skip to main content

Ponds & Aquatic Plants

Ideas for new pond, pros and cons of koi

12 years ago

So I am in the process of planning a new pond for our house. I have a pond that is grossly overstocked (not from purchases, but koi and goldfish spawn) at my folks house, so I am urgently trying to build one at our home to accomadate my growing collection of koi and goldfish. I wanted to ask the posters here what their thoughts were on goldfish vs koi ponds. From experience, I can honestly say that I enojoyed the goldfish only pond more than the koi/goldfish pond becuase of maintenance time. I am thinking of selling off my prized koi and just "keeping it simple" - has anyone gone through similar circumstances? Here is my list, feel free to add your 2 cents.

Pros:

Beauty, koi are really beautiful, (if you can see them)

Time and $ already invested: I already have ~ dozen and have invested in them greatly

Attachment: have had them for years

Cons:

They need a bigger, deeper, pond which means I might need to put a fence around it since we have lots of small kids and animals in the area.

Maintenance with such large fish

Probablly need a separate pond for the plants (I am tired to trying to keep them from eating the plants).

Any thoughts?

thanks everyone

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

ponderpaul
12 years ago
HEARING YOU!!! I have ten Koi, eight of which are 18Ã¢ÂÂ to 22Ã¢ÂÂ that I have had for about three years in a pond that is a little over 1,000 gal. I am thinking of selling all except my four favorites.
Debbie Downer
12 years ago
THANK YOU for thinking of the health and happiness of your fish, and being honest about what you can manage. I wish more people would! (And yes, I do think there must be a fishy equivalent of "happiness" that they experience.)

There are discussions all the time here about minimum gallons per koi to allow etc. and yes it may be true that you can technically keep them healthy with not a lot of space, if the filtration is adequate.... but I always wonder WHY BOTHER if there's not enough room for them to move freely. To see a group of koi moving together in a school across a large pond is an AMAZING sight. You don't see that when they are cramped. Without enough space they just kind of dart around aimlessly or don't move much at all.

Which brings me to goldfish. There are some bred especially for ponds with bright colors and long fins - some look exactly like koi - only they stay small 10-12 inches maybe. You can get that same schooling behavior in a lot less space.
Related Discussions
New koi pond
Q
Comments (2)
Other than a heron or maybe otter I don't know what would be "fishing" in daylight hours, but I sure am sorry you lost your fish. That is always so shocking. The net will hopefully make a difference. Anne
...See More
Pros and cons, turtle in small pond.
Q
Comments (11)
Sounds like you've already reached a decision based on your particular circumstances. That acknowledged, I agree with the above advice with the exception of the antibacterial soap business (causes more harm than good in the long run)in which case I defer to rsingley & whole-heartedly agree. The fact that I've survived all these years is proof enough for me;) Turtles are a pain to corral but that would be the ONLY reason to deter me. I'd welcome one if he showed up of his own accord (provided he didn't eat my fish for dinner). I'd try & steer kid's attention in another direction without discouraging interest in the pond environment. Losing a pet is hard at any age and you're alreading facing giving away the 3 koi at some point... blessings & happy ponding, ~digger
...See More
New Koi in a New Pond
Q
Comments (12)
Hi, Last fall I dug out and constucted a 15 by 15 foot pond with a waterfall on one end. The deep end is about three foot but then it tapers to about 6 inches. I have kept goldfish out there this winter by leaving a hole in the ice and a pump running. Of course over the winter I have been bitten by the Koi bug and have been given a beautiful platinum one and also purchased 3 others. Just mutts. But from what I am reading should I be concerned about them jumping out in the shallow end. If this will be a problem should I use netting at water level or higher and also what kind? Seems kind of annoying to have it showing. I think I can anchor my water lilies with alot of rocks but then if I need to use a net how will they come up? Any help for a newbie would be much appreciated. I live in southern Minnesota. At what temapture does the water have to be to put the Koi out and will they fight with the goldfish? They are all about the same size. Happy gardening! :) gardin angel
...See More
New to koi want to do a pond setup
Q
Comments (3)
I agree with pikecoe. Your cost estimate seems too low. A few points... DO go with an EPDM fish-safe pond liner (NOT pvc, NOT roofing liner). For a pond of your planned size, you should probably use a submersible pump. There are ones in every pumping capacity category (not just for "smaller" ponds). It will also be less costly to run and will be one less piece of equipment to hide. Where will your pump be installed? A skimmer box may be a good option. The bog area, if of sufficient size and equipped with plants and gravel, will function as a bio-filter. But do also add the waterfall for better aeration. UV's are not always necessary. Invest in a good pump and skimmer (if you are using one) before you buy a UV.
...See More
bradarmi
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks Kashka and Paul,
I gave into the koi craze when we built the pond 10 years ago, and now I know what I can maintain and what I have time for. While my fish are healthy and the pond plants are thriving (even with the constant grazing by the koi) - I feel like this year I didn't "enjoy" my pond because it was so green and murky ...first time in 10 years its been this bad. And now I am planning on building a pond of my own I wonder when did I loose the enjoyment of the hobby which is now turning into a "job"...just curious if others feel the same way.

I wonder if simply a larger pond would accomadate them (still planning on selling at least some) or if I should just revert to the easy and simple goldfish.

MPKS (Midwest pond and koi society) just had their fish auction, but I couldn't make it...anyone know of somewhere I can sell large and small (imported) Japanese koi in Chicagoland?
buyorsell888
12 years ago
Simply said: Koi are a lot more work and require bigger/deeper ponds than goldfish...

Many find a watergarden with plants and goldfish more relaxing and enjoyable than a koi pond....

Related Stories

REMODELING GUIDES Gravel Driveways: Crunching the Pros and Cons

By Erin Lang Norris

If you want to play rough with your driveway, put away the pavers and choose the rocky road

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING How to Make a Pond

By Mitchell Parker

You can make an outdoor fish paradise of your own, for less than you might think. But you'll need this expert design wisdom

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING Choosing a Deck: Plastic or Wood?

By Vanessa Brunner

Get the pros and cons of wood, plastic, composite and more decking materials, plus a basic price comparison

BUDGETING YOUR PROJECT Design Workshop: Is a Phased Construction Project Right for You?

By Eric Reinholdt, Architect

Breaking up your remodel or custom home project has benefits and disadvantages. See if it’s right for you

CONTRACTOR TIPS Building Permits: What to Know About Green Building and Energy Codes

By Matt Clawson

In Part 4 of our series examining the residential permit process, we review typical green building and energy code requirements

COMMUNITY Get a Bird's-Eye View of America's Housing Patterns

See the big picture of how suburban developments are changing the country's landscape, with aerial photos and ideas for the future

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING Why Is There a Bathtub in the Backyard?

By Becky Harris

Nope, it's not waiting for bulk trash pickup. These days outdoor tubs are serving soakers, beer drinkers and even the fishes

CHRISTMAS Real vs. Fake: How to Choose the Right Christmas Tree

Pitting flexibility and ease against cost and the environment can leave anyone flummoxed. This Christmas tree breakdown can help

LANDSCAPE DESIGN Garden Walls: Dry-Stacked Stone Walls Keep Their Place in the Garden

By Olander Garden Design

See an ancient building technique that’s held stone walls together without mortar for centuries

MODERN HOMES Houzz Tour: Nature and Efficiency Inspire a Woodland Home

By Natalie Wain

This English design plays up simplicity, natural light and its spectacular forest setting

Sponsored

Structural Remodeling

Franklin County's Heavy Timber Specialists | Best of Houzz 2020!

More Discussions

Leak in my small inground prefab watergarden...?

1

pothos with yellow leaves

7

Stock tank cracked, New tank has brass drain

1

Growing impatiens in water

1

What is destroying my Willow?

8