Musing: Actions to revive a potentially dying shrub or tree?

14 years ago

It has happened in my career of growing different trees and shrubs, that after winter certain ones look as if they are going to leaf out or bud, but time marches on and nothing happens. Once a certain period of time has lapsed, you know without a doubt that that plant is dead, kuput, finis.

We all know to check for green under the bark, but I have found that not to be foolproof. Something is going on inside that can't be seen causing the sap not to rise into the branches to get on with the leafing out process.

I wonder if there are any heroic measures that can be taken within a given period of time, dependent on the growth pattern of the plant, that will stimulate new growth from a different area preventing total plant death. Maybe you do something at root level, or to the branches (pruning) or trunk, Or a plant is dug up and treated, a plant hormone applied, salve put on--I dunno--just hazarding guesses here.

If such things might work, *when* to do it would be critical as there is a point of "too late". Knowing which categories of shrubs could be salvageable would be another point.

Anyone have experience with resuscitations?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

User
14 years ago
What exactly is it?
SPecify exactly what you are talking about, the age, and the general area that you live in.
sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PA
Original Author
14 years ago
I entitled this "Musing" because I'm not asking about a specific shrub although wondering about my lagging weigela made me compose this post. There hace been fair number of questions about viburnums that appear to be dying. So, taking a shrub like a viburnum, what might you do if you suspected that it was failing that could "revive" it? Versus something like a lilac?
Related Discussions
Why does it look like this sugar maple is dying?
Q
Comments (77)
Just for the sake of chronicling this experience, I ended up spraying right after my last reply. It took about 3 mins and exactly 1 gallon to do all the trees and some shrubs. The wind was so calm and I knew it was my only chance. It rains here about once or twice a month yet it will happen when i need it to stay dry. It looks like some light sprinkles now.
...See More
Camellia dying, help please!
Q
Comments (34)
It could use more foliage. Not sure if it lost foliage due to inconsistent watering, cold winters, etc. I could not tell if the camellia is a hybrid, sasanqua or japonica from the leaves. Do you know? Does your pot have drainage holes in enough spots to allow for excellent drainage? The pot should have acidic, very well draining soil (not garden soil). The soil should also be kept as evenly moist as you can -not wet but not dry either-. The foliage needs morning sun only if it is a hybrid or japonica, reticulata. Sasanqua leaves can take more sun though. Mulch will minimize soil evaporation, protect from hot/cold extremes and provide some nourishment as the mulch decomposes. Plastic pots may get too hot in the summer and stress roots in contact with the plastic. Avoid weeds and grass in the pot as camellia roots are only about 4" deep, tiny ad fibrous so they compete with grass/weeds roots. Not sure what fertilizing program you are using but a fertilizer for camellias, azaleas and hydrangeas applied per label directions may be fine. Pinching may be useful to make the plant fill up with more foliage once the cause of the original leaf drop has been addressed.
...See More
Desert Rose leaf tips dying
Q
Comments (59)
I have been trying to grow a desert rose for many years now. When I first got it the pot was too small so I repotted it, but I used regular soil and was very tricky to water it just enough to keep it between brown tipped leaves and yellow leaves. I finally read up and repotted it into cactus/succulent potting mix. When I had pulled it out of the old pot I was amazed it was still alive because it had only 2 or 3 small roots coming off the big ball, and it surely had root rot. There was not much at stake so I washed it in water and actually sprayed it very hard with the hose nozzle to clean off the black stuff. Back to the new pot and soil, it started to grow very fast but the leaves will not get dark green, they look pale. The soil was miracle grow and I'm wondering if it has the wrong fertilizer in it? Also even though it drain much better than before, I think I'd like to pot it again with a good amount of sand added to the succulant soil so it drains even better. Oh, I did pull it out of the new soil once to see how the root rot was doing and it had grown new roots like crazy! I couldn't believe how fast the new roots grew! So what do you think I should do? Add sand because I feel it is still holds too much water, and what about the pale green? It used to have dark green leaves. It has only bloomed once in many years, sometimes I just can't give up on a living plant no matter how bad it looks. Thanks, Tony
...See More
This and that. Garden musings.
Q
Comments (49)
That is such good news about Lisa, Ingrid. I was getting worried, given all that is going on now. I'm glad Lily is going to help out. I know several people who have had this surgery, and never regretted it a bit, including a friend who has an enormous garden. I am so sorry to read about your garden. I know you don't want to do anything about the critters, but I couldn't stand by and not take some action--or hire someone to build some protective fencing. I have had a strange year--absolutely no deer have come around here all season to chow on my roses. They're very much around our village and the hills, so it's puzzling. I spent a small fortune on a big supply of deer repellent, too. I've used some early in the season, but I don't know if spraying the stuff in July is very worthwhile. Those blasted creatures are probably out in back right now laughing their heads off. I tempted the fates. Flowers, I'm so happy your Colette is charging back. She is one of my toughest roses. I know she looks awful just before dormancy is broken, but I know she's alive. You know how angry I was with Brother Cadfael for his poor reblooming. At the end of August 2118, I chopped him down (sort of). He went from close to 9 feet to less than two. I think he liked being cut down to size, and for the past year has grown like crazy back up to nearly 9 feet, and he has been reblooming better this summer, but the heat just destroys the darn blooms. A gardener can't win. But yes, roses are full of surprises--not always good ones. I'm a pessimist. Diane
...See More
jean001
14 years ago
What, and whether or not something, can be done depends upon what it's failing from.
Embothrium
14 years ago
Picture trying to talk specifically about general medical conditions, this is almost the same kind of thing.
sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PA
Original Author
14 years ago
OK--let me ask this way. In what cases will pruning stimulate an otherwise failing plant to put out new growth? Which will respond by sending growth from the root level? And does root level stimulatio mostly only occur in suckering shrubs? I'm trying to come at this from the "Big picture level".
laceyvail 6A, WV
14 years ago
I think you're talking about failure of a shrub to break dormancy. I've had this happen twice with a mail ordered shrub, and both nurseries replaced the plant. And once with a shrub that I had moved the previous season and had struggled some. Nurseries have told me that there was nothing to do but wait and see.
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
14 years ago
i dont see where pruning will save a dying tree ... or a dead tree ... hard to pin point that dichotomy ...

if you are dying.. will lopping off your arm???

perhaps.. if in fact that its the problem part ....

but how would you know on a tree ...

the losses i have had .. in late spring.. after i note bud swelling.. i can usually figure out a hard frost or freeze.. that hit the plant at just the wrong time.. and yes.. it can hit on tree ... or only affect the struggling on ....

a previously struggling plant [transplant .... drought the prior year... disease.. bug????] ... might have just enough power to bud out.. but then they get hit with the killing temps.. and frankly.. it just gives up .. if it had a choice ...

and if that is the case.. of what good would pruning be???

i suppose.. at that point.. you have nothing to lose ... cut on it.. and see if anything can be saved ... but i wouldnt bet too much money on it...

ken
Dan _Staley (5b Sunset 2B AHS 7)
14 years ago
OK--let me ask this way. In what cases will pruning stimulate an otherwise failing plant to put out new growth?

This doesn't make sense botanically.

Dan
ditas
13 years ago
On a different note - I don't suppose you are including certain species w/ documented/claimed, shorter life-span?

e.g. 'had to put down a Quacking Aspen on the nursery's above diagnosis ... this guy refused to go w/o leaving heirs behind. I'm still discovering thick roots & sending shoots all over the place, running under other beds, particularly where they are not welcome & won't work aesthetically ... up to 30' away - where life support is, for sure! I hate chemical killings of invaders but the neighbor's yard is getting assaulted/invaded!!!

In my plantings, prior to demise of this *wonder boy*, I have inadvertently severed/chopped roots ... the ends took life of their own & created the heirs apparent!!! Ugh! What does one do w/ a very assertive kind?

Musing: Actions to revive a potentially dying shrub or tree?

Comments (9)

User

sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PA
Original Author

Related Discussions

jean001

Embothrium

sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PA
Original Author

laceyvail 6A, WV

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

Dan _Staley (5b Sunset 2B AHS 7)

ditas

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Musing: Actions to revive a potentially dying shrub or tree?

Comments (9)

User

sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PAOriginal Author

Related Discussions

jean001

Embothrium

sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PAOriginal Author

laceyvail 6A, WV

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

Dan _Staley (5b Sunset 2B AHS 7)

ditas

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PA
Original Author

sujiwan_gw 6b MD/PA
Original Author