I have grown both, Jude for 16 years, and Golden Celebration for at least 13 years. I love both of them, and each has its strong points. Golden Celebration is a continunous bloomer for me. Jude's rebloom is erratic, but for beauty, it can only be beat by Augusta Luise and Evelyn (in my opinion--ha). Many love Jude's scent, but I barely notice it. Both roses are huge in my garden, 8-9 feet tall and quite wide. I love the way Golden Cel grows with its neighbor Boscobel. I would say GC is the better all around rose, and Jude is the more beautiful. Diane
Q