You may want to sample this gray from Benjamin Moore, with a darker blue/gray for the trim to complement the slate.

I actually like the white and I’d just paint over it with a coat of fresh white paint. Maybe change up the trim color.

Inspiration

Traditional Craftsman colors are warm earth tones. You said you don’t like the yellowish white, but are you open to a warm palette otherwise?

Yes, this beige color just looks too creamy.

What a lovely house. It reads beige/tan on my screen. It’s best to take pictures when the sun is at your back so the structure you are photographing is well lit.

• https://www.sherwin-williams.com/en-us/color/color-collections/architectural-paint-colors/craftsman-design-exterior-paint-colors

• https://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/color-overview/color-palettes/color-by-style/craftsman-paint-color-palette

• https://modernbungalow.com/blogs/historic-homes/the-ultimate-guide-to-craftsman-color-palettes

• https://www.thisoldhouse.com/curb-appeal/21017983/paint-color-ideas-for-craftsman-houses

Please consider something besides white. If you don’t like warm colors, a blue or green like this would look awesome with the slate

I agree with the suggestions for a warmer Craftsman color. i like white houses but i don’t think it would look great on your house, plus, i think white houses have been overdone the past several years, often inappropriately,. And this is coming from someone (me) living in a white house !

I am another that doesnt like the white, nor the cream. I do like the blue above, or even a shade less blue, and more gray, and darker trim. The roof looks gray. The brown, does not go with the roof. Take your colors from the beautiful slate you have there already.

More inspro

In the photos the gold tone of the slate is noticeable enough that I’d want to include that in my color scheme. the earthy teal green beeboo22 shows is gorgeous.

Thanks to you all for your input! i think I will look at the Craftmans colors and be bold with one of them.

Sage green.