skip to main content

Fruit & Orchards

Cherry Question

15 years ago

In the Fall of 2002 I planted two sweet cherry trees from Stark Bros. One was a Stella and the other a Bing. The Stella was advertised as a dwarf and the other semi-dwarf. Both trees are about the same size, nothing dwarf about either. They have fruited for the first time.

I picked about 4 gallons of the Stella cherries Wednesday. The quirrels and birds had been very active in the tree, the taste of the cherries did not seem to vary much from the darkest to the lightest in color.

Also, the skin was cracking on some of them from over ripeness or from the wet spring, so I picked. Perhaps I picked too early.

I was quite disappointed in the taste. Not knowing what a ripe stella cherry was suppose to taste like raises several questions.

Stark Bros. was going through a transition to new owners somewhere around the time I ordered about a dozen fruit trees from them. There have been problems with other fruit trees from them. So, I wonder if I do really have Stella cherries, esp. since I obviously did not get a dwarf tree.

Of those who know what a Stella cherry is like, how does it rate in sweetness? What is the apperance of a ripe Stella cherry. The outward apperance looked similar to what I have seen at the grocery store described as Rainer, the inside flesh was white except in rare instances where red color had run into the inside flesh, perhaps from being overripe.

I have yet to pick the tree described and sold as Bing from Stark Bros. Some of these cherries appear to be getting darker in color which leads me to believe these may be Bing. This tree is not as full by a long shot.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

fruitnut Z7 4500ft SW TX
15 years ago
I had a Stella that produced for about 10 yrs in West Texas. The fruit is only a medium red when fully ripe. I didn't think the quality was good at all. Even when fully ripe they weren't very sweet. They rated with the poor ones from the store. Didn't have any other varieties at that time. Have grown some Bings here that have been great.

You need some way to get some of your crop fully ripe on the tree. That is the only way you will be sure of the quality.

The Fruitnut
letsski
15 years ago
I have to disagree with fruitnut on the color of the Stella,

I have one that is about 18 years old. The Stella needs to be very dark purple before picking. It is very sweet and quite prolific when the conditions are right.

I have found over the years that you really need to wait until the last possible moment to pick, otherwise they are average at best.

My guess is that yours were not ready.

I am going to try to post a picture of mine as here in the Bay Area it is just about ready to pick.

Letsski
Related Discussions
Sweet Cherry question
Q
Comments (2)
Mrs G. I used to have a Black Tartarian cherry at my old house. The tree was loaded every year because my Lapins cherry pollinated it. He needs to buy another sweet cherry variety to pollinate them. Tony
...See More
Carmine jewel cherry questions
Q
Comments (8)
They have been the rage since Evans was rediscovered and since carmine jewel was developed. Hard to believe thats almost 15 years now! They are bred mainly for the mid prairie climate in central saskatchewan (in saskatoon). Anything surviving their trials should be hardy to zone 3 at least by what ive read. They are considered trouble free there because many if not most pests and diseases are non existent up there. I havnt found any other information about their resistances out of the prairies or more northern locations. I have read over and over how carefree they are. After going through more info, I am curious as to whether or not you could grow it as a multi stemmed tree rather then a "fruit bush".
...See More
purple leaf sand cherry question
Q
Comments (1)
a pic would sure help .... i dont understand why you think cutting stuff off.. will help thicken it.. but then i cant really see the plant ... are they tree form .. or shrub form ... and i am not sure.. i would be doing it right now .... within a month.. they should be slowing down for winter ... if you cut them now.. they MIGHT ... go into a vegetative growth phase.. and not properly harden off in fall .. whatever you do.. no more fert .. if you use any ... google rejuvenation pruning of flowering shrubs ... that would be how i do it.. cutting some down to 3 inches or so ... hoping that 2 or 3 new ones would replace the one taken ... you do it this way.. because if you do it at height ... then you get to 2 or 3 way out there.. and next thing you know.. they are flopping on the ground.. because that spindly trunk cant hold it all up ... ken
...See More
I Have Some Nanking Cherry Questions...
Q
Comments (12)
I can't imagine that anyone would try to go to the trouble of pitting something the size of the nankings I've grown -- they're just too small and there's not enough flesh on the pit -- but I like them anyway for what they are. They're very pretty in the spring, seem relatively trouble-free, and I like to snack on them like I would wild strawberries or black raspberries or other small fruits that you don't tend to find in significant quantities but are nice to snack on anyway. Taste-wise I'd compare them to a good but not great and definitely not particularly sweet sour cherry.
...See More
Scott F Smith
15 years ago
It sounds like you picked them "way not ready", not just "not ready". Thats why the birds and squirrels had not yet eaten them all, they prefer their fruit ripe as well :-) The birds are doing a major number on my cherries right now.

Scott
gardenmom_1985
15 years ago
There are only 2 truly dwarfing rootstocks available for cherry, as far as I know: Gisela 5 and Krymsk 5, so make sure you know what your rootstock is before you buy. If the person selling doesn't know, then it isn't. With these you can prune to a vase and keep the tree at about 10 feet and it won't be too hard to net so that you can actually ripen the fruit before the birds get them. It was the wetness that caused cracking in your cherries, not ripeness. Vandalay is my favorite cherry, black, just like Bing, but resistant to cracking, and self fruitful so it sets fruit in poor weather. In our rainy spring this year in Western Washington my tiny one year old tree that the deer pruned last summer so it really is tiny (less than 4 feet high) set 6 cherries! It is on Gisela 5. You don't need another tree for pollination. You can get them from Raintree, but it is too late for this year.
hoseman
Original Author
15 years ago
Fruitnut, you are so correct. I picked the Bing Cherries yesterday, even though many were not completely ripe, they were sweeter than the Stella. Gardenmom, thanks for the suggestion on Vandalay.
ca_cherry_grower
15 years ago
I have one Stella tree plantd 15 years ago. For me, the Bings are better. I think Stella is better suited where Bings don't do well. They both get really dark when ripe. Most sweet cherry varieties I know will get really dark when getting very ripe.

Stark Brothers may not be the only one labeling rootstocks as dwarf that don't really dwarf. I have seen both Mahaleb and Colt labeled as semi-dwarf and both of the rootstocks can easily grow beyond 25 feet.

Related Stories

Design Dilemmas: 5 Questions for Design Stars

By Annie Thornton

Share Your Design Know-How on the Houzz Questions Board

MATERIALS Woodipedia: Is It Cherry or Is It Alder?

By Marci Crestani

Learn the differences between these two wood types, as well as costs, sustainability and a caution about finishing

REMODELING GUIDES Your Floors: Zebra, Tiger, and Teak Wood, Oh, My!

Get the Pros and Cons of Exotic Woods: Hickory, Cherry, Rosewood and More

FURNITURE Smart Shopper: How to Judge Antique Furniture Quality

Pick the treasures from the trash without expert experience by learning how to evaluate antiques and what questions to ask

KITCHEN DESIGN A Cook’s 6 Tips for Buying Kitchen Appliances

By Christine Tusher

An avid home chef answers tricky questions about choosing the right oven, stovetop, vent hood and more

BEDROOMS Houzz Quiz: What Color Should You Paint Your Bedroom Walls?

By Jennifer Ott Design

Cool and soothing, or warm and spicy? Answer these questions and learn what hue is right for you

EDIBLE GARDENS Summer Crops: How to Grow Tomatoes

By Marianne Lipanovich

Plant tomato seedlings in spring for one of the best tastes of summer, fresh from your backyard

FURNITURE How to Mix Wood Furniture Finishes

By Love Your Room LLC

Furniture doesn't need to match to look good; add character and charm to your home with mismatched — but complementary — tones

KITCHEN DESIGN Design Dilemma: Lightening Up a Kitchen

By Annie Thornton

What counters and accents could balance the wood in this kitchen?

TREES 6 Unsung Spring-Blooming Trees

Billowy blooms and rare fragrances will make you wonder how these flowering trees could ever have been underused in landscapes

Sponsored

More Discussions

what is wrong with my indoor mango????

13

Peach variety recommendations, please

2

beginning fruit or new leaves

6

No flowers on my apricot tree?

6

What's causing this strawberry problem?

2