Houzz Logo Print
plaidpine

Backsplash ideas that won't make my cabs look worse by comparison

19 days ago
last modified: 19 days ago

The previous owner redid the countertops and backsplash. The countertops look fine with the cabs, the backsplash really does not work. It just makes the cabinets look worse than they need to.

I had been thinking of changing the backsplash to a simple off white square or rectangle tile in a stacked grid. I don't know if this would look good or bad with the grid tile floor. It could look cohesive or it could look like a grid prison is wrapping around you.

I don't like a subway running bond pattern. My husband hates rows of vertically oriented rectangle tiles.

Please suggest a backsplash look.

A note about the cabinets: we feel neutral about them. Don't love or hate them, very glad they're wood. Keeping them for a while, may reface in a couple years, would still go with wood. I am changing the knobs and pulls because the square knobs are sharp and have cut my hands!




Editing to add other relevant photos:

Undertones don't match -


Counter with Maria Killam whites undertone wheel -




Real color of floor grout (in entry closet where it has never been walked on) -



Comments (65)

  • 19 days ago

    This is a chat gpt rendering of white grid tile backsplash in my kitchen



  • 19 days ago

    The photos included in your original post make your counters look whiter - and they look like they work with the backsplash (looks like Bedrosian Cloe White tile - 2.55" x 7.87" actual dimensions - which has been a ridiculously popular tile on Houzz + everywhere!). However, the close up photo (with the white paper) definitely makes the countertops appear to have a yellow tone.


    You don't need to rent a steam cleaner or hire someone for the floors -


    Use The Pink Stuff (paste) + a rotary cleaning brush. Both will work separately - however, together it's just easier (according to my sister - she has tiled floors in the kitchen of her house - I have hardwood throughout my house - except for three of my bathrooms + laundry/mudroom - but it's not big square tiles like these + the tile floors are all new).


    However, I have The Pink Stuff + a rotary cleaning brush - and both work on many things (both products made me want to find things to clean bc they worked so well 🤣).


    It's so surprising how dark the grout becomes - and then the floor looks so busy with grids everywhere (my sister keeps a clean home - but her grout still became pretty dark).


    The photos below were posted by customers on Amazon who purchased The Pink Stuff:




    This photo was posted by a customer who purchased a rotary scrub brush:




    This is they type of brush:



    It was about $39 - they have many options of them. It's nice to have one that has some of the softer heads for cleaning windows (so funny - because I've never cleaned my own windows before - until I bought this and decided to do the huge set of them in the kitchen!)

    plaidpine thanked dani_m08
  • Related Discussions

    Backsplash or no backsplash?

    Q

    Comments (7)
    LOOOVE what you've done. That's going to be stunning. I have a small pass through that I created where there was a door and went through this same argument with myself. In the end, I stayed with the flat counter and now that the top has been installed I can tell I'm going to love the extra deep space. My situation is quite different though. It's where I plan to do baking things, and while mine is next to the dining room it doesn't overlook it. It will also serve as a landing zone for things going in/out to the back patio. I'm assuming the DR will have a casual feel and get daily use. Are there views into here from other rooms of the house? I was going to say "flat counter" since it appears you want the two rooms to really function as one. But given that the sink is there I think I would go for the raised counter. You don't want to be splashing into the DR. Tough call.
    ...See More

    Looking for backsplash ideas

    Q

    Comments (27)
    You can love teal today and get tired of it in 5 years. You don't want to have the desire to change something that fixed in 5 years. Save the teal accents for things that can be easily brought in and changed later. Fun accents will bring a smile to your face just as readily. Since your counter is fairly busy you really need to rest your eye a bit by going with a solid color backsplash. I'd go light to contrast the cabinets and so that the pops of teal accents you place against it really shine. I think an updated subway tile in a non- traditional size such as 2x6 or 4x8 would give you the slightly offbeat look you want. You probably just need to match the color to one of the lighter tones in your counter material. Bring some pieces home and you'll find the one that gives your eye the most pleasure. Be sure you have a nice teal accent item so you can't see how it plays into the mix.
    ...See More

    Thoughts on my flooring and backsplash ideas?

    Q

    Comments (1)
    Hi, I've always loved that style of pottery--it's lovely! Have you considered a honed slate? We really liked the Andhra Blue--there is variation in the colors, but a bit more subtle than the picture above. The colors range from grayish-blues to grayish greens. It looks good with a dark grout, and has a very natural look. There are some pics on this website of a few different slates/quartzites available. As for backsplashes, I'm in the same boat. We're using the slate in our bathrooms with a white pebble border/backsplash. Don't think pebbles would work in the kitchen. Maybe a combo of metal and different shades of blue glass tiles? (to pick up on the different blues you have between your pottery and cobalt glass) Good luck--it is truly overwhelming, because there are so many beautiful things out there to choose! Here is a link that might be useful: Slate pics
    ...See More

    Need help choosing backsplash for soapstone counters/oak cabs

    Q

    Comments (32)
    I was looking at this website about choosing a color scheme. According to this, my kitchen has a split complementary color scheme. My wall color is blue. The complement is orange. The split complementaries are yellow-orange (my cabinets) and red-orange (my Brazilian cherry floors). I also have a good dose of neutrals with my appliances and light fixtures and gray countertops. In addition, my walls are a grayed blue to tone down the blue, allowing the split complementaries to shine. My stone does not read as "green" as the previous picture of the Frank Lloyd Wright kitchen. I'm really not fond of the monochromatic color scheme currently popular. My kitchen is a lively place and the bold color scheme fits it well. I am confused as to why others feel the colors are fighting with one another? Regardless, finding a suitable backsplash is proving to be a challenge.
    ...See More
  • 19 days ago

    The counters read as "white" in person. They are not a stark white. They're off-white. You can see in my original post there is a roll of paper towels. The counters are thankfully not as bright white as the paper towels, but they generally read as white. My phone camera is truly terrible and there's no way for me to capture colors accurately, but the point of the close-up photo showing the counter and backsplash was more to demonstrate how different their undertones are.

    I had seen your other post on Houzz dani, about your sister's tile grout and the Pink Stuff - definitely encouraging!

    There is one little hiccup with cleaning the grout and returning it to its real lighter color... In the kitchen, 2 of the tiles at some point were replaced and the grout used around those 2 tiles was done very dark to match the rest of the (dirty) grout! So now if/when we clean the grout, those 2 tiles will still be surrounded by dark grout, which will have to be removed and re-done to match the new lighter grout color. Makes me nervous (matching it correctly. Grout is tricky / deceiving.)

  • 19 days ago
    last modified: 19 days ago

    Here is the counter with Maria Killam's whites undertone wheel


    For anyone unfamiliar with this colorwheel: top is "true-white", right is off-white, bottom is cream, left is blue-white

  • 19 days ago

    Hiring a professional tile cleaning company is the fastest and easiest way to getting clean and well sealed grout. They have expertise and equipment as well as chemicals. A $15 brush attachment for your drill will also do an excellent job if you have the time and energy to use it.


    IME, a rotary cleaner similar to what is shown is much better at light cleaning than heavy cleaning because the lighter cleaners can skitter around without applying much pressure. They are not nearly as effective as the old style rotary floor machines sold to homeowners in the 1950's and 1960's for stripping and buffing.

    plaidpine thanked apple_pie_order
  • 19 days ago

    Once your grout is cleaned, try using grout paint to color match your 2 rogue tiles. Lots of colors available and you simply paint it on with a small brush. Home Depot/Lowes carries this product.



    plaidpine thanked ratherbesewing
  • 19 days ago

    If it were me, I’d clean the tile then add a rug with some color in there - then I would choose a color from the rug for the backsplash - I do feel like a richer color would look nicer with the cabs




    plaidpine thanked la_la Girl
  • 19 days ago

    Once the grout is cleaned the grid affect will fade enough. Bring home samples.

    Sample | ASSAMPLE-TERRAZZORENATA | Ann Sacks



    plaidpine thanked dan1888
  • 18 days ago

    Not square tile - looks like bathroom wall tile.

    plaidpine thanked Suki Mom
  • 18 days ago

    Can I get opinions about a hexagon / honeycomb backsplash please? Would that pattern work with my square grid floor and my honey oak cabinets? If I go with this option I would just choose as close a match to my counters as possible. Please don't be shy to give me your thoughts.




  • 18 days ago

    I like the AI kitchen backsplash rendering, assuming grout paint and a runner down the floor happens as well. And I think off white hexagon tile looks good too, the ones with equal length sides all around appearing more classic to me than the flattened ones, which feel vaguely midcentury?... or actually 10-15 years ago I think I saw those have another moment.

    plaidpine thanked Julie S
  • 18 days ago





    Not sure why chatgpt always takes my pantry out of the rendering but anyway there's the comparison square vs hex.

  • 18 days ago

    Any other materials besides tile I should consider for the backsplash?

  • PRO
    17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    Before you change that backsplash get the floors professionally cleaned! it’s the dirty grout that is giving a strong grid look! after that gets yourself a nice runner…also change out the switchplates to white.

    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors with Ease
  • PRO
    17 days ago

    Cleaned grout



    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors with Ease
  • 17 days ago

    I'm getting excited about clean floor grout and having a runner rug!

  • PRO
    17 days ago

    I would also change up your lighting bulbs..they are very warm…add daylight bulbs makes such a difference.

    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors With Ease
  • 17 days ago

    The lighting is pretty dim in this kitchen. I will change the bulbs and I bet you're right it will be so much better, not just for the appearance of the kitchen but also for preparing meals!

  • 17 days ago

    As for the backsplash, I really do think I need to change it. The purple undertone doesn't relate to anything else about the home or my color palette. Also the backsplash tile is kind of trendy looking and next to the cabinets it creates a look of "NEW backsplash, OLD cabinets."

  • PRO
    17 days ago

    Change your bulbs and see what it looks like color-wise..I think it is the lighting..I think it is more gray and the hardware needs updating…if I was to change anything it is the flooring…

    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors With Ease
  • 17 days ago

    It's clear that most people think the floors are the worst problem. The tile floor runs through the kitchen, foyer, and hall to laundry. My husband and I are not really bothered by the floor, and I guess we're trying to understand what is so offensive about it. I love the tile size and the simple grid format. The color of the tiles could be better but it's not terrible. The dark grout can be restored to much lighter. Is it the dark grout that's the big problem?

  • 17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    get a green tile backsplash....anything else you care to do like changing floor or simply adding a runner will work w green w the honey cabinets as your backdrop. I dont care for the tile floor and due to small sq footage .....a remnant or sale clearance material can easily work. go to flooring stores and give them the dimensions. I dont think the tile floor is worth spending time/ money on ...a long narrow galley can really play up a good floor..doesnt have to be spectacular but anything besides whats there.


    attractive green tile w honey shade wood. do you like slate look floors ?

    Saint Paul Craftsman · More Info


    Modern Galley Kitchen Design · More Info


    plaidpine thanked herbflavor
  • 17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    Green is a big element in my color scheme and I love wood with green.

    It's so interesting how much people hate our floors. I'm definitely taking it to heart and appreciate the feedback.

  • 17 days ago

    To give an idea of our color palette:






  • 17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    herbflavor - yes I love slate floors. And the walkway outside up to our front door has that type of look.


  • 17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    Subway tile in a basket weave



    or double basket weave pattern



    an article with examples:

    Basketweave Tile Backsplash – Eye-catching Subway Tile Layout Designs






    plaidpine thanked s m
  • 17 days ago

    Im sensitive to undertones, have followed Maria Killam for 10 years, and I too have a problem with your purple backsplash! The floors are old style but so are the cabinets, so yea, here to confirm that a simple update that won’t cost the bank is get the backsplash in color harmony with the other elements of this room.

    plaidpine thanked Julie S
  • 17 days ago

    I agree the backsplash and the floor don't work together.


    I'm another one who likes the backsplash and does not like your floor. (Sorry, ha ha!) However I don't live there and so my opinion is worth exactly what you paid for it. :-)


    If it were me, I'd clean the heck out of the tile floor, get some large, colorful runners to cover as much of the tile as possible in the kitchen - and then accessorize the counters just a smidge to tie it all together.


    If that doesn't do it for you, and you still hate it together....then yes, it sounds like the backsplash is an easier fix than ripping out rooms of the same tile. I like the idea of green in this kitchen, and adding green may be easier to pull off than trying to find the right shade of white with those floors....lest you end up with a new shape but the same problem all over again.

    plaidpine thanked Ally De
  • 17 days ago

    I like the basketweave patterns. I'll add that to the list of possibilities. You know, I actually like the way a darker backsplash looks... but I feel like doing an off-white that matches the counters would be more versatile. ?

    If I was designing a kitchen from scratch I wouldn't pick white counters or backsplash. But I think the countertops the previous owner chose are fine and work nicely with the cabinets so I'm just going to keep them. They were not the right choice for the beige floors. You can kind of get a sense in this photo how the floors could read as just a vague light neutral white-ish, but when you put something whiter with them that's when they read as more dated-beige.



  • 17 days ago

    In a galley should the rug be centered with floor showing on each side? Cover the whole floor between the 2 sides? Or be over on the sink side?

  • 17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    Sounds like you may do a major over hall in the kitchen (at some point). IMO, the cabinets are very decent, I don't mind the backsplash or the counter. The thorn with the rose is the floor.

    How would you feel about doing a temporary cover? There is a lay down flooring...installer cuts it to fit the space, and it is simply laid down over the tile, comes in patterns or plain. Now, if I can remember the brand.... it comes on a roll, just like carpet. It is not vinyl sheet...it is thicker and the weight of it keeps it secure on the floor.

    Dawn breaks over Marblehead,


    Mannington sheet vinyl flooring, sold in rolls and cut to the desired size, offers a durable and stylish flooring option. This type of flooring can be laid down without adhesives, making it suitable for areas where you might want to easily remove and replace the flooring, like smaller rooms with minimal traffic. Mannington's sheet vinyl is known for its waterproof and scratch-resistant properties, along with its ability to mimic the look of natural materials like wood and stone.

    plaidpine thanked elcieg
  • 17 days ago
    last modified: 17 days ago

    One reason I don't want to change the floor tile is the mess/dust, so the idea of covering it is better to me than ripping it up. But I would only do that if the covering was indisputably better than the tile. Keep in mind the tile runs through kitchen, foyer, and hall.

    I love that with tile I don't have to worry about pulling my fridge or stove out to clean under/behind. Hard to find something other than tile that can reliably withstand that with no risk of scratching.

  • PRO
    17 days ago

    I really don’t mind the flooring it just needs a good grout cleaning.


    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors With Ease
  • 17 days ago

    There are some interesting/pretty stick on floor tiles - they even have grout for them so that they look like actual tile. Many options - really depends upon your style:


    Floor Pops by Chris loves Julia:



    These come in different colors - including a beige marble look tile in place of the gray ones above. Floor Pops have many different designs + there are other manufacturers.


    Also, many people have painted their tiled floors. You just need to use the correct products (I believe Rustoleum has one).


    The next three people used stencils on top of base paint:






    You posted that you liked slate tile - Home Depot has black slate from Brazil (= good bc very durable). HD also has other colors - I don't know the country of origin for the other colors of slate tile.

    These are slate tiles and marble in a 12x12 size. They purchased the slate from Home Depot (maybe the marble also):


    HD has quite a few different sizes - the prices are reasonable for all of them:


    4x12 in herringbone pattern:



    I think these might be 12 x 24:


    This is 4x16 I think with a matching grout color:


    plaidpine thanked dani_m08
  • 17 days ago

    If you decide you are going to keep your floor tile (once the grout is cleaned it will look much better), here are some backsplash ideas (you posted something about liking blue and green):


    Here is slate on a fireplace - you could use it on your backsplashI:



    The nine following photos are all tiles from Bedrosian - I can't remember which one this is - but it's posted on their site and is easy to find. You can purchase them from other retailers (many times at a lower price with free shipping + free return shipping if you decide against using them):







    This next tile is like your current tile - but in green (also comes in blue and an aqua - it's called Baby Blue - but I have this color and it's more aqua):


    It comes in a 5x5 size also:


    This would look pretty with your cabinets:


    The next set of photos are tiles from Lowe's:





    It comes in a white shade also:

    Here is the name + price:


    Here is one last one from Lowe's:


    This next photo was posted by a customer in order to show that her tiles were darker than what was shown above (she liked the color of the ones she received more than the ones posted by Lowe's):



    plaidpine thanked dani_m08
  • 16 days ago

    @plaidpine In a galley the rug should be centered. If you look up images of galley kitchens with runners the ones that look the best, imo, have a centered rug that is wide enough so that if you work at either side of the galley you are able to stand on the rug.

    Personally, I would not cover your floor with another flooring. Clean the grout and either seal it or potentially us grout paint. I used grout paint in a past laundry room and it held up well to years of traffic including a large dog. The backsplash is definitely the odd man out in the kitchen.

    plaidpine thanked s m
  • PRO
    16 days ago

    With backsplash I would incorporate some white with whatever color you want to add so that it flows nicely from the white countertop…I would not add a solid color…so many to choose from!

    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors With Ease
  • 16 days ago

    OK so the plan is coming together:

    - Keep existing tile floor but restore the grout to a much lighter color.

    - Add a runner rug to the galley.

    - Change the backsplash to either all off-white (countertop match) or a mix of off-white and green or off-white and a warm color that blends with the wood cabs.

    - Backsplash tile pattern could be hexagon honeycomb, subway basketweave, or in the case of a 2 color backsplash, a simple geometric design.




    Need advice about grout look/color for backsplash. Should it be basically "invisible" or stand out a little to emphasize the pattern?

    Thank you to everyone for helping me!

  • PRO
    16 days ago
    last modified: 16 days ago

    Yes a great plan keeping the geometric square theme will help it feel cohesive..match the grout to the tile so it looks seemless. I would not add a octagon with your floor.

    plaidpine thanked Home Interiors With Ease
  • 15 days ago

    Nowhere does it say that a backsplash needs to be tiled. You could just paint it. I removed tile from ,imne and have had paint for many years on my backsplash. It hold up fine and wipes clean.

    THis would give you time to play with colors to help you move forward with a tile at a later date. Paint existing wall color or get a quart of a green you like and live with it for a while.

    plaidpine thanked RNmomof2 zone 5
  • 15 days ago

    RNmomof2 I like that you are thinking differently. I've had painted drywall "backsplash" before too and it was perfectly fine (but I did have that short bump up of the counter onto the bottom of the wall.)

    Like I said early in the thread, I'm open to a backsplash material that's not tile. I do regularly splash water behind the sink and have to wipe it dry. I don't tend to splatter food when I cook but it's bound to happen now and then. The current stove has a raised back that would "protect" the wall behind.

  • 13 days ago

    Can I get opinions about this idea please:

    This backsplash or similar-

    Chatgpt AI rendering probably looks a little darker than it would actually appear:

    A menswear theme is part of my interior design plan for the home, so the herringbone ties in with that.

    Do you think it would be a mistake to go for a darker backsplash like this? I could also do the herringbone in an off-white to match the countertops.


  • 13 days ago

    Your dark tile idea is very interesting. It makes the floor look better!

    plaidpine thanked Suki Mom
  • 13 days ago

    Do you have good under-counter lighting? If not, I'd avoid a dark backsplash.

    plaidpine thanked einportlandor
  • 13 days ago

    IMO something with a bit of color will work better than off white. Getting the off white to go with your counters will be more difficult, like what you are dealing with now.

    plaidpine thanked kcooz07
  • 13 days ago

    I would look for green tiles for your backsplash. Green works so well with your cabs and gives them a fresh, updated look.


    I had Stanley Steemer come in and clean the grout and tile floors in my entire house. The floors came out looking fabulous!

    plaidpine thanked Amanda Smith
  • 13 days ago

    If you had a window on that side, maybe the super dark could work. As is, looks like a black hole - at least on my screen. I was thinking a much lighter green.....several that Dani posted would look good.


    I am going to 3rd the recommendation to be very careful with yet another shade of white.

    plaidpine thanked Ally De
  • 13 days ago

    Quick side note - I have painted beadboard as my backsplash. Threw it up as a quick option years ago, it is still there. Good semi gloss paint = cleans up easily, and so easy to change the color too. 😆 It isn't the right look for everyone but it has worked well for me. Maybe one day I will find the right tile.....

    plaidpine thanked Ally De
  • 12 days ago

    It is hard to tell the colors on monitors - I think you’ll need to go to a local tile shop and get some contenders, then once you have your final choice - mock up a few boards with grout to make sure it’s right (I would go low contrast grout for a less busy look overall) and then choose from there -


    for me the menswear tile seems a bit formal/overdone for your cabs/counters - but that’s just me

    plaidpine thanked la_la Girl
  • PRO
    12 days ago

    The floor tile and the backsplash both present a problem for me. Would suggest you replace both especially if you are going to leave your cabinets as they are. Perhaps a natural slate for both would provide a good foil for the color of the cabinetry.

    plaidpine thanked Norwood Architects