If you know how to prune bareroot material, and prune some and don't prune some, as a control, you'll never again suggest anything by Whitcomb Really? Since all of the many trials I've read Whitcomb's descriptions of used controls, I wonder how your statement fits. Or maybe your point is that you find out with the not pruning that the not pruning backfires, and you wish you had pruned - instead of using part of the batch as a control. Sometimes with rants it can be hard to tell what is being said. I do know that I am tired of topped deciduous stock being presented here or shipped to me. A rare hawthorn I had here for years never got over the topping and got pulled out; a crab I've had here long enough for it to be fully established and growing vigorously is growing even more all over the place than many kinds of crabs do anyway because it was topped. What I am talking about is arbitrary top pruning, as Whitcomb calls it, and not selective pruning. As for Dirr's publications, if you don't know what is wrong with some of the things he says, then you don't really know the subjects he is saying these things about. This post was edited by bboy on Wed, Nov 13, 13 at 15:00

I have some gojiberry bushes that are rooted in pots. If you are interested, I could use apricot and pear cuttings in the early spring. Do you know the varieties?

I have access to a pomegranate that does well in AZ at 4500 ft. Winters get to 20s and maybe a few nights colder. Plant has leafed out. Can send if you send mailer with postage or if you want special priority from post office send enough for me to buy one of those mailer boxes. I have just started to root cutting for myself. Or I can try to make more cuttings and you can contact me in the fall. It is possible we have emailed before. Variety is unknown, dates from 1920s or 1930s and is lighter pink and sweet.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fmAgtFixPg&feature=youtu.be Jacob and I have been talking about plant propagation and I started thinking we ought to be sharing this on the forum, since a) the forum seriously needs a shot in the arm right now b) this is the right time of year for woody plant cuttings. I have been "Winter Propagating" for many years now, with a pretty good success rate, using quart-sized glass canning jars. One winter, I had some old pickle jars that held probably two quarts and I used those. I'm thinking even the plastic mayonnaise and peanut butter jars would work, too. Their main function is to keep the cold, dry, winter air from dehydrating the cutting before it has a chance to grow roots. I have found that cuttings don't mind the cold as long as they have the protection from the air. Rather than go thru a long tutorial here, I found a YouTube that runs pretty close along the way I do it. That link is here: http://scvrs.homestead.com/Cuttings1.html The submitter of this particular YouTube is rooting roses, but I have also rooted cuttings from Harry Lauder's Walking Stick, all kinds of bushes, blackberry and raspberry canes, and grapevines. Last year, I tried to propagate cuttings from my Aronia bush, but I messed up in the spring by letting the new little plants get too dry. When you use this method, the really tricky part is in the spring when the sun starts heating up the inside of the jar. Normally I'm more careful and I start tipping the jar off for part of the day to "harden off", and then providing shade for the plant during the time it's resting under the jar. So the next selection I would offer you is this one on propagating Nanking Cherry Bushes. Lots of information here that can be applied to almost any cutting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1iAQlTxnB4U This fellow mentions the use of rooting hormone and I have to say I've started cuttings with and without and really don't notice much difference. Most recently, I've seen some people recommending the use of aloe vera gel. Just make sure you cut off the spiny sides of the aloe leaf, as that dark green slime is NOT what you want to use. The good part is the clear. Here are some other selections you might find interesting. I'm assuming you have some time to kill here, in case you hadn't noticed. LOL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_GYGaeeT5C4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w98biG2NVCw It appears that one point of failure for rooting cuttings is that the leaves aspirate and fall off and then the cutting has to struggle to try to make new leaves AND roots. So misting is one alternative and I found a cannabis grower who's got instructions for making his own misting machine. But that made me think that a common sickroom cool-mist humidifier from WMT would do the same thing, easier and cheaper. Somebody mentioned spraying on a biodegradeable leaf spray that is "really a wax" and that made me think of back in the days when everybody had a philodendron in the house and they used to sell leaf wax for that. I can't seem to find a good source for that but I found instructions for cleaning the leaves and water with a little mild dish soap in it was recommended. As long as the cuttings were not going to be in direct sunlight, it might be good for the leaves to have a little dip in some of that. Here is a YouTube posted by a woman using Potassium Permanganate crystals in the water in which the cutting is rooting. "Pot Perm", as it is sometimes referred to, is hard to find here where I am. It's used to disinfect fish tanks. It can be bought on Amazon. But here's the thing: if you get glycerine or sugar in it, it starts a fire. And there are warnings not to get it on your skin unless it is diluted with water to a light pink color. So now I'm not sure I even want to go this direction. Sounds like lots of room for an accident with this stuff. But here's the link if you want to see it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fmAgtFixPg&feature=youtu.be Its main use is as a fungicide. It is sometimes used as a foot soak when there's athlete's foot or some other skin problem that involves fungus. I read somewhere that when the heels dry out and start to crack, that's a form of athlete's foot. But I don't know if that's right. It can treat water and make it safe to drink in an emergency situation. So I'm torn because seems like it might be good to have some of that on hand except for the fire-starting thing and what it might do to your skin if you didn't have it diluted in water. I wouldn't want to be responsible for putting an inquisitive child at risk or accidentally burning my house down because of having some of that in my pantry. Lots to think about, sharing it in case any of you are interested. This year I'm trying again with those Aronia bushes, with a few tweaks using tips I've found on some of those YouTube videos. I'm kinda playing it by ear. I just stuck the ends of the cuttings in sections of aloe leaves to begin with. Haven't decided whether I will try to root them in a pot, maybe in my attached garage where it's cold but never reaches freezing temps. or whether to use the glass jar method outside. Haven't decided whether to take them out of the aloe leaves when I put them in potting soil, or just plant each cutting with the aloe section still on. Decisions, Decisions.....