Nice house and yard. Consider choosing a dark bold brown for the fascia/soffit (and, perhaps, around your bold red door) but leave all the window trim white. A lighter brown for the siding you're adding would work well. https://www.pellabranch.com/blog/global-blogs/black-window-frames/ If the additional work to be done is changing out the windows, replace the large ?fixed? window with a pair that open and consider choosing black frames. You could then consider choosing a dark bold brown for window trim as well.

And, I don’t want to make your head explode,,,but, there is a way to tie your front door colour and trim, even more closely to the brick. There is a tiny device ($55) which connects to an app on your phone. It actually measures the colour of the brick. it’s as quick as taking a photo. With a surface as varied as yours I would measure about 5 different bricks. get the average Hue angle to plot ot on the colour wheel. That makes it very easy to find paint colours to harmonise with it from the same Hue Family. Once you have that, you can find lighter/darker/warmer/cooler/more grey/ more colourful colours to work closely with ithe brick. They will relate as they belong to the same Hue Family.

Thanks for all this great advice! @kandrewspa Our original thought *was* dark green—BM Essex or Chrome Green! When I pulled the picture into Photoshop and colored it, we weren't sure with the blueish slate floor. It might just be that the Tudor Brown that is making it feel off. Hopefully, that will be gone. I'll post a pic... @Jennifer Hogan We would like it to speak to the interior as well. The foyer as you enter is not done yet, but the room to the right and kitchen straight ahead that you can see are 90% there, so we will definitely take into consideration the color-ways there when deciding. Great point! The cranberry/blue-leaning red is the present color that we will be painting over. You can see a bit of it on the side door as well... @tracefloyd We love the blue, too! It's one of the colors we'll be grabbing chips for when we hit the paint store. We are still weighing the possibility of keeping and painting the storm because that doorway is like a wind tunnel. A neighbor's home built by the same people has no storm on their arched door and it looks so much better. The former owner of our house built a rectangular frame in front of the beautiful arched door to accommodate the screen. A custom arched storm door is on the long-term list. @houssaon Thanks for the suggestions! We'll grab those chips when we hit the paint store. @Patricia Colwell Thank you for the invitation to rethink the shake siding. We saw it on a much larger, more modern tudor with a pretty standard brick pattern and consistent color. Our house is made from bricks that were rejected by the brick factory and pretty funky and busy, so I see your point! I've been meaning to get a peek behind the aluminum, so maybe I need to get on that. There's a half-moon arched window behind the peak on the front of the house, so we hope to have that repaired and get rid of the siding they added to cover it to expose the brick. It's like that on the back.

A McMansion, huh? Didn't know people were still pursuing this architectural design with all that had been written about avoiding this style trap. The house is huge and hulking and is mostly roof/attic. McMansion is a slang term that describes a large, often opulent or ostentatious, mass- produced house. The name carries a somewhat critical connotation because McMansions lack architectural uniqueness, class, or style. You keep referring to gray...................nothing in your current palette is gray. If they look gray to you, then there are online color blindness tests you can take to determine if you are seeing colors correctly. What's with the large brick corbels at the base of all the gables? Just another applied detail with no design basis. . Do you think you understand exactly how much roof you have on your home as currently designed??????? And how much that roof is costing you?? McMansions