I had a bad one; we’d just finished it Friday. I got an email from Big A about it (it was part of a Fresh order a while back) the very next day. :(

Here’s hoping none of us get sick!

We have two jars. Neither were in the recall. I rarely eat it, but the Mr. loves his PB and vanilla wafers LOL!

Our jar has been recalled and DH has eaten a few tablespoons with no effect. They say to throw it out but I'm going to return it to the store. It was over $4 and I have the receipt.

I threw out an unopened jar of Jif peanut butter but just thought to look at the number on the open jar. It also has the recall lot number 425 on it. We ate all of it but 2 spoonfuls and no symptoms.

I have a jar of Jif creamy. Already ate about a quarter of the jar and no symptoms. Jif is made in my hometown at the original plant, and when they're roasting peanuts the smell is heavenly.

Oh dear. So sorry. Hope everyone stays well. Fortunately we don't buy Jif, but that doesn't mean it can't happen to our brand too.

Had no idea JIF was owned by Smuckers. My 99+ Mom eats lots of PB - easy protein. We had a few jars of JIF Natural in the recall. Like really, what is safe to eat anymore !!

Can any recalled jr be fed to birds? Woodpeckers, nuthatches? What if heated sell first?

Just checked my half-empty jar. Yup, on recall list. I feel doubly bad though--I've also been using it to bait mouse traps.

I bought some to ue for Vietnamese peanut sauce — I otherwise use Teddy natural chunky unsalted. I was relieved my jar wasn’t on the recall list. The peanut sauce was yummy.

JIF--people really buy that brand???

The recall has been expanded to other products that contain Jif.

Other food products in recall

I know someone who ate the recalled peanut butter, before she knew it was recalled, last week. She got violently sick. She said it was a bad 24 hours but got better from there. Her spouse, who reports he ate way more than she did, is fine.

Arcy, yes. I like JIF peanut butter. But I am trying to lose a few pounds now, so sugared pb is on my no fly list.

Ally, how awful! Glad she’s feeling better.

I got Skippy Natural yesterday. DH and I agree on most things … but not pb. I like crunchy, he likes creamy. I need some bite in mine!

Jojo, what are you getting now? I’d like to get something healthier, too.

Jinx, I'm actually staying clear of all pb for now. The healthier brands don't do it for me. I like the sugar, lol.

I'm embarrassed to admit I like the sugar in PB too. Which is weird in some ways because I love "pure" nuts. Literally any nut - you can't find a nut, legume, or vegetable that I don't like it its unadulterated form.

But for PB? I love me some Jiff. If that relegates me to low brow status in some eyes...I'm ok with that. :)

ETA - I also like some cheap wines. Feel free to clutch your pearls now....

Jif has molasses and I always felt it made it peanuttier. I bought Skippy because the shelves were empty of Jif when I replaced my jar. Skippy is sweeter than what I remember.

I sometimes have a spoonful of pb as an afternoon snack but most of the time I eat a few walnuts. They have more health benefits.

I’ve never understood sugar in PB. Or applesauce, for that matter. Anyway, one of our grocery stores makes their own peanut butter and boy, is it good. Peanuts and salt.

I like Jif extra crunchy. DH likes Peter Pan creamy, so we buy both. Also don’t care for natural PB either. One TBS is 95 calories, but yes, I realize it’s the sugar.

Ally De, one of my top three favorite sandwiches is a Fluffernutter sandwich on store bought bread.. Hey, the Fluff matches my pearls.😊

LOL Jojo. I like Fluff in hot chocolate so you get zero judgement from me. :)

Even if you threw your Jif out, you can still submit a claim and they’ll send a coupon for a replacement. TheUPC and product code fields on the form are optional. https://jms-s3-mkt-consumer-p-pmc6.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/recall.html?gclid=CjwKCAjwkMeUBhBuEiwA4hpqEOWt4kdkqc-W12yZYk0EL8iieYmwJyMrGgOYgQvLo-2f1-QdpNgz5BoCQ6sQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

I had several jars of Jif in the pantry that I bought when it was on sale last month. I am not a PB connoisseur and just buy whatever 'name' brand is on sale. None of my JIF was included in the recall.

But I am more selective with my jam and only buy Dickinsons' - it's probably all sugar.

Thanks Mama Cita. I was a bit miffed that there wasn't any news about reimbursement.

Jojoco, Fluffernutter is one of my all time favorite sandwiches, too.

Arcy on here peanut butter shaming. 😆

Mama Cita, thank you for sharing that link! Interestingly enough, A-zon sent me the email with the Fresh order number that had the Jif … when I went to look at it, they’d removed the Jif link. I could see the image of it in my shopping cart, but when I clicked, got a page unavailable.

Weird as it sounds, I bought about 18 pounds of JIF No Sugar Added peanut butter on Amazon back in March. The were 8 jars each weighing about 2.5 pounds, It was a very good price, and I planned to donate most of it to our local food pantry. But for some reason they couldn't ship it to my home address, so I had them ship it to my parent's independent living apartment in a senior facility. Just forgot to tell my mother I was doing that. The box was so heavy that the staff carried it up to my mother's apartment and told her not to lift it. When she got it opened she went beserk, not understanding why Amazon had sent her 18 pounds of peanut butter! So she began giving it away to other residents, my brothers, and just about anyone who stopped by to visit. We did end up having a good laugh once I explained what happened.

Anyhow, it's great peanut butter and makes the best peanut butter cookies. I think the lack of added sugar makes a big difference in the cookies. I managed to save 2 jars after my mother's big giveaway. Doesn't match the recall code, but I'm chucking it out anyhow!