Hi McFlurry we just went through the same thing we wanted grays with a beige tone. We picked SW Perfect Greige for bottom, SW spalding gray for shakes and SW turkish coffee for shutters and accent...our door will be stained as well. I don't think you can go wrong with any colors you picked....adaptive shade is really nice. Good luck!!

I hope you don't hate me for being honest. And I realize this doesn't answer, really, the color question(s) you've posed. Here goes anyway. The biggest problem I'm seeing - from here - is that the trim color doesn't work with the gray/black brick. The harmony that should exist between the trim color and the permanent elements on the house isn't happening. Altho I understand the "baked on" point, it's not doing the house any favors so the question becomes just because it's "baked on" is it really an advantage. Even tho the gutters and fascia are a baked on finish is not going to last forever. It's going to need maintenance and painting eventually. One way to look at the situation is, "Saving" it just because it's there and baked on at the cost of the overall cohesion and aesthetic of the curb appeal is kind of a high price to pay for what may actually just be an illusion of a maintenance free, forever finish. A new trim color, stain color, and front door color could go a long way in making the most of the permanent elements you have to work with and the overall curb appeal of the house. JMHO.

amazing gray is a greige.. I have it in our master bath and I can't imagine it clashing with bronze/brown colored windows... it also doesn't show green undertones in our bath- if anything, it will look slightly lavender in certain lights, but not nearly as much a revere pewter did. I doubt if you'll have that problem outside... I would make sure that balanced beige wasn't too pinkish before you decided on that... where will the stone be? the entire front? will the stucco only be in the back?

The houses I’ve seen painted grey and white with the orange barrel roof don’t look “right” to my eyes. They are telling two different stories so I hope you get big samples of both house and trim colors to check this out before you decide. If your tired of the peach a cream with medium to dark brown trim would work with your roof and look more updated and fresh.