Can/should I fertilize my water garden w/ normal fertilizer?

10 years ago

I've got a wee little container water garden (basically a large ceramic pot full of water, plants, one goldfish, and a few snails). I only very rarely feed the fish (think a flake a week)

Currently, the plants include a Yerba mansa in a floating pot (it's sending off lots of babies, I need to find a home for those soon), a bit of watercress (thank you, nearby Asian market), some pennywort (I think), an unknown bulb that looks kind of like an iris or something (I'll be giving it a proper pot once it's a little taller), and some algae.

Since this is Arizona, the water is alkaline and kind of salty, and it will be getting warm soon. I do partial water changes every week or 3 (basically, when the water reaches ~3/4, I scoop out water 'til it's at ~1/2, then fill it to the brim).

Right now, the plants are all happy and green, and I'd like them to stay that way. But I probably can't afford a special fertilizer designed for aquatic plants. I have some liquid fertilizer intended for normal in-ground type plants (Schultz, 10-15-10 with micronutrients, recommended dosing is 7 drops per quart of water with every watering).

Do you think it would be a good and useful thing to put a few drops of that in the water, or at least put a drop or two in the Yerba mansa's pot (it's looking a little sad)? If not, is there anything else (cheap) that I can or should do to keep my plants happy?

This post was edited by TamTrible on Fri, Feb 21, 14 at 16:35

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

lmjk1221
10 years ago
I wouldn't suggest adding fertilizer to the water. You'll end up encouraging algae growth. Can you take the plants out and fertilize them, let them drain well and then return them to your pond? I fertilize my floating plants by dissolving MiracleGro in a bucket and putting them in it overnight. Then I rinse them off really well and put them back in the pond.
tamtrible
Original Author
10 years ago
Well... the yerba mansa's in a floating pot. Do you think I can safely give it a drop or 2 of fertilizer?
Related Discussions
How often can you fertilize tomato with water-soluble fertilizer?
Q
Comments (15)
Well, I'll chime in with a straight face, MOL..... my 'maters are all in pots, and need water at least twice a day, I mix up some MG in a bucket and pour some into each bucket I have next to each plant, I keep that water-bucket there so all I have to do is dip out some water and not drag the hose all over the yard.. so essentially I am giving each 'mater some liquid fertilizer each time I water...I won't even speculate at what strength but the water is blue, from the MG... most of my 'maters are getting pretty big, they are from last year's planting Tom brought me.... but they are still setting fruit so I keep them going even tho' they are pot-bound now.....I speculate that the only thing that keeps them going is the liquid fert., by now, because any other nutrient in the potting-mix has been long-gone..... works for me.... sally
...See More
should I fertilize my plumeria?
Q
Comments (12)
I don't grow plumeria, but I do grow more than 100 species of trees in containers. The nutritional requirements of plants are very similar, and the ratio of nutrients (one nutrient to the others) used by plants is remarkably similar. As an example, Sunflowers, sedum, sequoia, and snapdragon all use about 1/6 as much P and about 3/5 as much K as N. The rest of the nutrients used fall into a pattern that varies very little in ratio. What varies most is the AMOUNT of nutrients various plants use, rather than the ratio. Based on actual usage, even the common 20-20-20 soluble fertilizer made by so many fertilizer producers is a high phosphorous fertilizer. When using 20-20-20 your plants will use about 3.3 parts of P for every 20 parts of N. After doing the factoring for how P is reported on fertilizer labels, 20-20-20 provides 2.6X more P than your plant can use, so if a grower really thinks he needs an extra measure of P to produce more blooms (he doesn't), it's much better to use a 1:1:1 ratio fertilizer like 20-20-20 than to use a fertilizer that supplies P at problematically high rates. In years past, I used to use Miracle-Gro 24-8-16 or miracle-Gro 12-4-8 fertilizer, which I would fortify with Scott's STEM (soluble trace element micronutrients). It worked very well. When I discovered Foliage-Pro 9-3-6, I knew before I even used it that it was going to be an excellent product. It's easy to use, has ALL the essential nutrients plants normally take from the soil, at the average ratio at which plants actually USE the nutrients (a big plus), and the nutrients are soluble, meaning you don't have to depend on the activity of biotic soil populations to break the nutrients down into a form plants can use. It also doesn't utilize urea as a N source, which helps to keep your plants full and compact. It really is pretty difficult to go wrong using the FP 9-3-6 in combination with a soil you can water to beyond saturation (so your flushing the soil as you water). Best luck. Al
...See More
What soil/fertilizer should be used for my vegetable garden?
Q
Comments (2)
I would mix in an organic ready made fertilizer. The one I used last year came in pellet form in a bag. It was a combo of things like potash, bone meal, rock phosphate, etc. Compost itself is just one source of some nutrients. It's main use is making the soil nice and loose and ready for soil organisms. After planting, I use Miracle Grow spray once in a while. I don't use anyone's compost in my food garden because I have no clue what was in it. Last organic bag I bought had half of an old glittery shoelace mixed in.
...See More
When should I start using fertilizer on my mango trees again
Q
Comments (11)
Hi tropicbreezent, I live in Boynton Beach west of the Turnpike, I have never had my soil tested. Realistically that would be the logical thing to do to determine what type of nutrients and ratio to put back into the ground. My trees produce very well and the varieties I grow are delicious. I would fertilize monthly from March - October perhaps a quarter of the reccomended amount each month up until October at which time I would apply a larger amount with a heavier ratio of potash. TB, my thinking is that I probably only need to fertilize the trees 2 or 3 times a year and water as needed and cutting back on watering from October to February. This winter we had near record rainfall in Palmbeach County. I don't know how that extra rain will affect production this year. I often feel that I throw everything at my trees but they would do just as well with less. I'm trying to find the right balance of fertilizer and schedule to go by. In my surrounding area there are several of us that grow mango trees. Our fertilization plans are all almost the same except one neighbor who does much less but yet has high productivity and very tasty mangos. tropicbreezent thank you for responding and giving your advice, I certainly appreciate it.
...See More
lmjk1221
10 years ago
I'm not sure what you mean by a "floating pot" but I'll assume you can't remove it from the water. I don't think a drop or two would hurt, but the bigger question is will that tiny amount really help?
tamtrible
Original Author
10 years ago
I meant a drop or 2 of the fertilizer concentrate, with directions of "mix 7 drops with a quart of water"...

And the floating pot is... a small (like, 4") pot, with a ring of styrofoam keeping it on the surface. Yerba mansa is more a bog plant than a pond plant, but with a container water garden, I don't have a "bog"... there's roots sticking out the bottom (in quantity), and the string of babies has circumnavigated the pot several times. It would be... annoying to take it out. The other things would be a lot easier to temporarily remove.
lmjk1221
10 years ago
You may want to check out the post about container pond/green water above this one. It's the liquid part of the equation in your case that would concern me. I wouldn't use a fertilizer full strength that's meant to be diluted. And if you're assuming it will become diluted in the water, well, that's kind of the issue.

Some fertilizer will leach into your pond from your plants no matter the method, but in a small pond I would think even a small amount could create a big problem,
tamtrible
Original Author
10 years ago
I suspect, since I don't feed my fish (or, at least, feed him *very* little), and my little pond is currently close to 90% covered with plants, a little fertilizer isn't going to give me a big algae problem. I mostly want to make sure I'm not going to kill Brainiac or something by adding fertilizer that isn't meant for ponds.
chas045
10 years ago
I think this is actually a proportion issue. You have a small volume pond and therefore would need a small amount of fertilizer. lisak has a point that you might need to be more careful than a larger pond manager but if you just pretended that your plants were house plants and responded as directed you would be fine. Yes, some fertilizer would disolve in the pond in low concentration (lower than algae would really appreciate) and then would slowly be picked back up by all the plants as needed.

I thought your question was really about whether 'regular' fertilizer was OK to use; it is as long as you remain on the minimal side rather than casually and perhaps massively overloading with chemicals. For example, many here have used Jobes fertilizer stakes. They are just run of the mill fertilizer in a convenient 'stick it in' form.

Can/should I fertilize my water garden w/ normal fertilizer?

Comments (7)

lmjk1221

tamtrible
Original Author

Related Discussions

lmjk1221

tamtrible
Original Author

lmjk1221

tamtrible
Original Author

chas045

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Can/should I fertilize my water garden w/ normal fertilizer?

Comments (7)

lmjk1221

tamtribleOriginal Author

Related Discussions

lmjk1221

tamtribleOriginal Author

lmjk1221

tamtribleOriginal Author

chas045

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

tamtrible
Original Author

tamtrible
Original Author

tamtrible
Original Author