Explore Your Garden Personality: The Collector
Abundant in plants, art or even oddball items? These principles can help you make sense of them in the landscape
Jay Sifford
January 12, 2014
We gardeners are as varied as the spaces we create. Some of us are artists, creating beautiful, balanced vignettes; some are philosophers, finding meaning in a sparse but thoughtfully executed space. Then there are the collectors, sometimes eccentric or uberserious but always fun, passionately driven to have the newest, greatest, rarest and best. You will frequently find collectors at the farmer’s market early on a Saturday morning, at botanical garden plant sales, at flea markets or reading specialty plant catalogs with an intensity usually reserved for bestselling novels.
Perhaps you are a self-proclaimed blatant collector or perhaps, like most gardeners, your personality or archetype is split. Most collectors, whether they will admit it or not, could use a bit of help to tame their collections through cohesive design principles.
Perhaps you are a self-proclaimed blatant collector or perhaps, like most gardeners, your personality or archetype is split. Most collectors, whether they will admit it or not, could use a bit of help to tame their collections through cohesive design principles.
My garden has been very forgiving and patient with me. My collection phases have historically resembled the Chinese calendar. There was the year of the heuchera and the year of the hosta; then came daylilies, Oriental lilies, Japanese maples and conifers. In my evolving zeal for collecting, some of these plants survived, some died and some were removed.
Then came the art. There was ceramic art, rusted steel sculpture, blown glass, oversize pottery, wind sculpture, even a set of antique Chinese doors. What was I to do?
An honest garden designer will frequently tell you that it is easier to design a garden for someone else than for yourself. Good judgment with regard to design principles is easily clouded by emotional attachment to heirloom plants or collected art. If you are an out-of-control collector, a good garden designer could be your best friend.
If the thought of hiring a garden designer to brutally tame your collection scares you, and buying the vacant lot next door for expansion isn’t a possibility, there are some design principles you can employ to test the waters. Depending on what you collect, some of these principles will apply more specifically to your garden than others.
An honest garden designer will frequently tell you that it is easier to design a garden for someone else than for yourself. Good judgment with regard to design principles is easily clouded by emotional attachment to heirloom plants or collected art. If you are an out-of-control collector, a good garden designer could be your best friend.
If the thought of hiring a garden designer to brutally tame your collection scares you, and buying the vacant lot next door for expansion isn’t a possibility, there are some design principles you can employ to test the waters. Depending on what you collect, some of these principles will apply more specifically to your garden than others.
Group collectibles together. Marcia Donahue is as much a collector as she is a celebrated ceramic artist. Integrating her whimsical collection of hundreds of bowling balls into a garden would have been a daunting task for any garden designer. One good solution: Group similar items together. This principle is especially helpful if collected items are small and similar in shape. Go ahead and make a bold statement. You know you want to.
Perhaps your collection is a bit tamer than the one shown previously. The designer of the garden shown here created a spectacular display of heathers by grouping them together. By doing this she emphasized both their similarities and unique qualities. Additionally, the dwarf conifers interspersed throughout the space pull the eye and create rhythm. If the collection had been dispersed throughout the property, much of the impact would have been lost.
Embrace similarities. Find the common thread in your collection. Perhaps it is color, as shown in this photo. By embracing the common thread and allowing plants to show off their individuality with regard to texture or shape, you can create continuity while allowing parts of your collection to shine with their own unique qualities.
Use a ground cover as a unifying element. Just as an area rug can tie a room full of disparate furniture together, a ground cover can weave cohesiveness into a disparate collection of plants. Notice how this carpet of Mazus reptans (USDA zones 5 to 8) brings unity to this collection of sedges, ferns, nandina and Brunnera.
Discover sight lines. I believe no garden is complete without at least one sculptural element. I also believe there is a fine line between just enough art and too much art. This can be a difficult concept for the collector to grasp.
Almost every garden has multiple sight lines; the entire garden is not usually visible from any one vantage point. The collector can use this to his or her advantage with regard to art placement. A well-placed shrub, a screen, a wall or even a house corner can create a new opportunity for siting art. Placing art this way adds a new dimension of depth and discovery to a space. Depending on size and how much attention each piece commands, try to limit your art to one to three pieces per sight line. That is enough.
Almost every garden has multiple sight lines; the entire garden is not usually visible from any one vantage point. The collector can use this to his or her advantage with regard to art placement. A well-placed shrub, a screen, a wall or even a house corner can create a new opportunity for siting art. Placing art this way adds a new dimension of depth and discovery to a space. Depending on size and how much attention each piece commands, try to limit your art to one to three pieces per sight line. That is enough.
Rediscover simplicity. Sometimes the devil is in the details and less is more. If your garden collection is frantically driving you instead of bringing you peaceful enjoyment, it may be time for decisions and change. I know many collectors who have reached this point. Evaluate your plants; take note of those that are performing well and those that aren’t. Consider planting a single species en masse. In the end you won’t be sorry.
More: What Kind of Gardener Are You? Find Your Archetype
More: What Kind of Gardener Are You? Find Your Archetype
Related Products
Hope Restoration is Central Ohio's only full-service, design/build general contractor capable of every facet of... Read More
Related Stories
Porches
Porch of the Week: Catching a Breeze in Austin, Texas
By Becky Harris
The new screened-in space has a beautiful fireplace as a focal point and includes lounging and dining spaces
Full Story
Before and Afters
Before and After: 4 Landscapes That Bring Resort Style Home
Stunning fire pits, luxurious pools, elegant entertaining zones and other relaxing spots give these yards vacation vibes
Full Story
Before and Afters
Before and After: 3 Exuberant, Wildlife-Friendly Landscapes
By Elena Vega
Ho-hum expanses give way to colorful meadow-inspired gardens that encourage butterflies, birds and bees to stay awhile
Full Story
Landscape Design
7 Key Features to Include in Your New Landscape Design
By Kate Burt
Looking to create a gorgeous outdoor space that suits your home and lifestyle? Start by considering these options
Full Story
Events
Outdoor Flooring, Turf and Tile Products for 2024
By Julie Sheer
See the latest materials for patios, decks and yards displayed at the recent Surfaces trade show
Full Story
Saving Water
10 Gardens That Capture and Drain Water With Style
Landscape pros design beautiful and hardworking gardens that effectively drain and manage rainwater and runoff
Full Story
Before and Afters
Yard of the Week: Ranch Home Opens Up to Indoor-Outdoor Living
A home and landscape makeover near Denver creates harmony and connection between interior and exterior spaces
Full Story
Patios
15 Outdoor Spaces That Rock Permeable Paving
These patios, paths and driveways showcase beautiful and integrated drainage solutions
Full Story
Outbuildings
Family Gatherings in Argentina Inspire a Pavilion and Guesthouse
By Becky Harris
A new yard adds room for hosting, swimming and bringing part of one homeowner’s culture to her family’s Seattle home
Full Story
Gardening Guides
What Will We Want in Our Landscapes in 2024?
Discover seven trends that landscape designers predict homeowners will be bringing into their outdoor spaces this year
Full Story
My favorite plant lately is the Heuchera Paris, blooms all season, great foliage and perfect massed or as accent.
I believe we were separated at birth! I, too, am a Collector with Romantic and other tendencies. I am married to Whimsical - which only minimally describes me. Our archetype is "Chaos!"
Jay, thank you for a wonderful article.