Have you thought about black, to blend with the shutters.

Just to get an idea:

The Behr one —

I came across this London house, it’s BM New York State Of Mind —

I don’t know the blues on the next two, just wanted to show darker ones (and the first with black shutters) —

Tons of great blues out there, I’d sample a few to see them in different lights.

Thanks so much! Would you just keep it simple and do black or try a blue?

I like both ideas. You certainly can’t go wrong with classic black, but the right blue could look nice, too. Since you just moved in (congtats, btw!), you might want to keep it simple for now and go with black, then revisit later?

If you decide you want blue, I’d go with a deeper, darker one for more presence.

I’m worried the blue gray roof doesn’t go with the black so I guess that’s why I’m thinking the door could tie it in. I could also repaint shutters a navy. My indecisiveness is real. 🤦‍♀️😂

Understandable! It’s a big decision. Maybe sit on it a bit, look around for inspiration, test some samples, etc. Would like to see what you end up doing, lovely house. :)