Finish Advice for New Oak Island Top

2 months ago

We put a rift sawn white oak top on our kitchen island. We use the island for food prep (with cutting boards), eating, and homework. There is no sink in the island.

We love the look and super smooth feel of the unfinished oak as it sits and are looking for a product that will 1) retain the raw, unfinished, no sheen, look, 2) provide some protection against grease or berry stains (3 young kids), and 3) does not require a sprayer to apply.

We tried out the General Finishes high performance Flat water based topcoat. Aesthetically, it's acceptable but it leaves a slightly rough feel (product was brushed on with a foam brush, as per the instructions). If I sand it with 220 to make it smooth again, I'm assuming that it will remove all of the protection.

If you have any product or technique advice, we would greatly appreciate it.

Featured Answer

cat_ky

2 months ago

You need the finish to be food safe. Try food safe Mineral oil.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

jlc712
2 months ago
We used Rubio Monocoat on our wood counters. It's a matte finish and has held up really well. I think it's been 5-6 years. You can scuff sand and add another coat when needed, but we haven't needed to yet.
0
The Beach House Group thanked jlc712
Related Discussions
Newbie needs advice: finishing oak exterior door
Q
Comments (6)
Don't try to stain it in place ... have it cut to fit and the hinges routed and holes drilled, lay it flat on some sawhorses and do each side. Then install it. It's way easier to get an even coat, avoids runs in the finish, etc. That usually means waiting until late spring, and does mean you take down the old door, re-install the old door and take it down again when the replacement is ready. But it's sooooo much easier, Use as many coats of a penetrating oil stain as it takes, or let it stay on longer before wiping for a deeper color. Don't pay attention to the names of the stains, look at the color samples. Beware of "Red mahogany"! It's REALLY RED. It's useful for boosting the red tones in a stain that is not red ehough, but way too red to use by itself.
...See More
Finishing an oak desktop (new wood) and have a question or two?!?
Q
Comments (2)
The only clash would be if you changed varieties of poly---water based to oil/oil to water. I quit using tack cloths years ago---blue paper towels dampened with solvent(for the finish being used) works much better, in my experience. I also get better results with poly when using a Purdy(my favorite) or other good man made bristle brush. The china bristle is best for oil based finishes, while the man made is better with water based finishes. But, for me, the man made gives better results with both. But, with the man made brush, I find wiping any excess off the brush on the can/container causes air bubbles---brushing an area more than three strokes also causes bubbles.
...See More
Walnut Island top used as cutting board - photos & finish details
Q
Comments (60)
len, you’re welcome. You won’t regret it. I hope you intend to cut right on the island, not just have a beautiful wooden island that you’re paranoid about getting marked up. We passed the 10 year anniversary this past June and while I’ve toyed with sanding it down a bit as mentioned above, I think we’re going to give it a few more years. Of course a few weeks after we hit 10 years we got a really bad stain from where I left the metal disc from a food mill sitting on the counter overnight. I don’t understand why a wet piece of metal leaves a dark black stain in the wood. There’s some sort of reaction between the wood and the metal when it’s wet. It’s not a rust stain. The marks are black. I’m sure it will sand out if I bother but… who cares? It’s a kitchen, not a museum.
...See More
Wood Island Top Choices...advice appreciated!
Q
Comments (18)
There are functional, practical differences in choosing end, edge, and flat grains. If you want to chop directly on it, the end grain, as shown in Francoise47's 1st photo allows the knife blade to go down between, or parallel with the grain, so there is less damage, and less change in the appearance. Edge grain or flat, with the grain running sideways on the surface, will be cut by the knife, so is more likely to show the cut and later, possibly have little pieces come loose, making it less smooth and more beat-up looking. Edge grain is supposed to do have less problem than flat, because the exposed grain is tighter/thinner. Flat is perfectly OK if you're not going to cut on the surface. Flat boards could possibly cup, which isn't a concern with the other 2 styles, but made well, this shouldn't be a problem with the flat boards, either. Other than that, the looks can be quite different, and that's where personal preference comes in. These all make a difference in the price, because of the amount of work and material involved. The person making this for you should've discussed which wood, which grain direction, and thickness before quoting a price.
...See More
Related Professionals
Plymouth Cabinets & Cabinetry · Elmhurst Flooring Contractors · Oro Valley Flooring Contractors · Bridgeport Furniture & Accessories · Skokie Furniture & Accessories · Fort Carson Furniture & Accessories · Harrison Cabinets & Cabinetry · North New Hyde Park Cabinets & Cabinetry · Chelsea Flooring Contractors · North Liberty Flooring Contractors · Clovis Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · San Juan Capistrano Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Winchester Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Plant City Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Fort Lauderdale Cabinets & Cabinetry
The Beach House Group
Original Author
2 months ago
Our carpenter suggested Rubio and mocked up a sample but it came out a lot darker and more golden than we were shooting for.
0
jlc712
2 months ago
There are several colors of Rubio, not sure what you tried. We went the clear natural. You could also try Waterlox.
0
Clyde Kalvin
2 months ago
You would need multiple coats and you need to lightly sand between coats.
The Beach House Group
Original Author
2 months ago
Thanks Ann. I saw that in the instructions and just figured that the final coat would still be rough. I'll try it.
0
Clyde Kalvin
2 months ago
@The Beach House Group You want several coats sanding between each and then you put on your last coat and it should be very smooth. I have refinished a maple butcher block tabletop and the finish is smooth.
0
dani_m08
2 months ago
@The Beach House Group - Ann Marks is exactly right. Your last coat should lay down flat and not "raise the grain" = smooth.
0
John Liu
2 months ago
last modified: 2 months ago
“Osmo Polyx Oil” is a wipe-on hardening oil from Germany, “Emmet’s Good Stuff“ is a wipe-on urethane made in the US, both are foodsafe when cured. Both leave the feel of the wood grain unaffected, neither make the wood darker although the grain contrast is slightly enhanced. Both can be sanded out and spot-refinished with no sign of the refinishing. Two wipe-on applications is sufficient. No particular need to sand between applications.

I learned of these from some woodworking forums, and turns out my furniture maker uses Osmo Polyx often. I was looking for a finish for my maple edge grain butcher block counters, and tested these two, as well as mineral oil/beeswax and Waterlox, for stain resistance against espresso, soy sauce, red wine, and other common kitchen messes, left on for 5 min, 1 hour, and 12 hours.

The sample finished with Emmet’s was unstained after 12 hours of all those things. The sample finished with Osmo was very faintly stained after 12 hours of espresso, which was the most staining of the things I tried. It only took a few minutes to sand out the stain and refinish with Osmo. Mineral oil/beeswax was pretty useless in stain resistance. Waterlox was, surprisingly, not that protective at all.

See more info and details here

https://www.gardenweb.com/discussions/6466680/butcher-block-countertop

I wrote a longer post about my subsequent experience with these finishes in actual use on my countertops and cabinets (which I ended up finishing variously with Osmo, Emmet’s, and mineral oil/beeswax - different finishes for different locations), but Houzz ate it. Arrrgh. If these finishes are of interest I’ll re-type it.
0

Finish Advice for New Oak Island Top

cat_ky

Comments (9)

jlc712

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

The Beach House Group
Original Author

jlc712

Clyde Kalvin

The Beach House Group
Original Author

Clyde Kalvin

dani_m08

John Liu

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Finish Advice for New Oak Island Top

cat_ky

Comments (9)

jlc712

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

The Beach House GroupOriginal Author

jlc712

Clyde Kalvin

The Beach House GroupOriginal Author

Clyde Kalvin

dani_m08

John Liu

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

The Beach House Group
Original Author

The Beach House Group
Original Author