Zero-Turn or Traditional Mower for small but 'complicated' yard

13 years ago

I am looking to buy my first riding lawn mower. My current push mower is heavy (self propelled with a broken transmission so I just push it) and slow to cut with. My yard is just a bit too big to want to mow this way so I end up not doing it as often as I should.

My yard is about 3/4 of an acre so its not terribly big, but it is not a big flat expanse of grass. I have a number of trees, and a couple of somewhat steep grades to contend with, so there are not a lot of large areas where I can just cut on through without turning.

I am debating if its better to go with a cheaper riding tractor like the Craftsman YT 4000 (42" 24 hp B&S 2-cyl) for $1600, or if I would find it easier to mow with something like the Craftsman 28986 (42" 21 hp B&S 1-cyl), which is a zero-turn radius mower.

I do not have any special love for craftsman, it just seems that they have some decent deals (quality vs. price) on their tractors. If I am off track here feel free to let me know.

One concern I have is the fact that the more expensive Z-turn mower is only a one-cylinder engine. I have been reading up on mowers for a couple days now (by no means an expert obviously) and heard a lot of people saying these are noisier and cause more vibrations. This seems obvious, but my question is how bad is it really? Should I be concerned about this? Will it overly affect engine life?

I really do not want to go much above $2500 at this time for a lawn mower, but could go a BIT higher if there were a good reason to. I seem to wind up on this forum a lot in my internet travels, so I was hoping someone out there would have some good advice for me. Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

buzzard_flats
13 years ago
Don't know your situation but I just bought a 20HP Ariens from Home Depot, using the $250 "bath" cupon code, had to add a cart to the deal to get the coupon, but with free shipping to my door (cross country in 7-8 days) an almost free cart and the fact that the Sears and Ariens are all made by Husqvarna in the same factory, it seems like a good deal.

A zero turn will get almost into corners but for the price of the yard tractor???

Down side is that Home Depot has very little customer support for this, upside the Agri-fab brand front tractor scoop from sears (and Husqvarna) bolted right up and from calling a Husqvarna dealer who measured the rims on the rear it seems Husqvarna wheel weights are a direct bolt on option.

With free shipping, at under $1400 bucks, I just don't know.

I used to be a Craftsman fan BUT the quality and customer service today stinks, mostly the customer service which we used to depend on, all thing being equal I would not buy from Sears again, I only bought the scoop as it was on sale and over $100 less than the local Husqvarna dealer wanted for it.

$1000 more for zero turn (trust me you will still need to trim with a mower or string trimmer) or a std lawn tractor is all up to you.
krnuttle
13 years ago
You may wish to consider what other jobs you will find for your "mower". I have a half acre with flower beds, trees, driveway, buildings, etc. While the zero turn may do a better job mowing in the difficult areas, there are other things that you can do with a lawn tractor. The biggest is hauling stuff in the trailer. With 3/4 of an acre I am sure you have stuff to haul.

My trees drop a lot of branches. This spring I hooked the trailer to the tractor, and went around picking up and cutting up the small limbs that had fallen during the winter. Each spring and fall there are at least two loads of deck tools to move to and from the deck. I have used my tractor and trailer to move dirt, move materials to and from the pond, move paver stones from the Van to the place where I was putting in a path through he flower bed. With all of those limbs, I must rent a chipper, and it produces a lot of wood chips that have to be spread around the yard.
Move tools to where I was trimming trees and bushes.

As I said there are a lot of other uses for a lawn tractor, in addition to mowing the yard.
Related Discussions
John Deere residential zero turn???
Q
Comments (6)
The Deere Z425 is my only choice by far. I like the Z425 because it's as close to a commercial model as there is for the money. By that I mean it has separate hydro pumps and wheel motors as opposed to integrated (all in one) lawn tractor style hydros found on cheaper models. Zero turn mowers only tear up a yard if you drive them too aggressively. They have greater steering capability but that doesn't mean you spin around every time you turn. If you do it will tear up the grass. A gentle turn is easy to do. The real advantage to a ZTR is it's ease of driving and it cuts mowing time in half. The lower model Deere ZTRs have residential hydros and fewer good features. Stick with the Z425. I'm fairly sure a regular bagger is available for the Z425 as well as the powered version. A powered bagger is only needed if you want to vacuum a lot of leaves in the fall.
...See More
New Cub Cadet i1046 Zero Turn
Q
Comments (36)
Well, this is late for this thread, but it is worth writing because I'm guessing there are folks out there looking at this mower as i was and looking for any recent reviews as I was when i bought. I bought my cadet i1050 two summers ago and boy what a mistake it was. I had a JD at my old house and sold it with the house when I moved out. Did a lot of reading and checking and bought this thing at a dealer here in Maine called FM Abbott. So, I'm not going to drag out the whole story because my head hurts when I think of all the crap I've been through, and i have to get up early to call the half assed service center because my mower is sitting in the middle of my driveway stalled. Long story short, she has been to the dealer no less than 8 times (at either their expense to pick up ($50) or the expense of my time, effort and aggravation to trailer it over there). A few were because "there was no problem at all" according to them even though they took it with them (if it started, it is doubtful they'd have taken it each time_ and eventually told me they'd taken a few pieces of plastic out of the gas tank that were causing trouble. The other times it was because of the drive system. I remember reading a review that said this mower "climbed hills like a scared cat". Ummm, well, maybe when it was new. I have a pretty modest incline in the back yard that I just have to get up a few times and I'd say over the 2+ years of mowing, I've had to bail out more often than not and go down rather than up. There was a while when I'd step on the gas and the thing would hesitate, think about it, one wheel would spin then eventually the other would catch up....that was another trip to the shop. And today, in the middle of mowing she stopped in the driveway...no nuthin. I wonder if I can find someone to buy this POS so i can go back and get another JD, p.s. also worth mentioning is the inferior job this thing does cutting long and/or damp grass compared to my deere. p.s.x2, the dealer is not good at all. very friendly in sales and on the phone, but i can't believe how many times i've had to go back and i get no sympathy whatsoever. p.s. x3. I don't work for another dealer or another company. email me and i'll gladly send pics of my pos and answer any other questions.
...See More
Need help researching best Zero turn for my needs
Q
Comments (11)
A commercial model would be the way to go. The big difference from a residential model to a commercial model is about 1500 to 2000 hours of service. Residential mowers are for part time home owner use. Commercial mowers are rated for hard work, 8 to 12 hours a day, 5 to 7 days a week. A typical residential mower is rated for 500 hours to 800 hours of life time service. A commercial mower is rated for 2000 to 3000 hours of life time service. I mow 5 acres of very rough land in Central Mississippi. I also have a fast growing grass type named Bahia Grass that loves hot dry or wet weather. To put it mildly Bahia Grass grows form 4 to 8 inches a week. I've owned 3 lawn tractors in the last 20 years. The first 2 were junk. In 1999 I got a Sabre by John Deere with a 46 inch deck, powered by a Briggs Vanguard. It did a pretty good job. But I couldn't mow the whole 5 acres. I had to hire a bush hogger to come in every year. Then if it rained a lot, my grass would get out of hand in a hurry. So my mowed yard got smaller, and smaller as the years went along. So I had to get a bush hog in more as the years went along. My mowed yard shrunk to about an acre. Than again a bush hogged field is not a pretty sight. My deck gave out last year on my Sabre. By that time my wife and I took on my mother in law's property due to the death of my father in law. Here we were in a wet year, with a broken mower. Things were getting in a bad way fast. I had to order a deck for an end of life mower. That took 2 week to come in. Then I had to paint the deck, and transfer all the hardware from the old deck to the new. That took about 2 more weeks. During that time we had to hire a bush hog, and a lawn care mower to knock the grass down on both properties. My wife and I started researching ztr mowers. Like you we didn't want to spend large amounts of money. We found that residential ztr mower had no longer life spand than our lawn tractor. Ether they had the same stamped deck and residential engines, along with the same hydro transaxles. Or if the mower had a fabricated deck, it still had a 500 hour rated engine. So 50 hours a year = 10 years. If we were going to spend that much on a mower, we wanted longer than 10 years. We looked, and looked, and researched, and looked, and researched. During that time the grass never stopped growing. I got the Sabre back into action. We got the mil's lawn back in to shape. But we lost the battle at our place. We made our decision. Funny someone mentioned our mower above. We got a 52 inch Bad Boy Pup with a 30 hp Kohler Command Pro. I've got to say that mower changed our life. What took us day to mow. We now can do it all in about 3 hours. And that's not traveling all that fast with a 52 inch deck. I'd say average speed is about 5 mph. We have trees, and rough grounds. I've rambled enough, so I'll show some pictures. Oh! I haven't found the ride to be that bad. Good Luck! ms
...See More
Zero Turn Mowers
Q
Comments (4)
I agree with ptg, You don't have enough property to justify the need for a Zed. Keep a few things in mind here. ZTR's were developed for people in the BUSINESS of cutting grass because time is money to them. Zed's are expensive to buy because, unlike a lawn/garden tractor, they have TWO hydro pumps and TWO drive motors. For Joe Consumer, that's twice as many things to maintain, to go wrong, to repair and to replace. A LT/YT/GT is far more useful than most Zed's are when it comes to doing other chores around the property. The exception here is definitely the Walker but the price speaks for itself. Aside from ground speed offered by Zed's, the other bonus is their ability to manuveor around objects, obstructions etc much easier and quicker than a conventional tractor that has a belly mower. An all-wheel steer (as suggested) will help you greatly when mowing around tree trunks, alongside twisty garden beds and sidewalks as well as other tight areas. If you said you had three to five acres of actual lawn to mow, then I would agree that a Zed should be considered. Especially if the property was well-tree'd or had extensive plantings, the abilities of the Zed would definitely save you time. However, my advice would also echo ptg's regarding your budget because a property of that size would dictate buying a true commercial quality unit. It's better to buy a decent quality garden tractor than a low-end ZTR.
...See More
dynamike59
13 years ago
Buzzard_Flats
I'am sorta confused, when you mention "scoop" in your numerous post about new Ariens do you mean "front blade".
Scoop to me means Johnny Bucket and Johnny Bucket doesn't make a front bucket for your small LT.
buzzard_flats
13 years ago
Scoop as in sears 486.248474 'front tractor scoop' also sold by Husqvarna but made by Agri-Fab. Not quite a JB and I am not expecting to do waht a JB would do but it does a great job moving loose soil or gravel around. I may even get more lazy and get a 12V actuator from Surplus Center in NB and power the lift function. I may drill the front scraper edge and add a wear edge if I start using it a lot, and that would also allow attaching some teeth which would help a lot in compacted dirt.

So I guess the short answer is 'scoop' not really ground engaging as would be a front plow blade where your pushing a load of dirt/snow in front but more of a lift and carry thing with a dump function.
moerrr
13 years ago
Look at used commercial ZTR mowers in your area. You may find a good one under $2500. You won't be sorry.
dynamike59
13 years ago
Thanks Buzz
I did alot of digging at Sears before I found the item # yesterday.
Did not know that Sears sold a scoop.
Looked at some reviews and the owners were really complaining about how hard it was to assemble and the mods they had to do to get it to work right.
Be gentle with your new bucket , you don't have a big GT behind it so your Ariens is going to get some abuse.
buzzard_flats
13 years ago
Mike,

Yes I am not going to do like some of the reviews said and run top speed into a pile of compacted soil. I also noticed the complaint of the dump pin bracket shifting, they could have included a few star washers to lock it up rather than flat washers. I think once it's in position I'll perhaps drill & tap for a couple 1/4-20 bolts to fix it in place.

The assembly would not be bad if they didn't keep turning the view around or at least put and arrow saying front in each picture. Some or most the spring clips included were way too big and just fall all the way through the pins. So I went to the hardware and bought the right size clips, a few cotterpins and fixed that. Like most assembly manuals this seems written by a tech writer who asked a few questions, wrote it up and never had a test subject work through it.

Zero-Turn or Traditional Mower for small but 'complicated' yard

Comments (7)

buzzard_flats

krnuttle

Related Discussions

dynamike59

buzzard_flats

moerrr

dynamike59

buzzard_flats

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US