I think it looks great!
You may just be in shock compared to what you're used to seeing. I would consider removing the shutters and painting the garage door to match (as suggested by others). You could brighten the landscaping up a bit with flowering bushes. I personally love the look of white hydrangea bushes. Also, I would make sure both the fixtures that flank the garage door match. I like the scale of the larger fixture.
Side note: Did you know the city can remove the old telephone lines to the home for free? It really eliminates visual clutter to the front of the home....assuming you no longer use a land line.
Q