Builder is withholding keys

HU-925329097

last year

Can a home builder with hold keys if we

cant agree on final draw. ?

Featured Answer

bry911

last year

@HU-925329097 - I think you need to consult with an attorney before you do anything else. Whoever produced the buildable plans had a duty to ensure that all measurements were correct, rarely would a builder have a duty to verify measurements on plans that they didn't produce. If there were contradictory numbers you might argue that they should have sought clarification, but their counter is going to be they had no duty to verify and therefore it wasn't their job to catch the error.

In my experience the builder is going to win this and your best bet is to try to negotiate a lower amount. Of course, I am making a lot of assumptions on the details I don't have and your particular situation may have nuance that will change that.

---

In every state it was always your property, even if you haven't paid the builder a single cent. A builder may have a clause that doesn't allow the owner access to the home during construction, that still doesn't give them the right to keep you out, it just means that your entry on the property would be a breach of contract, I doubt that many courts would find that a material breach, but it is possible.

However, the builder's biggest tool to encourage payment is a mechanic's lien. Mechanic's liens are very easy to get, but harder to perfect. In other words, there is a good chance that you are going to get a lien on your property even if you don't believe you owe the money. The builder then has some period of time to perfect the lien. Perfecting a mechanic's lien is not easy and it can be quite expensive, but if/when perfected your home is in foreclosure, which most people just pay rather than have their home foreclosed on.

Again, consult with an attorney in your area, who has construction experience. I suspect you might be better off paying the contractor and suing him for breach of contract for the driveway than allowing him to get a mechanic's lien.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (15)

rrah
last year
What does your contract say?
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
Its says all change orders have to be paid, final draw signed problem is he owes us concrete driveway, and wont agree on the amount we have on estimates to withhold and he wont sign until we sign a much lesser amount. if hes really coming back to do job he shouldnt care if amount is higher. live in ohio its been 15 month build for 2800 ranch
Related Discussions
Lanlord Refuses to Give the New Keys to the Tenant
Q
Comments (4)
Thank you for taking time to respond. Yes, of course it has everything to do with the refusal to give me the new keys... I reported several major problems with the apartment (leaking roof, faulty wiring, flooding of the kitchen when shower is on, garbage disposal broken and kitchen sink is un-usable, etc etc etc) to the landlord at the end of September (7 days before new months rent was due). By the time October rent became due the landlord still hasnÂt lifted a finger to fix any of the problems I reported. So I held back rent. He filed eviction and began all kinds of retaliatory actions: cutting off my electricity for a couple of hours here and there, physically disconnecting my internet cable at the cable box and after I figured that out and connected it back he simply cut the cable that was running through his storage space in half and put a pad lock on the storage door , so I couldnÂt get in and try to fix it; hosing off the deck above me and ruining all of my stuff that was sitting below by getting it wet, etc etc and the latest one is the key withholding. I do have a trial date set but itÂs not until the end of February and I canÂt wait that long until I have my keys. So I was wondering if I can somehow force him to give me the keys or may be the Elevator Association can be forced to give me the keys. After all they are the once ultimately responsible for anything to do with the elevator, including issuing keys.
...See More
Meeting Builder What about out requirements?
Q
Comments (11)
Our GC had a wonderful exercise for us. His assignment even before we met was to have DH & me write out our top 20 items/ideas for the house (in order of importance). We did this seperarately w/o knowing each other's top 20. We then brought this list to GC on our first meeting. This enabled him to get the big picture. We also took these lists to the architect. Along with this list, was a photo of what we desired & a layout we thought we liked. As the process has developed, all of our smaller, nitpicky items have come out. GC has appreciated the thought process that I've put into it all. He said it has made everything move smoothly. In the end, I will have less daily choices to make. Although I did SO much research prior to all of our meetings, I have welcomed GC's ideas & knowledge, as well. Afterall, we are hiring him for his skills, knowledge, & expertise. He has been doing this 30+ years & I have only just recently begun this process. I definitely would not go into this seeming like a total know-it-all or you will make GC's life quite unpleasant. Also, in all honesty, about 90% of our desires for our home, GC had already planned for, so I would really be looking for the best GC you can find.
...See More
Outside door handle-sets and keys. Also keyless entry question?
Q
Comments (8)
Unless you have a big box phobia check Home Depot or Lowes. We used a Schlage brand. We found in stock 4 sets all keyed the same....there is a number on the box indicating what the key is. They said they would rekey the rest for $5.00 each. We ended up just putting the 4 keyed alike in the regularly used entries. I got a cheap keyless doorhandle for one door, but the batteries went dead pretty quickly and I haven't bothered to replaced them. Doing it over again I would get one that requires no batteries or power.
...See More
what is there in between 'turn-key' and DIY?
Q
Comments (6)
That's nearly exactly how we did our build. I found a GC who was willing to take things to the dry-in and then I was going to use all my subs that I had worked with before along with my own labor to finish out the build. My family has also been involved in more than a few large remodels with many subs and lots of our own labor so I felt like it would work well. In the end, I ended up using quite a few of the GC's subs for jobs that I planned to sub out myself because the quotes were good and he vouched for their work. Get as many quotes up front as you can and make sure that not using the GC soup to nuts will save you money. In the end, I don't think I saved much if any money. Mostly because we did not have the luxury of time that you did, so I had to pay people to get things done even though I could have done them given enough time. The nice thing about our arrangement though was that the GC never felt like he had me in his grasp. He knew that there was a limited amount of work agreed upon at the start and if things didn't go well, that would be it. It helped me a lot too to not feel like I was locked in if things did not go well. In the end, they went great. I couldn't be happier with the GC and his subs, it was more my subs that were annoying (late, over their bids, sloppy, etc.) whereas my GC stuck to his numbers (in all but one or two cases) and the quality of work was very good. If you can find a GC willing to do this kind of work, I think it can work well, but be sure to get bids for all stages, as it might make sense if things are working out, to just have the GC continue on. That was something I was not expecting, but it did work out well.
...See More
bry911
last year
last modified: last year
If it is your land, it is your house at every stage of construction. Builders may write access clauses into contracts, but the owner still has all rights of ownership, even if it breaches the contract.

The recourse for nonpayment is a mechanic’s lien, not illegal possession.
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
Ok good. it IS my land . Does that apply even in Ohio? do you happen to lnow a code or section of law thay supports your theory?
dan1888
last year
last modified: last year
Have a locksmith assist you. If you give the Builder a check, include Full and Final Payment on the reverse.
just_janni
last year
Your closing attorney can work to negotiate a final draw amount. It should cover the cost of a driveway and no more (the undone work) so that you could get it elsewhere if necessary. Your attorney should help here - get another estimate of the cost of a driveway, have attorney withhold that amount in a letter.
PRO
Charles Ross Homes
last year
Are you able to get a permanent certificate of occupancy without the driveway? Are there HOA requirements for the type of driveway you need to install?
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
I have the copy of CO and own the lot no HOA
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
Im going to pay the change orders , he

is adding bogus change orders for work he did that he did not give estimate for ( dim dimensions were wrong on the drawing and they kept building anyway without getting clarification. Hence kitchen was 15” smaller and they had to re do now at last minute hes trying to charge us for the rework.
cpartist
last year
What does your attorney say?
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
Which is exactly what i did ok thank you sir
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
I would like the credit due back to us

so were gonna ask for it tomorrow
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
The cobcrete is part ofbthe co tract he has not done or even mentioned he thinks we forgot he owes us a credit for work not done OR we can withold that amount of final draw but rather have him take what je owes us off of the change orders and then we can realease all monies and not have to ever see him again
HU-925329097
Original Author
last year
Paint on front abd rear porch, gutter install on rear pirch (1) , paint front abd overhead door , install light post

Builder is withholding keys

bry911

Comments (15)

rrah

HU-925329097
Original Author

Related Discussions

bry911

HU-925329097
Original Author

dan1888

just_janni

Charles Ross Homes

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

cpartist

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Builder is withholding keys

bry911

Comments (15)

rrah

HU-925329097Original Author

Related Discussions

bry911

HU-925329097Original Author

dan1888

just_janni

Charles Ross Homes

HU-925329097Original Author

HU-925329097Original Author

cpartist

HU-925329097Original Author

HU-925329097Original Author

HU-925329097Original Author

HU-925329097Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author

HU-925329097
Original Author