Am I breaking exterior color design rules?

last month

I’m currently having some sliding doors replaced on my sunroom. I wanted them in a color called canvas which matched my house trim color, SW Maison Blanc, more closely. I had to opt for a color called Sandtone in this series which is close to SW Taupe Tone.

The main of my sunroom is SW Evergreen Fog. I also used this on my front door since my house is brick and Maison Blanc is the trim color on the entire house.

My concern is flipping from the brick part of the house which has Maison Blanc to the Evergreen Fog sunroom with these new Taupe Tone doors and trim around them. I’m worried it looks odd. I can’t paint them either because they’re vinyl and I’m worried about peeling and issues.

My contractor stated he could add quarter round or trim around the new sliding doors which could be painted Maison Blanc to tie it more together.

I’m getting a new deck in the spring which will be stained this taupe color (similar to what’s there now). And I feel like this might pull the taupe door color together with the house — making it feel more cohesive. Maybe?

I’ve just always thought exterior rear doors should traditionally be the same color as the house trim. However, this is a different part of the house with a different main color. Maybe it doesn’t have to be?

How can I pull this all in together so it appears cohesive and makes sense? Can exterior rear doors be a different color than the trim? Should I let my contractor add trim I’ll paint this creamy Maison Blanc to be more like the house?

Your ideas are appreciated.

Thanks

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

PRO
HALLETT & Co.
last month
You have white vinyl windows, and the new door is shown? The door is buff and the rest of your team is a soft green? I’d paint all your trim to match the new door, you don’t need three colors of trim.
mojavemaria
last month
I think it looks fine. Most front doors are a different color than windows and trim so why would it be any different for a back door? No need for trim in the lighter color which would be worse IMO. The door looks about the same color as the railing which lends to the cohesivness.
Related Discussions
Plant color vs. house color- breaking the rules?
Q
Comments (13)
Melvalena, we may be neighbors. I'm in Waxahachie, where are you? Don't give me too much credit until it's all said and done. I had big plans for these beds when we first moved in, but didn't get much farther than weeding them, adding a little compost and fresh mulch. Other house priorities have come up year after year, and of course last year was so bad we couldn't hardly even go outside, much less plant anything and expect it to live. So instead of doing, I've been reading. All of the good local gardening books, ag extension info, websites, gardenweb, etc. I've been lurking here on the design side off and on, reading and re-reading. Also looking at what my neighbors have planted, and what looks good when. What I haven't gained in plants (so far) I hope I've gained in good sense. I've decided that while I do enjoy gardening, I want this to be as maintenance free as possible. I want tough, drought tolerant, well-behaved plants that don't require a lot of care and fussing. Another thing I've learned is that common plants are common for a reason. Wax begonias may be old and boring, but they sure do look great for most of the season with very little work. Those Stella daylilies may be passe, but mine bloom their heads off all season long, in a hell strip of full sun and clay. I've seen older google images of the house, and frankly, whatever we do here will be a vast improvement on what the PO's did, so I have to remind myself of that, and not get too caught up in the details.
...See More
Breaking the rules
Q
Comments (13)
Good tips, advice and encouragement - thanks! Can't do more slate without big effort and hiring help - so that's out. High and low growers I have done and will continue doing as I add plants in. I came up with a 'design' of sorts that breaks up the length of the walk by incorporating plantings that travel across it in one section and giving a 'break point' where new border plantings begin. I have some hedging areas using Anise - nice, lush dark green and very easy plant but grows big if not kept pruned - I can handle that. I also have lovely but randomly blooming hydrangea that are doing well, some nice gardenias, red impatiens, coleus, shrimp and plume plants, and a lugustrum tree at the walks end. I put up hanging baskets each year and add annuals as energy and time permit. It works okay. Well enough for me, anyhow. Biggest frustration is often plant choice. I have one area that seems would be simple. High / dappled shade with good drainage (according to my 'dig a hold and fill with water' test) and no issues of sandy or clay soil. I always amend soils at planting and take time to 'Do it right'. At this point - in that area - I have had: A) dwarf azaleas. Just didn't thrive there. In retrospect I may not have watered them in well enough. Moved them 30 feet away under the oaks and they are thriving. B) Indian Hawthornes. We're lovely for a while. Then my entire yard was attacked by hairy moth caterpillars which exfoliated many shrubs. I was out of town and came home to what looked like a horror movie of bugs. Had to get a broom and knock the things off my door to get inside. The Hawthornes never really came back and it became evident there wasn't really enough sun for them there. Moved them to the other side of the yard and now they are healthy and happy. C) varigated pittasporum. Made this choice after having three that were surviving and thriving in the area. Bought more - LOTS more - to use along the sides of that stretch of the walk . They were living there well and looking good till just this week. Noticed wilted area on one. Soon it was 12. Pulled up the bad looking ones as was advised on another forum that problem was likely a root rot. Over it. If I had to do it over again I would put pebble rock and landscape lights in that area. But I am in up to my neck now so leaving it unfinished is not an option. Hence my desperate cry for consolation lol! I am either stupid or stubborn but I am not giving up.
...See More
What "rules" did you break when designing your kitchen? Are you glad?
Q
Comments (49)
Sinks under windows are a holdover from when all dishes were washed by hand - before DWs! Now, the Prep Zone counterspace is usually the "thing" that makes the most sense to go under the window! +++++++++ While it's not a rule, I put my trash pullout in the Cleanup Zone instead of the Prep Zone - and I regret it every single day! If only I could do it over.... I have only about 48" b/w my peninsula overhang and the DR table if I center the DR table under the chandelier - another regret. It was supposed to be more, but we forgot to move the chandelier in the DR to accommodate the new location! It's only an issue when someone is sitting in both locations, but that's often enough, especially when we have guests. Finally, I actually followed a rule - minimum of 15" clear leg/knee space for the seating overhang - and it's still too shallow! I wish we had done 18"! My DS never sits there (he uses the DR table instead) and my DH only uses it for breakfast - and that's only b/c we moved the TV and that's the only place he can see it while eating breakfast. He has to straddle the cabinets and lean over to reach the counter. (Yup! I'll go to any lengths to get my DH to sit there! ) My DD and I sit there, but my knees do hit the back of the cabinets (but just barely).
...See More
shrubs against the house; breaking 'rules', etc. Our beautybush case
Q
Comments (11)
The thing is......there really aren't any "rules" :-) You will not find any landscape design text that will state "do not plant too close to a structure" or "avoid placing taller shrubs in front of a window". Most of these are just common sense practices or at best, a rule of thumb. And like anything else with gardening, it will be very situational. Sometimes taller and airy shrubs are intentionally planted in front of a window to act as screening! Personally, I'd rather look out into something leafy and green than need to pull shades or close curtains :-) One of the reasons I do not post much in the Landscape Design forum (even though I am a practicing landscape designer and garden consultant with a pretty successful 30 year business) is that I dislike the emphatic insistence by nearly everyone that too tall or too close shrubs must be removed and that a tree cannot be placed so that it obscures a direct view of the entry. Poppycock!! These are not landscape design principles but rather just personal opinions!! In all my years of garden consulting and design, I have seen these so-called garden design no-no's in all manner of permutations. Sometimes they obviously do not work but many times they do. As noted above, if the placement does not damage the structure or the plant itself and it is something you, the client or homeowner values and likes, then it is perfectly acceptable to leave it in place and work/design around it. And that also includes trees planted close to a foundation. It is not automatically a bad thing but again very situational........depending on the tree species and the structural integrity of the foundation, it may very well be a non-issue. So by all means, go ahead and break the 'rules'....because they really do not exist outside of using some common sense :-) If it works for you and you like it, then go for it!!
...See More
Related Professionals
Orland Park Siding & Exteriors · South Windsor Siding & Exteriors · Montebello Home Builders · Edmond Painters · Midlothian Painters · Abington General Contractors · Universal City General Contractors · Fayetteville Architects & Building Designers · Mundelein Furniture & Accessories · Rossmoor General Contractors · Stillwater General Contractors · Cleveland Painters · Moorpark Painters · Yorba Linda Painters · East Haven Flooring Contractors
N K
Original Author
last month
Yes, the new door is the color of the decking, which I’ll be having rebuilt and finished in the same color.

I also debated eventually changing the sunroom siding color to the cream white color. And I didn’t want a monochrome color scheme for that. Thoughts on this idea?

I’d really prefer not to get rid of my cream white trim on the rest of the house.

The cream color wasn’t an option in this new door series and I would have just gotten that. But I needed lower thresholds inside to prevent trip hazard.
0
Jennifer Hogan
last month
I think it looks fine as is. My sliding glass doors are taupe tone and my window trim is cream. It was that way when I bought the house and I didn't even really notice or think about it until I had to replace one of the sliding glass doors. I replaced with another taupe as the whites were all too bright.
N K
Original Author
last month
AI suggested these options to me and I’m thinking about breaking up the green with my window trim and gutter color on the main part of my sunroom. I feel like that may help everything tie in better.
0
Jennifer Hogan
last month
I think I like yours better without the trim. Unlike the AI generated pictures your home has narrow trim and not a lot of space between the door and the windows. Right now you have nice balance and symmetry. For me the trim around the door feels too busy. But you are the one who has to love the way your home looks.
0
N K
Original Author
last month
Yes I agree. But above and between the boards are flat trim boards and T-111 barn siding above. The flat boards, AI suggested painting: these are wide.
0
N K
Original Author
last month
Here’s a look at the rear of the room. If you zoom in you can see what I mean about boards around doors and windows and barn siding. Someone and AI both suggested to me to paint these flat boards the trim color to break up all the green.
0
mojavemaria
last month
Do you have to keep the green? Your roof and railing lean red, the brick yellow and the siding green. If you painted the siding either a taupe to go with your roof or a buff to blend with your brick it might be a better look.
N K
Original Author
last month
What about the cream that my trim is painted?
0
N K
Original Author
last month
I’m very open to this idea…. Thank you. I’m not sold on the green either. It was a spur of the moment idea and I had been torn between Evergreen Fog, neutrals, and a burn orange color. When it was painted Evergreen Fog a few years ago I liked it better than the chocolate brown the previous owners had it. However, it’s wearing on me.

I see pictures like the one below and I’m leaning more towards neutrals.
0
mojavemaria
last month
Your inspiration pic is great but it doesn't have the reddish roof and yellowish brick that your house has. If you are planning on changing your roof and painting your brick then you can go a lot of different ways but otherwise working with them would look best.

The original color of brown was probably picked because brown has red in it and it would have related to the roof. I have a pink house that looks tan and though I don’t like pink it works with our roof and landscape so it stays. Good Luck!
0

Am I breaking exterior color design rules?

Comments (12)

HALLETT & Co.

mojavemaria

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

N K
Original Author

Jennifer Hogan

N K
Original Author

Jennifer Hogan

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author

mojavemaria

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author

mojavemaria

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Am I breaking exterior color design rules?

Comments (12)

HALLETT & Co.

mojavemaria

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

N KOriginal Author

Jennifer Hogan

N KOriginal Author

Jennifer Hogan

N KOriginal Author

N KOriginal Author

mojavemaria

N KOriginal Author

N KOriginal Author

mojavemaria

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author

N K
Original Author