Something needs tightening.

I saw that, but wasn't sure why it would be an issue. I could understand not using an indoor fixture outside, but any reason I can't use this indoors?

I do agree with Olychick though - the kitchen is very traditional so I'm not sure you can get away with something leaning so far modern. I don't think you have to go as foofy/ornate as the previous owners did - but I don't think you can do super sleek either. I think you're going to have to try and find some kind of happy medium. Groveraxle always has great suggestions, hopefully she (or someone like her - a pro) will weigh in and help find you something you love, but will also work in the space as it currently exists.

I would have taken the opportunity to remove that 3-light bulb fixture completely. Can't tell from the pics but are there only 3 cans lights in the entire kitchen? You need more lighting & the best lighting comes with a variety of light options...recessed lights, sconces if that works, under cabinet, etc. I like the look of no pendants over the island if that complements one's kitchen. In your case, not only do you need the extra lighting that pendents can afford but you need some "character" as another Houzzer suggested. I can think of a dozen options that would work but also dependent on the style you want to maintain. How about an industrial look fixture with a colored (metal) shade; bring in another metal, something in copper...anything to add omph to a B/W kitchen.