a full view or panels with a frosted glass for privacy, Factory finish wood or fiberglass... I would choose a white door, especially if you have direct exposure.

Need picture of whole house to recommend door type

Would you be interested in painting the shutters/garage grey and then decide on door‘s color. Seeing your entire home would help, but I think it might soften the brick, feel more modern, be more complementary to your front step, and open up more color options for front door. What color is your roof? Do you still want double doors or are open to sidelights? (Don’t know enough about fibreglass vs wood to comment.)

I think that your "rusty" paint color is what some Frank Lloyd Wright people call Cherokee Red, not that this matters.

I love the single door with sidelights!

Thanks all! We like the double doors because it’s easy for moving things, but would consider single with side panels. Does this full picture help for color ideas?

The dark color shutters…seems overkill with all the color variations in the brick.. I would go with a paler color for less contrast..even white… would allow the brick the attention it deserves..also the big tree seems out of place there..moving it ,away from the house to where it can be seen …separate from the house …with it’s own flower bed ..would be much more in proportion..

I'd keep your double doors - they look great. Opt for something like this, with privacy glass, in white or a reddish wood tone

I would go with a single door and two sidelites or a double door with 3/4 glass as indicated above. And natural wood finish. It would add an element of real wood to your home and look great with your brick.

Decide on the type of glass to suit the style/amount of privacy needed and hardware/lighting choices are important as well.

Seeing your entire home, I’d be tempted to remove the shutters, but I’d definitely paint them/garage to work with the roof. If interested in making additional changes down the road, landscaping adjustments would have a nice impact.