skip to main content

Have I killed my pin oak?

last year

I'm worried. Yesterday I was in fever pitch weeding and cleaning up our property. When I came to a pin oak tree there was a small, but stiff stalk growing near the base of the trunk. The leaves were NOT like pin oak. They were more ovate. Anyway, I cut it and applied some Fertilome stump killer and went on with my clean up. This morning I woke up in a panic, wondering if that might have been a shoot from the tree and would the stump killer kill the tree. I've gone out to look for it, thinking I'd try to trim it deeper if possible, but can't find it. Would anyone have good insight on what I've just done or should be doing? Thanks.

Featured Answer

BillMN-z-2-3-4

last year

I wouldn't be too concerned with such a large tree. Even if the shoot was from the pin oak, each root shoot is fed by one partial area of the roots and although I don't recommend doing that, it probably isn't going to cause noticeable or lasting damage to the tree.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

bengz6westmd
last year
last modified: last year
If the "sprout" wasn't from the pin oak, then there prb'ly isn't a problem. If it was, I'm not sure.
0
BillMN-z-2-3-4
last year
last modified: last year
How big was the pin oak?

The larger the tree, the more stump killer it would take to make the tree sick and the better chances it would have to 'shrug it off' over time.

A drop of stump killer on a smaller shoot wouldn't necessarily transfer any amount to a different tree unless they were somehow root grafted together in the ground. Spilling any real amount of liquid SK onto exposed or very shallow roots maybe another matter.
Related Discussions
I may have killed my strawberries in my towers.
Q
Comments (7)
An update to my strawberries. I killed them. So, being the diligent consumer I ordered some new ones from Nourse and they will arrive next week. One of the things I'm thinking of trying is to put screen door screening inside the tower and slice a hole in it to insert the strawberries. To reaquaint everyone with my science experiment, I have 6' sections of PVC pipe with an 8" diameter. The pipe has holes drilled in a honeycomb - each pipe has 100 or so strawberry holes. The pipe is filled with 1:1:1 mix (crushed granite, Turface and pine bark fines). The mix is large enough to easily go out the holes before the strawberry roots lock everything in place. Last time I covered the outside of the pipe with newspaper and cut holes for planting in the PVC hole. This worked reasonably well. I'm thinking that the screening will easily hold everything in place for much longer. It will eventually rust, but I'm not sure that's really a big issue. Anyone have any thoughts? Andrew
...See More
Death to my lawn? I think I may have just killed it!
Q
Comments (4)
I think the weed killer in the fertilizer may interfere with the grass germinating. It's generally safe to use on lawns, but only after they're established. It's kind of late to try to seed a lawn, anyway, so maybe your best recourse is to try to get the weeds under control between now and when the temperatures start to drop and reseed then. The best time to reseed is probably sometime between August 15 and September 15.
...See More
pin oak is my new shade tree
Q
Comments (6)
I had considered planting pin oak for some much-needed shade, but I spoke with a family member about their pin oak, planted when I was a kid. He had to have it removed a few years ago. He got about 20 mostly trouble-free years out of it in zone 8. I enjoy reading Steve Nix's Forestry Blog at about.com, and here's what he has to say about Pin Oaks http://forestry.about.com/od/treeplanting/p/bad_pin.htm If I lived in zone 9 and had a more "coastal south" soil, I'd be rushing to plant a live oak, but that's just me. I recently went to New Orleans and so many of them were left standing after the storm, I was shocked. Also, as far as your temperature zone goes, Red Maple would probably do batter in zone 9 than Pin Oak, but do what you like. I hope it grows well. Not much can beat a good shade tree! Here is a link that might be useful: Reconsider Pin Oak
...See More
HELP! I think I've killed my Pin Oak
Q
Comments (15)
Just an update - the tree is officially dead. Every leaf is brown to orange. The arborist told me it wasn't necessarily my fault the tree died, because it would take more than a dog pen over its roots to kill it. He suspects that it was stressed previously by construction that took place around its base prior to me buying the property. I think he was trying to make me feel better about the situation. I've gotten a good quote for removal, $1700 to take down and leave wood on premises, $2000 to take down and remove + $125 to grind out the stump. He is willing to take $900 to get rid of the tree, letting me make a payments on the balance up to 6 months. I haven't had tree work of this size done before, but I think this is a decent price. I'm looking for a replacement tree that I can put in the bare spot. Something that will be big enough to provide shade in about 5 years. I appreciate any suggestions.
...See More
Related Professionals
Berwyn Landscape Contractors · Braintree Landscape Contractors · Hayden Landscape Contractors · North Richland Hills Landscape Contractors · Salem Landscape Contractors · Shoreline Siding & Exteriors · Southampton Siding & Exteriors · Wilmington Siding & Exteriors · Welby Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Chicago Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Des Moines Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Fort Myers Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Fullerton Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · New Albany Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Prichard Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures
ksmetamaid
Original Author
last year
last modified: last year
BillMN-z-2-3-4, it's an old established pin oak. Big. The trunk is 2' in diameter, I suppose and I'm terrible at estimating height. I was hoping what you said would be true. -That it would take a lof of stump killer to kill the whole tree. I only applied enough to cover that stem/stalk.
0
rhizo_1 (North AL) zone 7
last year
I urge you to read the directions on your stump killer. If you don’t have the directions any longer, find them on line. Stump killers are different than other herbicides.
BillMN-z-2-3-4
last year
Fertilome stump killer is applied to fresh cut stumps undiluted.
0

Related Stories

HOUSEPLANTS 8 Houseplants You Can't Kill

By J. Peterson Garden Design

They're forgiving and let you forget. Houseplants don't get any easier than this

GARDENING GUIDES Celebrate Eastern Oaks for Wildlife, Longevity and Seasonal Interest

By Benjamin Vogt / Monarch Gardens

There might not be a more important tree to have in your eastern U.S. landscape — if you can fit one in

DECORATING GUIDES The Dumbest Decorating Decisions I’ve Ever Made

Caution: Do not try these at home

TREES Great Design Plant: Southern Live Oak Offers an Unbeatable Canopy

By Falon Mihalic

Keep it dense or prune it for more light. No matter how you grow Quercus virginiana, it’s a majestic addition to its native landscape

FLOWERS AND PLANTS This Fragrant, Flowering Ground Cover Thrives Under Shady Oaks

By Oakley Gardens

Island gooseberry, or Ribes viburnifolium, is a California native that’s at home in low-water gardens

FEEL-GOOD HOME 12 Very Useful Things I've Learned From Designers

By Becky Harris

These simple ideas can make life at home more efficient and enjoyable

CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANTS Great Design Plant: Coast Live Oak

The stuff of legends and memories, this California tree is one to build a whole landscape around

GARDENING GUIDES How I Learned to Be an Imperfect Gardener

By Benjamin Vogt / Monarch Gardens

Letting go can lead to a deeper level of gardening and a richer relationship with the landscape. Here's how one nature lover did it

KITCHEN CABINETS Why I Combined Open Shelves and Cabinets in My Kitchen Remodel

By Lyndsye Felsman // By Design Podcast

A designer and her builder husband opt for two styles of storage. She offers advice, how-tos and cost info

BATHROOM MAKEOVERS What I Learned From My Master Bathroom Renovation

By Becky Harris

Houzz writer Becky Harris lived through her own remodel recently. She shares what it was like and gives her top tips

Sponsored

More Discussions

looking at marcesence

1

Red maple inosculation

3

fence builder put a nail in a tree ...

17

Gum Balls clean up

0

Is this tree a problem?

1