skip to main content

honda hrx217hxa vs snapper spv21675

16 years ago

I'm pretty much decided on the Honda mower, but at $729 the price is steep. Is it worth the extra $$$ compared to the Snapper that I can pick up for around $389.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

duke88
16 years ago
I have the HRX217HXA and it's a great mower...but that's a big price difference for the Snapper. If the Snapper is new it can't be in the same league as that model Honda. When I was looking for mine I almost bought a Snapper Hi-Vac w/ Kawasaki engine and it was about the same price as the Honda.
mattv21
16 years ago
The Snapper you can buy for $389 must be the SE series, unless you are getting a killer discount. And no, the SE doesn't compare to that Honda. But the Snapper Hi-Vac that you can get for $500-600 certainly _does_ compare. You would not need the commercial version (which is the only Hi-Vac I can think of that would retail for anything close to the $729 you cite for the Honda). You could get a Kawasaki-powered Hi-Vac for less than the Honda, which has a commercial-duty engine anyway. Or you could get a Snapper with a less costly and lighter Briggs engine. I'm a Snapper fan, so I'm obviously biased, but I think there is more value in the Hi-Vac than in Honda mowers.
Related Discussions
Best brand push mower?
Q
Comments (29)
I live in Florida, and have St. Augustine grass (for those familiar with that variety) which is very popular here. It is a wide bladed grass, which is actually more of a vine, and quickly dulls mower blades compared to finer grasses. I have had 2 Hondas, a commercial from 2009, and currently an HRX217HYA, and both with the micro-cut blade system. Not sure if it’s the deck, or blades, but I always get random uncut blades of grass throughout the yard, looking as though they’ve been blown down, and not just missed. I Had a 1997 Honda that I gave to my in laws, and it cuts beautifully. It has an aluminum deck which creates a better vacuum I believe because the left side isn’t as tall as the right if that makes sense. The new Honda’s are like a donut, being the same height all the way around. My dealer suggested letting them sharpen the blades to see if that helps. I figured a new mower’s blades would be sharp, but apparently they aren’t necessarily like they should be. Currently I’m not thrilled with the new Honda decks. I hope a good sharpening will change my mind.
...See More
Honda vs Snapper,Cub Cadet,Toro
Q
Comments (23)
Honda may have good engines, but the plastic decks on their more expensive consumer line would be a deal breaker for me. I would much rather buy an aluminum deck Toro or Lawnboy or a steel deck Snapper. I use to work for Honda as an internal auditor and audited Honda Power Equipments plant in Swepsonville, North Carolina. The plant management told me Honda made the switch from aluminum to plastic to cut costs. I got a Honda Harmony mower for my brother at a company discount. Even though he only uses this mower sparingly as a trim mower and is careful with his equipment, the deck cracked. To top it off Honda delivered this mower without an air filter element and my brother did not catch their mistake until he was doing preventative maintenance, approximately one year after taking delivery. A neighbor bought a plastic deck Honda Harmony a few years ago and did not like its maneuverability and lack of mulching power and gave it to his mother. He bought a much cheaper Troy Built and likes it much better. The Lawnboy Insight Platinum, the Toro Super Recycler, or the Snapper HI-VAC would be better choices than the plastic deck Honda mowers and the Toro and Lawnboy are significantly less expensive. I would choose the Toro if you primarily mulch and the Lawnboy or Snapper if you primarily bag.
...See More
Briggs 600 Series vs. 700 DOV Series Engine
Q
Comments (8)
The following is my opinion. The very best mower engines (in order) are probably: #1 Kawasaki #2 Honda commmercial #3 Briggs OHV #4 Briggs Quantum #5 Honda GC #6 Tecumseh #7 MTD - Chinese engine #8 Kohler - Chinese engine The Briggs Quantum, Honda GC and Tecumseh are all well suited for residential use. I don't have experience with the MTD and Kohler Chinese engines. My opinions are different than some of the experts. I look for the best value. I don't care if the engine is less sophisticated than the other models. If I were looking for a mower for residential use, my choice of engines (in order) would be: #1 Briggs Quantum - Because of the low price, this engine is the best value for home owners. If you hit a rock the top engines will be just as dead as the cheap Briggs. The Briggs Quantum is the easiest engine of the bunch to service. Dealers usually carry the spare parts for servicing. The carburetor is simple to remove, clean, and repair. The valves and valve guides hold up very well. The most common problems are (a) dirty carburetor (b)fuel lines that deteriorate and (c) the plastic air filter housing sometimes warps. #2 Honda GC - This engine will have the same problem as the Briggs Quantum - a dirty carburetor. The carburetor is difficult to service bacause of the installation design. #3 Tecumseh - The basic engine is durable, but the carburetor has the plastic venturi tube with o rings. After a few years, this design deteriorates and carb repairs/replacements are likely. The cheap oil pump is a good feature. #4 Briggs OHV - This engine would make a good boat anchor. The compression release is very sensitive to high altitude. There were some problems with the sparkplug gaps and the carburetor throttle plate sticking. I feel it is a heavy design. #5 Kawasaki - best engine made. Has full oil pressure lubrication. Expect problems related to old fuel. This represents less value to the home owner because of the cost. #6 Honda commercial - 2nd best engine made. Expect problems related to old fuel. The plastic air filter housing warps where it attaches to the carburetor. This represents less value to the home owner because of the cost. #7. MTD Chinese - For a few years, dealers will not have parts. I don't know anything about this engine and the report card has not been developed. #8 Kohler Chinese - same as the MTD. I like the Toro because of the cast aluminum deck.
...See More
Toro 20093 vs. Honda HRX217HXA
Q
Comments (18)
I can't comment on the two listed above too much, but i will comment on the LB Plat. I recently purchased the Lawn Boy 10795, which is similar to the 797, but without the Blade brake. I love it. I was down to that and the toro, and the it was a close call, but went with the LB due to the reputation of the Honda engine and I liked the bagging system. I looked at teh HRX honda at Home Depot, thought it was nice, but was turned off by the drive system. Also, not 100% on what it means, but the Platinum LB has a sealed drive system that is upgraded from the lower level LBs.
...See More
cuff46
Original Author
16 years ago
Do any of the Snappers have the blade brake clutch? The ones I looked at at Sears did NOT have that feature.
mattv21
16 years ago
None that I know of anymore. Snapper tried that about 20 years ago and gave it up. If that's a priority for you, then Snapper isn't going to fit your needs. There are a couple of Toro Super Recyclers that have that, though, and they are also excellent mowers and similar in price to the residential Hi-Vacs.
jopopsy
16 years ago
What made you skip the HiVac w/ the Kawa power plant?
jopopsy
15 years ago
Hey, how come nobody mentions the regular snapper mulchers when comparing to the Honda? From what I have read, the Hi-Vac may not mulch as well as the Honda, but the regular Snapper mulcher should. No?
ericmvest
14 years ago
I bought a CP215517HV a couple of weeks ago for $800 delivered. This is an commercial, 21" HI-VAC with the Honda 5.5 HP GXV160KA12 commercial engine and commercial steel wheels. This was a new, old stock model. The current commercial HI-VAC model has a plastic control panel with a cup holder and a slightly different ground speed control. The dealer included a side discharge chute and mulch cover at no additional cost. These are extra cost options on the commercial HI-VAC model.

Another Snapper dealer offered me a CRP2160KWV for $750. This is the current commerical mulching model with the commerical Kawasaki FJ180V engine and commercial steel wheels. This dealer offered to included a side discharge chute and rear bag kit at no additional cost. These are extra cost options on the commercial mulching model.

From my experience you can get a commerical Snapper 21" HI-VAC or mulching model for about the same price at the consumer grade HRX217K2HXA. To get the Honda 5.5 HP comercial GXV160KA12 engine that came on my new Snapper in a Honda mower you would have to buy the $1,169 Honda Commercial HRC216K3HXA model. Both the Snapper and the Honda commerical mowers have 14 guage steel decks and the consumer grade Honda HRX217K2HXA has a plastic deck. I have a brother who bought a plastic deck Honda Harmony. Even though he is careful with his equipment and only uses the Harmony for trim work, the deck cracked. Since Honda deems steel decks better suited for their commercial mowers and my brother's cracked deck experience, I prefer Snapper's steel deck over the HRX217K2HXA's plastic deck.

0

Sponsored

More Discussions

Fall into Cleanliness: Join the Discussion on Fall Cleaning Services

0

can anyone identify these bugs?

1

Custom zero turn mower bag attachment

0

Looking for cordless walk behind trimmer

2

Looking for edger with blade

0