Sorry, I just realized you mentioned the table is rounded. I would use #2 since the base is stone.

Thanks for the opinions - even if four of the colors have been suggested by at least one person. We have agreed that the brandy (suggested by no one) won't work. It is too reddish pinkish and doesn't go with the cherry cabinets. We have had the colors in the family room most of the day. Sixty, the Oxford blue goes well with the blue in the rug, but we decided that it doesn't really work with the quartzite. The quartzite is an aqua blue and the purer navy blue doesn't exactly clash with it but it doesn't do much for tying into it. Of the Rock, Chocolate and Cognac, we are starting to think that any of them could work. We are leaning toward the Cognac. It doesn't have too much red in it and ties well to the cherry. Part of the cherry grain is the same color as it. What we like about it compared to the Rock and Chocolate is that the Cognac still looks like a color when the room lighting is low while the other two start looking just blackish. The Rock and Chocolate would be a lot of dark surface in the room. I really like all the colors and at least three of them would work but watching them in all the lighting conditions, we think the Cognac is best.

Try this......move the ottoman where your coffee table is now just to see if a darker plane will give you the "anchorage" you're looking for. If that does the trick then you can either purchase a new, dark coffee table or paint the base of your existing one. I think adding an area rug will make the space seem too closed in. I like all your colors.

Thank you @JudyG Designs for pointing that out. The area is 116” by 69” (not including the brick chimney). So fully reclined would take up half the width! I will see how one chair works. Since posting this I have been able to envision the orange chair with the rug shown next to a wall of books.