Comments (23)
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
carlinaia

Elise: I designed my 7'w. X 2'd maple butcher block counter in 1981, when I built the kitchen. I took my cues from butcher shops and made it thick enough to be able to strip the surface, which I've sanded twice to clear up deeper cut marks, the most recent caused by chopping meat with a heavy cleaver. My prep sink (21"x18"x8") makes this area work central. I scrub it with bleach solution after cutting meats and oil it every two to three weeks or after heavy use (for party prep). How many other surfaces do you know of that can handle this treatment for 36 years. If it were ever to need replacing it's easy, cheap and fast. Can't say the same for all my other counters, which are granite. If properly cared for it will provide decades of service and can look good as new. Wish I could say the same for me....


1 Like    
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
User

@Elise Amiot It all depends on how a person wants their counter to look today, tomorrow or next year and beyond. If you want your butcher block counter to look used and worn, then by all means, chop away on the counter. If you are just wanting that beautiful butcher block look today and tomorrow, then pull out your cutting board. The both - used and unused will need maintenance since it's wood.

1 Like    
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Loren D
Hmmmm, some comments on here are making me second think the possibility of a second island;)
2 Likes    

Related Stories

Kitchen Design 25 Kitchen Islands That Think Outside the Box
For these asymmetrical, rounded, split-level, wedge-like and otherwise unconventional islands, it’s hip not to be cuboid
Full Story
Pendant Lighting Choose the Right Pendant Lights for Your Kitchen Island
Get your island lighting scheme on track with tips on function, style, height and more
Full Story
Kitchen Makeovers Before and After: 5 Kitchens With Contrasting Wood Islands
Pros, including one found on Houzz, pair wood-finished islands with painted cabinets for a pleasing look
Full Story
New This Week 5 New Kitchens With Clever Island Designs
Consider these unusual shapes, functional features and stylish looks from photos recently uploaded by pros on Houzz
Full Story
Kitchen Design 15 Ways to Kick Your Kitchen Island Up a Notch
Make your kitchen island work harder — and smarter — with these fun and functional features
Full Story
Kitchen Design 10 Kitchen Island Features Pros Always Recommend
Design and remodeling professionals say these are the elements every homeowner should consider when planning an island
Full Story
Houzz TV 5 Kitchen Island Features Worth Considering
In this video and article, get details on clever island designs that add seating, style, countertop surface and more
Full Story
New This Week 9 New Kitchen Island Designs
Get the lowdown on down-low dining spots, raised-up workstations and other island features shared by pros on Houzz
Full Story
Before and Afters Before and After: 4 White Kitchens With Contrasting Islands
See how a splash of gray, blue or green makes a kitchen island stand out in a sea of white cabinets
Full Story
Most Popular How Much Room Do You Need for a Kitchen Island?
Installing an island can enhance your kitchen in many ways, and with good planning, even smaller kitchens can benefit
Full Story