Houzz Tour: Suspended Garden Wows in a New York Loft
A ‘micro courtyard’ hangs in clear view from the inside of this former warehouse to create a rare connection to the outdoors
Mitchell Parker
July 31, 2016
Houzz Editorial Staff. Home design journalist writing about cool spaces, innovative trends, breaking news, industry analysis and humor.
Houzz Editorial Staff. Home design journalist writing about cool spaces, innovative... More
Houzz at a Glance
Who lives here: A couple in finance
Location: Tribeca neighborhood of New York City
Size: 3,000 square feet (279 square meters); three bedrooms, three bathrooms
Architect Andrew Franz didn’t want his clients to pass up an opportunity that comes only once in a lifetime. The couple, both in finance, were looking to buy a place in New York City that would require only modest renovations. But when Franz saw a messy unfinished studio with raw concrete floors, he urged his clients to jump on it.
Why? The unfinished unit occupied the top floor of a low-key building in Tribeca, one of New York’s most desirable neighborhoods. The top position gives the unit roof rights, meaning whoever renovated it could create a dramatic outdoor space — an extreme rarity in the city — overlooking the Hudson River. “They would have carte blanche to do what they wanted with it,” Franz says. “You don’t stumble on something like this every day.”
But if an outdoor space is hard to come by in the city, try an outdoor space indoors. To get that one-of-a-kind amenity, the couple and Franz punched a hole in the roof to create a suspended glass-encased garden that hangs like a green oasis right in the loft interior, shown here.
Who lives here: A couple in finance
Location: Tribeca neighborhood of New York City
Size: 3,000 square feet (279 square meters); three bedrooms, three bathrooms
Architect Andrew Franz didn’t want his clients to pass up an opportunity that comes only once in a lifetime. The couple, both in finance, were looking to buy a place in New York City that would require only modest renovations. But when Franz saw a messy unfinished studio with raw concrete floors, he urged his clients to jump on it.
Why? The unfinished unit occupied the top floor of a low-key building in Tribeca, one of New York’s most desirable neighborhoods. The top position gives the unit roof rights, meaning whoever renovated it could create a dramatic outdoor space — an extreme rarity in the city — overlooking the Hudson River. “They would have carte blanche to do what they wanted with it,” Franz says. “You don’t stumble on something like this every day.”
But if an outdoor space is hard to come by in the city, try an outdoor space indoors. To get that one-of-a-kind amenity, the couple and Franz punched a hole in the roof to create a suspended glass-encased garden that hangs like a green oasis right in the loft interior, shown here.
Franz felt that his clients might not be inclined to use a rooftop garden if it remained unseen. By dropping a portion of the garden into the interior, the homeowners can enjoy the view and be encouraged to venture up and outdoors. “It’s like a micro courtyard,” he says.
The drop-down garden also allowed light to flood into the unit “rather than cutting a million skylights in the roof,” he says.
Franz used the ceiling joists he cut out for the garden to create the staircase treads and landings. The railings are blackened steel.
Side table: Oscar, Otto collection, Andrew Franz; table lamp: vintage Gordon and Jane Martz, Rewire Gallery; stool: Catenary, Token; pendant lights: Alberto, Otto collection, Andrew Franz
The drop-down garden also allowed light to flood into the unit “rather than cutting a million skylights in the roof,” he says.
Franz used the ceiling joists he cut out for the garden to create the staircase treads and landings. The railings are blackened steel.
Side table: Oscar, Otto collection, Andrew Franz; table lamp: vintage Gordon and Jane Martz, Rewire Gallery; stool: Catenary, Token; pendant lights: Alberto, Otto collection, Andrew Franz
Here you can see the garden from the living room. The garden is part of a mezzanine that includes a small seating area to the right.
Furnishings in the loft are a mix of vintage and custom pieces. Franz and his firm designed the sofa and coffee table, and the end table is part of his firm’s furniture line. Many of the bought pieces are vintage Danish designs. The chandelier came from a former East German parliament building.
A fire many decades ago charred the columns, which were then painted over by previous owners. Franz tried having them stripped and sanded, but his crew couldn’t get through the blackness. “I was alarmed at first but then realized it’s quite beautiful, and we embraced the charred finish,” he says.
The columns are also twisted and distorted, a fact made more prominent when Franz brought in the more finished straight lines of the mezzanine and cabinetry. “I learned a long time ago that you have to embrace your obstacles,” he says.
Sectional: Otto collection, Andrew Franz; sectional fabric: Bosforo, Brochier; coffee table: custom, Andrew Franz Architect; chairs: vintage AP16 by Hans Wegner; vintage banded kilim rug: Double Knot; chandelier: vintage Module I light fixture by Peter Rockel, Palast der Republik; side table: Tequila, Karkula; photographs: Peter Margonelli
Furnishings in the loft are a mix of vintage and custom pieces. Franz and his firm designed the sofa and coffee table, and the end table is part of his firm’s furniture line. Many of the bought pieces are vintage Danish designs. The chandelier came from a former East German parliament building.
A fire many decades ago charred the columns, which were then painted over by previous owners. Franz tried having them stripped and sanded, but his crew couldn’t get through the blackness. “I was alarmed at first but then realized it’s quite beautiful, and we embraced the charred finish,” he says.
The columns are also twisted and distorted, a fact made more prominent when Franz brought in the more finished straight lines of the mezzanine and cabinetry. “I learned a long time ago that you have to embrace your obstacles,” he says.
Sectional: Otto collection, Andrew Franz; sectional fabric: Bosforo, Brochier; coffee table: custom, Andrew Franz Architect; chairs: vintage AP16 by Hans Wegner; vintage banded kilim rug: Double Knot; chandelier: vintage Module I light fixture by Peter Rockel, Palast der Republik; side table: Tequila, Karkula; photographs: Peter Margonelli
Bluestone pavers and river rock form the base of the garden floor. Though there’s a drain in the floor, the garden also has a retractable roof that can close the area off to rain and snow.
Chairs and triangular table: Leaf collection, Arper; retractable roof: Rollamatic Roofs
Chairs and triangular table: Leaf collection, Arper; retractable roof: Rollamatic Roofs
BEFORE: Previous owners hadn’t done anything with the rooftop, which enjoys views of the Hudson River.
AFTER: The area now features a partial green roof and deck with sitting, dining and grilling areas. Most of the plants are what would be native to the area. “Outdoor space in New York is a precious commodity,” Franz says.
Iroko sofa and chair: Niek collection, Piet Boon; low iroko table: Annet, Piet Boon; green chairs: Leaf collection, Arper; end table: Petal by Richard Schultz, Knoll
Iroko sofa and chair: Niek collection, Piet Boon; low iroko table: Annet, Piet Boon; green chairs: Leaf collection, Arper; end table: Petal by Richard Schultz, Knoll
This angle shows the retractable roof, which slides over the opened portion to keep rain and snow out when needed.
BEFORE: The building had been converted to lofts in the 1980s, Franz says, but only modestly. Before that, the unit was once a warehouse for caviar, so when Franz’s clients bought it, the floors were still raw concrete with drains in them (to allow ice to melt and drain away). The vast expanses of brick wall were painted and tarred (to aid in refrigeration). It took Franz’s crew a long time to restore all the brick. “It wasn’t pretty,” he says.
AFTER: A custom cabinet and bench create a vestibule, and screen the entry from the rest of the apartment.
BEFORE: The unit previously had a mezzanine, but it was in an area beneath the gull-wing roof that made you have to duck beneath pipes to move through it.
AFTER: Franz moved the mezzanine level to the wall of windows and created a new kitchen in its former location.
He kept the material palette simple. Most of the wood in the apartment is American walnut. Any stone is bluestone, including the countertops and floors in the kitchen. And all the tile, with a few exceptions, is from Heath (in 11 colors). “There was a strong intent not to have a million materials,” he says.
A raised portion of walnut cabinetry conceals messes left in or near a second sink. “That way, when you’re in the living room, you don’t feel like you’re staring into a kitchen,” he says.
Tall cabinets allow the space to look more proportional in scale.
The top of the cabinets align with the bottom of the mezzanine and a bank of custom cabinets in the living room. “It creates a nice datum all the way around that’s calming and consistent,” he says.
Pendant lights: Cheope SP-P-D1, Vistosi; stools: Catenary, Token; countertops: custom, New York bluestone; base cabinets: walnut; upper cabinets: opaque lacquer; cooktop: Wolf; faucets: Dornbracht; sink: Franke
He kept the material palette simple. Most of the wood in the apartment is American walnut. Any stone is bluestone, including the countertops and floors in the kitchen. And all the tile, with a few exceptions, is from Heath (in 11 colors). “There was a strong intent not to have a million materials,” he says.
A raised portion of walnut cabinetry conceals messes left in or near a second sink. “That way, when you’re in the living room, you don’t feel like you’re staring into a kitchen,” he says.
Tall cabinets allow the space to look more proportional in scale.
The top of the cabinets align with the bottom of the mezzanine and a bank of custom cabinets in the living room. “It creates a nice datum all the way around that’s calming and consistent,” he says.
Pendant lights: Cheope SP-P-D1, Vistosi; stools: Catenary, Token; countertops: custom, New York bluestone; base cabinets: walnut; upper cabinets: opaque lacquer; cooktop: Wolf; faucets: Dornbracht; sink: Franke
The kitchen is open to the living room. Franz exposed the ceiling joists by removing a hammered tin ceiling. “The goal was to maintain transparency and openness,” he says.
Cabinet pulls: Rajack, Nanz
Cabinet pulls: Rajack, Nanz
A dining area sits beneath the mezzanine and features all midcentury Danish furniture. “The clients were very sympathetic to that period and the craftsmanship and aesthetic,” Franz says.
Pendant light: vintage Counterbalance, Arteluce; mirror: 48 inches, Orange; sideboard: vintage NV54, Niels Vodder; dining table: vintage by Finn Juhl, Niels Vodder; chairs: PP701, PP Møbler; green rug: Greta, Kashthall; steel windows: Shelton Studio
Pendant light: vintage Counterbalance, Arteluce; mirror: 48 inches, Orange; sideboard: vintage NV54, Niels Vodder; dining table: vintage by Finn Juhl, Niels Vodder; chairs: PP701, PP Møbler; green rug: Greta, Kashthall; steel windows: Shelton Studio
A reupholstered original Womb chair sits next to a bank of walnut cabinetry in a small TV room that leads to the guest bedrooms.
Chair: vintage Womb by Eero Saarinen, Knoll; daybed: vintage Ralph Rapson, Knoll; area rug: Stubb, Kasthall; lamp: Wyeth
Chair: vintage Womb by Eero Saarinen, Knoll; daybed: vintage Ralph Rapson, Knoll; area rug: Stubb, Kasthall; lamp: Wyeth
A bank of interior windows separates the guest bedrooms from the rest of the loft, and helps light bounce through the spaces.
Adjustable wall light (right): vintage Alvar Aalto; overhead light fixture (right): Taraxacum, Flos; chair: Wormley, Dunbar; chair fabric: Castel; art: Peter Margonelli; artistic wall light (far right, foreground): Gio Ponti
Adjustable wall light (right): vintage Alvar Aalto; overhead light fixture (right): Taraxacum, Flos; chair: Wormley, Dunbar; chair fabric: Castel; art: Peter Margonelli; artistic wall light (far right, foreground): Gio Ponti
The guest bedrooms feature the same vintage midcentury modern stylings found elsewhere in the loft.
Pendant light: Ettore, Otto collection, Andrew Franz; rotating sconce: MSC-R1C, Serge Mouille; headboard: custom, Otto collection, Andrew Franz; nightstand: vintage George Nelson, Herman Miller; bed: Dux 818, Duxiana; footstool: Papa Bear, A.P. Stolen; drapery and Roman shade: Angel Threads; window treatment hardware: Morgik Metal Designs; rug: Minore 113, Hanna Korvela
Pendant light: Ettore, Otto collection, Andrew Franz; rotating sconce: MSC-R1C, Serge Mouille; headboard: custom, Otto collection, Andrew Franz; nightstand: vintage George Nelson, Herman Miller; bed: Dux 818, Duxiana; footstool: Papa Bear, A.P. Stolen; drapery and Roman shade: Angel Threads; window treatment hardware: Morgik Metal Designs; rug: Minore 113, Hanna Korvela
They also showcase custom headboards designed by Franz.
Sconce: vintage Alvar Aalto; nightstand: George Nelson
Sconce: vintage Alvar Aalto; nightstand: George Nelson
A custom walnut vanity in a guest bathroom is an homage to Danish design. The side opens to reveal a red lacquered interior with a magazine rack. The small drawer on the front holds extra toilet paper rolls. The wall is clad in three different colors of tile, though it’s hard to tell from the photo. The countertop is marble.
Mirror: Grant, Schoolhouse Electric & Supply Co.; sconce: vintage Sergio Mazza; vanity: custom, Andrew Franz Architect; tile: Heath; faucet: Waterworks; sink: Toto
Mirror: Grant, Schoolhouse Electric & Supply Co.; sconce: vintage Sergio Mazza; vanity: custom, Andrew Franz Architect; tile: Heath; faucet: Waterworks; sink: Toto
A bench made of live-edge wood sits in a dressing room that’s part of a guest hall. The custom cabinets open with custom leather pulls.
This floor plan shows the overview of the loft, with the garden on the left and the bedrooms to the right.
This cross section shows the gull-wing-shaped roof line, and how moving the mezzanine from the center of the loft to the far left allowed for more headroom.
Browse more homes by style: Apartments | Barn Homes | Colorful Homes | Contemporary Homes | Eclectic Homes | Farmhouses | Floating Homes | Guesthouses | Homes Around the World | Lofts | Midcentury Homes | Modern Homes | Ranch Homes | Small Homes | Townhouses | Traditional Homes | Transitional Homes | Vacation Homes
Browse more homes by style: Apartments | Barn Homes | Colorful Homes | Contemporary Homes | Eclectic Homes | Farmhouses | Floating Homes | Guesthouses | Homes Around the World | Lofts | Midcentury Homes | Modern Homes | Ranch Homes | Small Homes | Townhouses | Traditional Homes | Transitional Homes | Vacation Homes
Related Stories
Houzz TV
Houzz TV: Step Inside an Industrial-Chic Forever Home
See how a former commercial space becomes an art-filled dream home for 2
Full Story
Kitchen Design
Gray Cabinets and a Wood-Wrapped Fireplace Update a Downtown Loft
The kitchen peninsula is jazzed up with custom wallpaper made using a photo from the homeowners’ Amsterdam honeymoon
Full Story
My Houzz
My Houzz: White Paint and Light Floors Transform a Chicago Loft
Fresh holiday ideas add a festive touch to a couple’s renovated Scandinavian- and industrial-style home
Full Story
My Houzz
My Houzz: Books and String Lights Cozy Up an L.A. Loft
Devoted hours and Disneyland-like whimsy create a strikingly personal style in downtown Los Angeles
Full Story
Modern Homes
My Houzz: Splashes of Color in a Modern Arizona Loft
Artwork, travel mementos and midcentury furniture come together in this home in a Tucson residential community
Full Story
Houzz Tours
Houzz Tour: Boutique Hotel-Inspired Makeover for a San Diego Loft
Check out these before-and-after pictures to see the dramatic transformation of a downtown industrial loft in California
Full Story
My Houzz
My Houzz: A Restaurateur’s Lush and Luxe Chicago Loft
An artistic eye and the right cat make this spacious Bucktown condo a fun and very personal home
Full Story
Small Homes
My Houzz: Sweet Vintage Touches in an 1865 Cincinnati Loft
Collected farmhouse-style decor fits in beautifully in this couple’s cozy rented apartment
Full Story
My Houzz
My Houzz: A Moody Industrial Loft in Boston
By Faith Towers
A couple’s ‘moderate minimalist’ style works well with the raw finishes of their open space
Full Story
My Houzz
My Houzz: Pretty Pinks and Neutrals in a Boho-Chic Loft
By Faith Towers
Macramé blends with midcentury cool in this couple’s converted 1887 Rhode Island rental. Plus: An adorable cat tepee
Full Story
This is one of the best & most inspiring renovations I've seen one Houzz. I love it all & there are so many smart ideas that integrate function & great design. Wow!
Just stunning! Applause to the architect and the homeowners for an artistic new home!
What an innovative and amazing design. This really "WOW"s me.