Warm water w Gas tankless hot water heater w built-in recirculation?

last month

Dear all, thanks again for your help.

I'm new to gas powered tankless hot water heater. I heard from my plumber that he would not recommend installing a new gas tankless hot water heater with built-in recirculation system (e.g., Navien's ComfortFlow or Rinnai's RE Series such as the RE199iN), as he said that with such a system, even with a dedicated hot water return line, the cold water will still become warm.

My question is, why? I will have more discussion with him tomorrow to learn more (and will update the forum about what I learned), but my first impression is that does not make sense.

Can folks who have experience about this share your experience please? Also, would you choose a "condensing" (more efficient but more complex system) unit or a "non-condensing" unit (less efficient, but simpler design so might be more reliable because of less moving parts etc) as of now (March 2025)? It seems that the "non-condensing" unit might be going away, so are we stuck with buying only "condensing" unit now? Any thoughts or comments about this? Thanks again!

By the way, here is what I learned about "hot water sandwich effect".

For reference: Navien’s patented ComfortFlow® system is the first to include a buffer tank, recirculation pump and fine-tuned controls into a tankless water heater, resolving the cold-water sandwich effect* and issues of minimal flow rates commonly found in other tankless water heaters.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (2)

3katz4me
last month
No answers but I did have the warm cold water problem. We bought a house with tankless heater. No problem at first but then we turned recirculating off while we were gone for an extended period. Then we turned it back on 24 hours a day rather than a few hours. We then got the warm cold water. My solution was to just turn recirculating off entirely. We’ve adapted to running the water for a while to get it hot. Waste water or waste enrgy recirculating. Never had this problem with previous tanks.
W C thanked 3katz4me
Jake The Wonderdog
last month
last modified: last month
I've never heard of warm cold water with a dedicated return line. I don't see how that's possible.

If you're talking about condensing versus non-condensing tankless water heater, condensing is the only way I would go. Non-condensing requires stainless steel venting which is very expensive. I've used several of the Rheem condensing tankless units and they work very reliably.

Since you're talking about recirculation, I would prefer a separate recirculation pump rather than one built into the water heater. TACO and Grundfos both make good circulating pumps.

Consider using a hybrid electric heater instead though. Depending on your cost of electricity, the hybrid electric may be cheaper to operate than a condensing gas tankless. You have an ideal location for a hybrid electric and it avoids dealing with any venting - again which is very expensive for non-condensing but cheap (PVC) for a condensing gas water heater.

It also avoids some other issues such as a longer wait for hot water without a circulating pump.
Related Discussions
Instant hot water, large house tankless water heater
Q
Comments (18)
After ours was installed I stumbled across a company that makes an all in one unit called Eternal Hybrid (link below). You may want to contact them and see about getting the energy efficiency specs to go that route. I think Navien also makes an all in one system now too. I would think either company would be able to give you more accurate energy specs and better answer your question. The other thing to keep in mind is that without the loop (& pump), you are in effect wasting gallons of water waiting for the hot to kick in--think showers, sinks, etc. How much does the water wastage cost in terms of both water & sewer bills + the unnecessary waste of a resource? In addition to washing machines not pulling enough water through at a time to trigger the heater and then remain on long enough to actually get the water down the line to the machine, some dishwashers are having problems too. Here is a link that might be useful: Eternal Hybrid Hot Water Heater Site
...See More
tankless hot water heaters with recirculation
Q
Comments (13)
We were recently going to install a Rannai unit in our home but decided against it. While a great idea, the cost and practicality didn't seem to make sense. Some of the reasons we decided against it included dedicated 1" gas line run up the outside wall of our house (two stories), needed the recirculation to provide hot water to HE washer (uses small bursts of water), discussions of intermittant bursts of cold water, more stringent annual flushing requirement, need soft water and the total cost. Talked to a few installers and Rannai seemed to be the preferred choice. Considered Navian for the included recirculation but they are still fairly new on the market. Just seemed better to replace our two tank water heaters. I think tankless water heaters will eventually become the standard but right now they are still an expensive option.
...See More
Tankless Water Heater w/ Existing Tank System
Q
Comments (3)
So when you say you are worried about bacteria then want to set your water heater low to save energy, that's where the bacteria grows. You want your tank at 120 degrees so it kills off bacteria but also does not scald when used. 100 is the ideal growth range for bacteria. http://lifehacker.com/whats-the-best-temperature-for-my-water-heater-1465372005 My other question is how is it possible for you to go through two 50 gallon heaters? How do you have it plumbed? Perhaps change to a different shower head or your current tanks are set to too low of a temp or the whole thing is plumbed wrong. I get that some people like their high flow shower head, but you will pay for it in energy. If you have a high flow shower head then are worried about energy, I find that silly.
...See More
Electric Water Heater 4500 w to 5500 w Elements
Q
Comments (12)
You know I think I'm going to buy a Geospring hybrid water heater instead of the electric water heater with the 5500 watt elements. I did a little more research last night and from what I read GE did a re-design of the Geospring and brought the manufacturing back to the US. Owner reviews say the re-designed model has been more reliable than the previous design. I still plan to get the 5 year, extended warranty to cover labor if something goes wrong. GE sold the manufacturing equipment for Geospring to Bradford White so Bradford White would handle manufacturer warranty issues. Bradford White confirmed that when I called them today. The expected annual cost of electricity for the Geospring was $162 where the expected cost of electricity used was $555 for the water heater with the 5500 watt elements. I should recover the cost difference for the more expensive Geospring water heater in 2-3 years and the savings should pay for the full cost of the Geospring in 4-5 years. I live in a state with a warm climate so that should help the efficiency and recovery time of the Geospring.
...See More
Related Professionals
Wolf Trap Handyman · Shamong Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Champlin Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Gilbert Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · San Juan Capistrano Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Ojus Kitchen & Bath Fixtures · Prior Lake Cabinets & Cabinetry · South Farmingdale Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Eagle Mountain Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Galena Park Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · York Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Galena Park General Contractors · Jackson General Contractors · Welleby Park General Contractors · Wolf Trap General Contractors

Warm water w Gas tankless hot water heater w built-in recirculation?

Comments (2)

3katz4me

Jake The Wonderdog

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US