Houzz Logo Print
central_valley

Are these test results meaningful?

last month

I'm testing my soil for pH and NPK for the first time, and I'm not sure what to make of the results I'm getting. Suggestions are welcome.


I'm using an Environmental Concepts testing kit that I bought on Amazon a few months ago. Until today it was unopened.


I'm testing five samples:

  • Three from different vegetable beds.
  • One from a formerly grassy area that was dug up by construction workers last summer, and now is probably mostly subsoil.
  • One from an area on my patio that contained several years’ accumulation of leaf mold and droppings collected from my chicken coop, together with a quantity of bedding (wood shavings) that came along when I picked up the droppings. I would estimate that the volume of wood shavings was about half the volume of droppings, and of course, they were much less dense. Everything is now thoroughly rotted, and has been mixed and sifted.

The pH of all five samples came out to be 7.0 or 7.5. I don't know if those numbers are accurate, but they seem within reason. But the nitrogen content of all five samples came out to be 0. I'm suspicious of that. I just don't see how a mixture of leaf mold and chicken droppings, with a few wood shavings mixed in, can contain no nitrogen. And being suspicious of that nitrogen result makes me suspicious of the other four.


I have not performed the phosphorus and potassium tests yet. I’m waiting to read the comments on this post before I decide whether it’s worth the effort.


The kit has no expiration date, but should be reasonably new. The instructions are somewhat complex but easy to understand, and I followed them carefully. Unless I read the instructions five times and misunderstood them the same way each time, I don't see how my technique could have been at fault.


Should I accept these results as valid? Buy a better test kit (if so, what)? Or just forget about home testing and send my soil out for analysis?

Comments (8)

Sponsored
Grow Landscapes
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Planning Your Outdoor Space in Loundon County?