Friend or foe?

13 years ago

So maybe not so much friend, but if this guy will become a beautiful butterfly, I guess I can be ok with it eating a couple of rose buds. If just a rose slug though - will be moved were the birds can get to it a bit easier!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

vettin
Original Author
13 years ago
Forgot photos:

{{gwi:255462}}

{{gwi:255463}}
User
13 years ago
Future butterfly or not, when I see these munching on buds, I usually pull them off and toss them into the ligustrum a few feet away. They can eat the ligustrum to the ground for all I care, but I want all the roses for myself.
Related Discussions
Friend or Foe Friend or Foe?
Q
Comments (2)
It looks like a picture winged fly. I see them around, don't think they cause any trouble.
...See More
Friend or foe in the mixed border?
Q
Comments (7)
Yes, L. inflata will try to blend in but the foliage is a bit coarser than L. siphilitica and the flowers tiny as you confirmed.
...See More
Online Used Furniture Consignment: Friend or Foe?
Q
Comments (3)
We have a used furniture store in my smallish town. They buy out of estates in local higher-end communities. I have gotten several great deals there (with free delivery!). You do have to kiss a lot of frogs. See if you can find a couple of those kinds of places in your area, make friends with the owners, and let them know what you are willing to wait for. Visit frequently. Good luck! And, coincidentally, one of my buys was also a Palecek chair. My upholster recovered for $35!
...See More
Friend or foe beetle
Q
Comments (16)
O no. We don't have those here (yet?) but they sure do look...fancy. :) I think your black ladybug has black spots. I made a collection of them in different colors once when I was in the south. They are fancy too in their own way! (Now that I think about it, when I moved to the upper midwest, they were all orange and boring. I wasn't collecting them at that point but they invaded homes in the fall to overwinter so they were hard to avoid.)
...See More
collinw
13 years ago
Most butterflies have specific larval food plants, I don't know of a butterfly that uses roses. Maybe a moth?
onederw
13 years ago
A question for you, Vettin: Do you feel the same way about brown moths that you do about butterflies?
Because this looks very much like your garden variety (pardon the expression) cabbage looper, the same villain who munches out petunias and geraniums and snapdragons and, well, cabbages if you've got 'em.
I haven't seen a lot of them on rose buds. Usually they choose softer targets. Could something else have damaged the bud first?

Here is a link that might be useful: Cabbage looper pix
vettin
Original Author
13 years ago
Bleh, bird food it is. Thank you!
organic_tosca
13 years ago
I agree with the "enemy" classification, but thought I would mention a similar larva that is definitely a "good guy": the Syrphid Fly larva, which will vacuum up aphids really, really well. This little green Syrphid Fly larva ( apparently he can appear in other colors, such as brown or yellow), has no legs - a way to tell which larva is on your roses. The one in your picture is NOT a Syrphid Fly larva, as it clearly has legs. I look really carefully now before I pluck a little green worm-like critter off the bush, because if it's Mr. Good Guy I need him - I have a real aphid problem here, and this little thing works at least as well as a Lady Beetle larva, if not better.

Laura
sherryocala
13 years ago
Vettin, what a great photo that first one is. I see the holes left in my buds, but I've never seen the culprit caught in the act. Thank you! I will be looking for those guys. Smush!

onederw, thanks for putting a name to it and for the link.

Here is a link that might be useful: If only sweat were irrigation...
onederw
13 years ago
Sherry and Vettin --
If you have just a few, a hand removal/ligustrum relocation program should work. If you are dealing with a major infestation, however, it may be time to break out the Bt -- bacillus thuringiensis. Not a pesticide, it works, I believe, by "freezing" the digestive process of the caterpillar. Couldn't happen to a better bunch of bozos.