You know yourself best. I think hickory can be nice, but your second photo... that's just WAY too busy and rustic (and honestly, a bit homely) for the rest of the kitchen. I would feel ZERO guilt in having those painted, some white or pale gray that goes with the counters. Like in Grover's painted mockup, would transform and civilize the kitchen. No guilt, would do immediately.
Q
Pendant lighting
Q