I like the set you have and do not think replacing it with the Costco one would make a difference. Instead I would recover the chairs and spend the money on a new piece to replace the china cabinet.
This is a Hamilton Webster fabric from fabricguru.com. It is polyester, so very good for dining chairs. It’s plain but with a texture and hints of other colors in the weave. I suggest this look because having a pattern on your chairs would be too busy for the simple lines of the chairs.
One one wall, a server with lamps and art and on the other a bar cart and mirror.
Q
2 cowhides
Q