe Polite House: What’s an Appropriate Gift to Welcome a New Neighbor?
Etiquette expert Lizzie Post suggests the right time and best presents to introduce a new neighbor to your area
Full StoryCOMMUNITYDiscover the Joy of Welcoming New Neighbors
Don't worry about a perfect presentation — a heartfelt note and a simple treat create a wonderful welcome to the neighborhood
Full StoryCOMMUNITYSimple Acts: The Unsung Power of a Good Neighbor
There are many ways to be a good neighbor, and they're often easier than you think
Full StoryPETSHow to Help Your Dog Be a Good Neighbor
Good fences certainly help, but be sure to introduce your pup to the neighbors and check in from time to time
Full Story
poaky1