Closing off 2-story foyer but what to do with big window?
We are considering the option to close in our 2-story open foyer to create an additional flex space/play room, and would love advice. I feel like it's a huge waste of potential space but there are some design challenges I'm not sure what to do about.
Specifically, THE BIG WINDOW. We'd probably need to fill it in or reimagine the window in some way. I have no idea if we could match the brick but it seems pretty standard. But, what if we can't? What are some other solution that would not look totally botched
- I hate this window because at night it's a direct eye shot to our daughter's bathroom. Didn't realize the horrible design flaw until we moved in, oops.
- But, it offers a lot of natural light which I so appreciate and would hate to lose. How would you create more natural light once we lose it?
- And, it seems like it's important architecturally to the rest of the house (see pic). Could we close off that window and would it still look good from the front? What should we do?
- It's slightly lower than the rest of the flooring level with the landing, and would be right at floor level or even lower, so it would be a very challenging room to put furniture in. I do not want to create a step-down because then it will be even MORE closed off when you enter the house than it is already.
Would love to hear similar experiences / ideas on how to solve! Also open to the advice that it's a terrible idea and we should just buy a new house. LOL
Comments (14)
5112bird
last yearThanks Patricia! I did not think about the issue with heating/cooling :(. The issue with closing off the railing is that we don't actually create a new space, it will only create privacy. I don't have a birds eye view of the floor plan but the door to the left is the office. It's basically a hallway right now so we wouldn't get any benefit if we only close it off. We might even want to just make that room even bigger to create a flex room (and create play area elsewhere). So, not married to the idea of it being a dedicated playroom but do want to create more space.
If we do close off the landing to create privacy, will it look weird next to the other railing?
Related Discussions
Major noise problems with 2-story foyer
Comments (11)This is unfortunately one of the biggest reasons not to buy one of these homes. The soaring ceilings really attract people visually -- the whole "grand space" concept first popularized by Gothic cathedrals -- but the lack of privacy walls and (sometimes) interior insulation makes for your own personal Radio City Music Hall instead of the Peaceful Shelter one first envisions. You may need a contractor to install some framing in order to put a door blocking your upstairs rooms from the stairway (do I have that correctly visualized?). You need a header put in, as well as a sill. Get a solid-core or Masonite door -- ask at your local lumber store (NOT a big box store!) for something that fits your budget and will block the most sound. Assuming your walls are insulated -- if not, don't bother with the next step: put weatherstripping around it as any air gaps transmit sound. You should also check whether your interior walls are insulated. We visited a friend in a new development recently and I was amazed, in a bad way, how much sound was transmitted between rooms on the same floor. Another problem you may have is that you may have little or no insulation between the first and second floors. This is something that some developers skimp on. Sound travels up as well as down....See MoreSpeaking of that 2nd Story Foyer Window...
Comments (12)Well, we do use the outlet for Christmas light. I am planning on painting it the color of the wall (cover and outlet both so it just "goes away"). The window is a double hung because from the outside it looks like the other windows on the 2nd floor. The house is called a "Victorian Farmhouse", so the windows across the front all look the same, you aren't supposed to think it has a 2 story foyer from the outside. Perhaps when we do replace it someday, we will choose a different style for there. Now you see why I'm interested in adding the faux window below it...too much wall space between the window and the door. This option will cost nothing, so I can try it out to see since I have that antique window in my family room hiding the hideous fireplace insert....I do like the idea of adding trim to the window, but none of the other windows in the house have this, but I guess it would match the door. There is just too much wall space in this foyer. I really want to add wood wainscott to the stairs and hall areas. But I have to take my dh into consideration...I think his bp is high enough! I'm also considering having some of our travel photos (upcoming European cruise) printed in b/w on canvas for the foyer--really large ones. This might help eat up some of the wall space. My dh keeps telling me to "just do a David Bromstad painting technique on canvas"--yeah right. thanks for the ideas....See MoreWhat do you think about a stone wall in a 2 story foyer/entry?
Comments (23)Call me crazy, but if a house has a foyer that "feels more like a hotel lobby", you have other, much bigger problems -- like creating a warm and welcoming home. lindsey, I do know about cutting off the blossom end : ). As for shorter canning times, I was born a city girl and have always been nervous with recipes from family and friends with canning times considerably shorter than what district home economists, Ball Blue Book etc. recommend, which is usually 15-20 minutes for quart jars and no less than 10 minutes; my mother in law has been trying to convince me for 25 years that it's safe to chicken in a boiling water bath in a regular canner rather than a pressure canner, and I'm just not willing to risk it, esp when it comes to my husband and kids. We're also probably pickier about taste than some people -- for example, I used to process in the canner 1- and 2-quart jars of the apple cider we press every fall, but we realized we don't care for the "cooked" taste, so we freeze the cider now instead. Some people have wine fridges and we have a pickle fridge lol. And several chest freezers for cider, our own beef, chickens, turkeys, venison, fruit and vegetables! april, the chicks stay in the incubator in the house just until they're dry and then out they go. We don't always have helpful broody hens to do the setting for us so the incubator is a huge help....See MoreTwo Story Great Room - Closed off Second Floor?
Comments (16)Jennifer K - We're looking at an A-Frame which typically has the two story of windows, although it's a vaulted ceiling and not totally opened to other space above. We like the modern A frame for our lot which is in the forest in a country setting. I guess we could always keep the A frame style in the exterior but not inside? That may be odd though. We're meeting our architecture/design team on Monday, but we wanted to have a good idea of our wants and needs so that we communicate them well. chispa - We do use a baby monitor. we don't necessarily need to hear what they do upstairs, I'm just more worried about how loud the main floor is for them when they're trying to sleep and we're down there. I've searched the forum which is what lead me here. Most of the posts mention two story rooms opened to the second floor, but I hadn't been able to find lots about two story rooms which were closed off to the second floor....See More- PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
last year 
PROWindows on Washington Ltd
last year
PRORappArchitecture
last year5112bird
last yearsofikbr
last year
We have simmilar layout with bathroom door in the view. privacy film fix it, and added nice decorative element.
- PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
last year 
lucky998877
last year
Mary Iverson