How to save a rose that is being threatened by its' root-stock

last year

The rose in question is the glorious "Sir Paul Smith". This plant has been in place for years, big and wonderful. This fall,I worked on the ground around it a bit,hoping to help out 2 of its' neighbours who weren't doing much-Aristide Briand and Climbing Jacques Cartier. This latter rose has never done much of anything as far as flowering goes; nor has AB, for that matter. Sir PS, instead, has always been great, though it had this odd way of sending out suckers of itself (!) ; I have 3 other Sir SPs which don't do this.

Yesterday I noticed that SirPS looked awful,and went to investigate. AB had grown a lot, and is covered in buds. The wretched Clbg. J Cartier was covered in buds, too-all of which looked bull-nosed. The few flowers that were opened were ugly, proliferated, etc. SirSP, instead, was sending up tons of suckers-but this time from rootstock! I pulled these out,weeded,watered and fertilized SPS with liquid fert.- and CHOPPED DOWN Clbg JC-enough of its' nonsense!!!

So now,I'm wondering how to approach this situation further,in order to (hopefully) save SPS. I think I will probably prune back some of its' laterals (some of which seem to be dying),and obviously must keep an eye on pulling out rootstock shoots. But perhaps I also need to remove some other neighbours? Is this plant probably doomed,or can I save it with a bit of coddling? I can't do a whole lot of that,what with the size of my garden and the lack of running water.

Any thoughts or comments would be much appreciated.

Comments (3)

seasiderooftop
last year
Darn, JC is such a disappointment... I have his white sport and I get exactly what you described with the buds getting ugly. Now he's finally putting on normal flowers, but the scent is only ok, not great... And he's getting blackspot! The only one in my garden this early in the year! You were right to take him down, I'm waiting to see if by some miracle he can take the summer heat which would at least give him one redeeming quality, otherwise he'll have to go. What an overrated rose.

My two cents on your original question:

I think your rootstock suckers on SPS are a consequence of root disruption when you amended the soil. It happened to me after I went a little too deep when forking in various "boosters" around Iceberg. Pruning back dead laterals sounds like a good idea in any case, but the suckering should subside on its own now that the soil is being left alone.
bart bart thanked seasiderooftop
Melissa Northern Italy zone 8
last year
My own root 'Jacques Cartier' is fine, on the other hand, and the flowers are always shapely. It gets some Damask crud in time, but I don't worry about it. Are the white sport and the climbing form fussier than their sport parent? By the way, JC, along with 'Enfant de France', 'Reine des Violettes' (one grafted, one, puny, own root), and 'Ispahan', all Damasks or Hybrid Damasks, is growing in heavy rocky dank soil and thriving on it.
bart bart thanked Melissa Northern Italy zone 8
Related Discussions
How to save this rose?
Q
Comments (3)
First I'd follow merediths suggestions. It sounds as if your rosebush may have a disease called " dieback", which is caused by a fungus called spps diplodia. You can tell if it is that because the pith will be mushy inside instead of green-white, and the outside of the dying canes turn black, the plant dies from the tips on downwards which is why it is called dieback. I send a declining rosebush back to nursery conditions. Small baby rosebushes are grown from cuttings under mist, or under a jar. This provides a greenhouse type atmosphere for the rosebush. This is the only method I've ever used that has revived a declining rosebush such as yours. If the rose is in full sun, I'd move a potted plant in front of it to give it filtered sunlight and then put a glass or plastic container over the canopy, being careful that it is big enough so that no leaves touch the glass or plastic. I'd keep it under a glass or plastic container until it is c. a foot tall, and in filtered sunlight until it grows to be c. 2 feet tall. The less it flowers this year the better, I'd want the energy of the plant to be used in building the canopy and root system. I'd remove all or most of the flower buds until it grows to be more than 2 feet tall After it has grown to be more than a foot tall, I'd start feeding it lightly with 5-5-5 the first time and c. 7-7-7- afterwards, every 4 weeks during the growing season. All this should help it grow back. T.L.C. goes a long way with roses. Good luck, may your rosebush survive and thrive, Lux.
...See More
Advice on how to move a rose that rooted thru a pot.
Q
Comments (7)
For exactly this reason, I don't set potted roses directly on soil. It helps to place a couple of bricks under the pot to prevent soil contact. I once lost a rose when this happened in my own garden. It did not survive the double shock of losing the root that grew out of the bottom of the pot, and then being transplanted into the ground. For that reason, my thought is that you might consider cutting off the root at the bottom of the pot where it emerges, and moving the pot to a place where this cannot happen again. Then wait a couple of weeks before planting the rose. That will give it time to adjust to the loss of the root. It is was a particularly big root, I would prune the top of the rose a bit to keep root and top in balance. Good luck to you. Rosefolly
...See More
Why it's important to be able to root roses
Q
Comments (19)
I think all of us rustlers have rescued a Dr. Huey or two. My best one was just down the road from me last year. There was a house doomed to become a strip center, with a tall rose growing at one of its front corners. It was mid-spring, too early to take cuttings, so I watched the rose weekly ... to get the cuttings as soon I thought they'd be viable. During one of my visits, I was interrupted by the foreman and the engineer for the project. When I told them what I was doing, they told me to take whatever I wanted, to hurry up and not hurt myself, and not to come back. I cut that rose to the ground, and tossed the whole thing into my truck, processed it into cuttings, and put them in the greenhouse. Since the wood was WAY too green, most of the cuttings quickly perished. Two of them rooted, however, and I anxiously awaited their first flowers .... wine-red with bright yellow stamens. Rats! maryann, I get a huge ache inside when I see the destruction of plants and structures that comes with modern suburban development. It breaks my heart. What did the rambler you found look like? Around here, Dorothy Perkins is on the roadsides and up in the trees. That's where mine came from. I also know of a red rambler, that's not endangered yet, that I plan to rustle soon. I have a feeling that it's Excelsa (or something like that) since it blooms late just like DP does. I'm glad all of you have used this method of rooting and that it's worked well. It was taught to me by a rose friend, and I am thankful to her every day. Without this, my nursery would still be an unattainable dream, and I would be without most of the garden friends that I have met over the past few years. Besides, there's just something mysterious and magical about being able to take a piece of a rose and make a whole new rose out of it. Connie
...See More
What happened to my roses? Root stock snapped in half?
Q
Comments (15)
Well, two months later, it happened again. This time in the front yard (with zero gopher mounds in sight, goddamit). I want to recover this rose . What's considered "good potting soil" in your estimation for the purposes of recovering this rose? All my container plants are in Al's 5-1-1 mix (5 parts bark fines, 1 part peat, 1 part perlite). My plants do extremely well in this mix, and it's impossible to overwater, but I'm not sure if 5-1-1 is a good candidate for the recovery of this rose as it isn't the most moisture retentive mix out there. Do you think 5-1-1 would work? You prescribe that I water the damaged rose every other day (I'm guessing you're basing this on your personal experience, as we have the same climate). Is this really necessary? My experience of watering something a thirsty plant every other day in standard Miracle Gro potting mix, even in the summer, is that it leads to root rot. Then again, I have been known to have a heavy hand when I watering. Maybe watering this damaged rose every day in 5-1-1 would be the way to go for me? I already have lots of 5-1-1 mix prepared, but no bags of standard potting mix. Thanks
...See More
bart bart
Original Author
last year
Melissa, my suspicion is that this climbing sport of JC might just be a stupid plant! the sort of rose which puts all its' vigour into growing long canes and many of them, and then just doesn't have enough energy left to flower well.Maybe with a lot of attention and spoiling it could be nice, but I don't have the time, resources, energy or inclination for that. It would be different if the colour was special,or if at any point in its' residence in my garden it had given me a moment of joy, but no, nothing. I'm glad to be rid of it, though someday I can imagine myself trying a normal JC...

Seaside, I hope you're right .However, SPS might just be getting too much competition. There's a huge General Stefanik next to it,plus a wild white hawthorn that I am trying to keep pruned so it grows as a tree. Last year I added a Cercis siliquastrum to the area and this fall, a weeping cherry. So it might also be too many Rosacaes in too small of a space. So I may move something in the fall,or remove the hawthorn, though it'd be a shame. Also, I want to see what Ariside B looks like; in the past I can't remember seeing it in bloom. So if it doesn't impress me, I may sp that. SPS HAS been great in the past, and therefore has earned my respect.

How to save a rose that is being threatened by its' root-stock

Comments (3)

seasiderooftop

Melissa Northern Italy zone 8

Related Discussions

bart bart
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

How to save a rose that is being threatened by its' root-stock

Comments (3)

seasiderooftop

Melissa Northern Italy zone 8

Related Discussions

bart bartOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

bart bart
Original Author