Totally disagree about skylights leaking. I've had them for over 20 years and they have never leaked. You do need to have them installed by someone who knows what they are doing. Mine were done by a very experienced roofing crew. When I did my remodel 5 years ago, I replaced the ones that were 15 years old and no leaks at all.

I have two in my kitchen and if it didn't involve some major construction, I'd put them in other rooms also. Buy good skylights and get a good installer. I think you'll be happy.