So many movies, so little time. Just this upcoming weekend, I would love to see The Great Debaters and Cassandra's Dream and There Will Be Blood is on the horizon. I think Denzel will win out, but it's so hard to choose between so many promising films.
The last two films I've seen most recently are Atonement and The Kiterunner, both excellent and somewhat similar in theme in terms of the actions of young folks when they have no understanding of the implications of their actions. But there is sure a big difference between England in the years before and during WWII and Afghanistan/Pakistan in contemporary times.
Atonement is so beautiful in its early scenes and its depiction of the rarefied lives of the British moneyed class. I don't want to give away too much of the film, but it's all about class and the way the wealthy close ranks when threatened by the lesser folk, even a young man like Robbie, played by James McAvoy, who has been educated by the family for whom he works and expects to go on. But once he is suspected of a crime he actually did not commit, there is no hope for him, in particular any chance of choosing his own future. The child who falsely accuses him--you can see this coming long before it happens--spends the rest of her life coming to terms with the damage she causes. The story seems simple enough on that level but it's the plot twists and turns, the cinematography, the tensions and pacing that provide the film's wonder. There is one scene on the beach at Dunkirk where British soldiers are located in the middle of a carnival that is surreal in its beauty and in its commentary of the absurdities of war. McAvoy is even better in this one than he was in The Last King of Scotland, and Keira Knightley is as good as she is in every film in which I've seen her. Wait until you see her in that green dress early in the film. Some nice surprises, including a brief dissertation at the end by Vanessa Redgrave on the relation between facts and fiction and what audiences expect and/or really want.
A critic I read said that folks who have read The Kiterunner will be disappointed in the film--the old which is better, book or film, debate. I try never to engage in that because the genres are so different and have different demands in bringing them to fruition. That said, I loved the film as film and also as a very good rendition of the book's central themes of love, betrayal, redemption. The actors are unknown to me so I can only say that the two kids who play Amir and Hassan as children are both terrific, the men who play Baba (he looks a little like Omar Sharif in his day) and Rahim Kahn looked like I thought they would look, and the actor who play Amir as an adult was much better than I was led to believe. The cinematography is awesome--the grandeur of the landscape, the beauty of Kabul before the Russians and then the Taliban turned it into a giant slum with people selling their artificial limbs and Shar'ia law causing behavior that would be hard to believe if that young woman wasn't recently condemned to 200 lashes and jail for being raped (I know she's been pardoned but that doesn't change the fact that she is certainly not the only woman to whom such a thing can happen)--Baba working in an American gas station, the drab CA apartment after the best home in Kabul. And the sky filled with kites is such a beautiful image of the innocent sense of freedom felt by the kids. That image lingers over everything else that happens, at least it did for me, and the ending reinforces my feeling about it.
More to come, folks--hope you get to see some of these superb films.
PidgeOriginal Author
wandaredhead
Related Discussions
How about current movies of the season?
Q
Sleep Apnea
Q
Babel (film)
Q
Movie season!
Q
PidgeOriginal Author
mwoods
andie_rathbone
PidgeOriginal Author
andie_rathbone
leaveswave
wandaredhead
Lisa_H OK
mwoods
sheila
tisha_
andie_rathbone
wandaredhead
PidgeOriginal Author
andie_rathbone
mwoods
wandaredhead
wandaredhead
PidgeOriginal Author
wandaredhead
PidgeOriginal Author
wandaredhead
PidgeOriginal Author