What are your options?

Are the historic colors from a specific brand?

Colors of Historic Charleston

Pale green walls, cream and terracotta is a classic combination. All three colors appear on your Historic Charleston sample card. Alternatively, butter yellow walls, light cream and dark green ("Charleston green").

I honestly like the current color scheme.

But, if you’re ready for a change, I’d sample some of the creamy white and beige colors

White on white, whatever is close to this house. The body of the house is the bright white.

If the house in the pictures is your house, I would paint it the same color it is. It looks very nice.

Paint companies have visualizers online you can upload a photo of your house and "paint" it using their colors. (It is much easiear if you can take a picture without tree shadows on the siding.)

I wonder if HOA will let the paint store cut the color for a paler greige?

I used AI to create these for you in my concept color scheme. Hope this helps.

I described your house to AI and this is what it came up with.

I clicked on the link from Celery...yes, looks best with an off-white house and white columns.